AI summary by TwinMind
Travelling to the Stars by Ladder - Numberphile
Numberphile
23m 23s
Book Introduction and Setup
- Story: "Mole Star" by Britta Teckentrup - children's book being read to Brady's baby son
- Plot: Mole looks at stars, wishes to own them all, gets magical ladders to collect stars
- Analysis focus: Examining physical feasibility of mole's star collection plan
Star Visibility and Quantity Analysis
- Moles are nearly blind - questionable if they can see stars
- Observable universe contains ~200 billion trillion stars (100-400 billion per galaxy, ~2 trillion galaxies)
- Human-visible stars: ~5,000 stars up to magnitude 6 brightness
- Analysis assumes mole collects only human-visible stars (5,000 total)
Ladder Construction Requirements
- Total distance to all visible stars: 786 million light years of ladder needed
- Balsa wood option:
- Density: 0.1 g/cm³, minimum diameter: 0.2 cm
- Total mass needed: 99.9 × 10²¹ kg (10,000 billion billion kg)
- Earth's mass: 6 × 10²⁴ kg - ladders would weigh ~1000x less than Earth
- Problem: Earth's carbon supply only 1.85 × 10²¹ kg - insufficient by factor of ~5
- Carbon fiber alternative:
- Density: 2 g/cm³, diameter: 0.001 cm (much thinner)
- Total mass: 3.5 × 10¹⁸ kg (3.5 million trillion kg)
- Within Earth's total carbon supply but exceeds surface carbon (4.35 × 10¹⁶ kg)
- Would require deep Earth core carbon extraction
Travel Time Calculations
- Mole speed: 6 km/hour
- Time to collect all stars at mole speed: 280,000 trillion years (2.8 × 10¹⁷ years)
- Much longer than star lifespans (~10 billion years) - stars would die before collection
- Spacecraft alternatives:
- Apollo 10 (40,000 km/h): 43 trillion years
- Juno spacecraft (365,000 km/h): 4.6 trillion years - still too long
Relativistic Travel Solution
- Mole must travel within 1 billionth of 1 billionth of speed of light
- At 0.9999... speed of light: journey takes 2 years 4 months in mole's reference frame
- Earth observers would wait 1.6 billion years
- Trip to Alpha Centauri would take ~0.3 seconds for mole
- Within mole lifespan (3-6 years)
Black Hole Formation Problem
- Mole's burrow dimensions: 5 cm wide × 4 cm high × 70 m long = 0.14 m³
- Total stellar mass: 20,175 solar masses
- Schwarzschild radius for this mass: 59,000 km
- Cannot compress this mass into space smaller than 59,000 km radius without forming black hole
- Earth radius only 6,000 km - would create black hole destroying Earth
Black Hole Evaporation Timeline
- Black hole evaporation time via Hawking radiation: 10⁸⁰ years
- Coincidentally equals number of particles in observable universe
- Mole would emerge as Hawking radiation, not as living mole
- Universe at that time: black hole dominated era (10⁴⁰ to 10¹⁰⁰ years)
Poincaré Recurrence Theory
- Only way to restore original star configuration: wait for Poincaré recurrence
- Finite universe systems eventually return to initial states
- Timeline: 10^(10¹²²) years - vastly exceeds any reasonable timespan
- Universe would cycle through all possible configurations before returning to original
Story Conclusion Analysis
- Book shows mole returning stars after realizing others need them too
- Physically impossible given black hole formation and timescales involved
- New ladders would require additional carbon sources beyond Earth
Promotional Content
- Jane Street puzzle: place 2 stars per row/column/section with no adjacent stars
- Book recommendation: "Fantastic Numbers and Where to Find Them" - covers large numbers including googol, googolplex, Graham's number, Tree(3)
