AI summary by TwinMind

Trebor Scholz: Stuck in the gig economy? Try platform co-ops instead | TED

TED

12m 59s

Introduction to Platform Cooperatives Through Up and Go Case Study

  • Esmeralda Flores: home cleaner in NYC using tech platform app
  • Earns $25/hour (2x previous company wage) - living wage
  • No algorithmic boss changing pay/hours - provides stability
  • Weekly worker meetings decide company operations
  • Receives training in finance, management, conflict resolution
  • Up and Go = platform cooperative where workers share governance and ownership
  • Workers decide wages, benefits, customer charges
  • Truly democratic workplace

Traditional Tech Platform Problems vs Platform Co-op Solutions

  • Tech platforms deny living wages, organizing rights
  • Expand economic inequality
  • Traditional platforms take 25-50% commission (exorbitant for immigrants who make up majority of gig workforce)
  • Up and Go workers decided 5% commission for platform operations/credit card bills
  • 95% goes directly to workers
  • No fiduciary duty to shareholders to maximize profit

Cooperative Model Foundation and History

  • Co-ops = group with shared need coming together to address it
  • Shared ownership and democratic governance
  • Consumer co-ops exist since 1844 (textile weavers in north England)
    • Pay cut in half, families starving
    • Sold oatmeal, sugar, flour through cooperative store
  • Modern examples: Land O'Lakes, Ocean Spray
  • Platform co-ops combine 200-year-old cooperative model with digital platform model

Platform Cooperative Characteristics

  • Equal vote in decision-making for all members
  • Shared decision process on:
    • Customer charges
    • Worker pay
    • Data collection and sales
  • Scaling equality approach
  • Cleaning industry has 75% annual turnover
  • Esmeralda with Up and Go 3 years (almost since beginning)
  • Shared ownership includes intellectual property of software
  • Can create social franchise networks to compete against large tech companies

Diversity and Access Benefits

  • Up and Go mostly Latin American immigrants
  • Traditional VC funding for minority-women-led founder teams: single percentile success rate
  • Platform co-ops enable diversity in tech founders that wouldn't otherwise access funding

Global Platform Cooperative Movement

  • Hundreds of platform co-ops worldwide
  • More resilient in crisis, more productive, retain workers longer, often pay better
  • Platform Cooperativism Consortium at The New School NYC
  • Supporting 500 projects/businesses in 30+ countries

Specific Examples

Co-op Ride

  • Driver-owned taxi platform with 3,500 drivers
  • Drivers make 10-30% more than large ride-hailing platforms
  • Passengers pay 5% less
  • Already one of largest worker cooperatives in US

Fairbnb

  • Community-focused short-term rental alternative
  • Available in 120 cities/villages with 4,500+ hosts
  • Half commission goes to community projects
  • Example: food-distribution center in Genoa, Italy

Operational Structure

  • Hire management and tech workers like traditional companies
  • Key difference: operational rules decided by all members
  • Management executes collectively-decided rules

Sector Applications Beyond Labor

  • Transportation, mobility, short-term rental
  • Care sector, culture/arts, higher education, data economy
  • Cooperative data trusts concept
  • Social media cooperative where users own platform and decide data usage
  • No fiduciary duty to maximize profits allows privacy/transparency focus

Scaling Model Differences

  • Up and Go sales increased 97% from 2018-2019
  • Don't scale like traditional Silicon Valley companies
  • Not about going public or maximizing profits
  • Scale by creating networks of companies competing against large corporations
  • Scale more quickly through global co-op networks
  • Scale democracy through decentralized crypto networks/blockchain

Call to Action

  • Teach model in law schools and business schools
  • Entrepreneurs start platform co-ops instead of traditional tech platforms
  • Incubators include this model
  • Unions start platform cooperatives
  • Ethical social impact investors consider for equality legacy

Economic Diversity Conclusion

  • Not claiming to eradicate economic inequality forever
  • Need more variety in economy: small unionized private businesses, employee ownership
  • When markets fail and government safety nets break down, people cooperate
  • Examples: food cooperatives during crisis, platform co-ops for living wages
  • Historical examples addressing structural racism/inequality: Black Panthers Free Breakfast Program, AFL-CIO
  • Democracy spreading from countries to workplace

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome