Summary by TwinMind · 12m 59s
Summary by TwinMind · 12m 59s

Trebor Scholz: Stuck in the gig economy? Try platform co-ops instead | TED

Trebor Scholz: Stuck in the gig economy? Try platform co-ops instead | TED

TED

TED

Introduction to Platform Cooperatives Through Up and Go Case Study

  • Esmeralda Flores: home cleaner in NYC using tech platform app
  • Earns $25/hour (2x previous company wage) - living wage
  • No algorithmic boss changing pay/hours - provides stability
  • Weekly worker meetings decide company operations
  • Receives training in finance, management, conflict resolution
  • Up and Go = platform cooperative where workers share governance and ownership
  • Workers decide wages, benefits, customer charges
  • Truly democratic workplace

Traditional Tech Platform Problems vs Platform Co-op Solutions

  • Tech platforms deny living wages, organizing rights
  • Expand economic inequality
  • Traditional platforms take 25-50% commission (exorbitant for immigrants who make up majority of gig workforce)
  • Up and Go workers decided 5% commission for platform operations/credit card bills
  • 95% goes directly to workers
  • No fiduciary duty to shareholders to maximize profit

Cooperative Model Foundation and History

  • Co-ops = group with shared need coming together to address it
  • Shared ownership and democratic governance
  • Consumer co-ops exist since 1844 (textile weavers in north England)
    • Pay cut in half, families starving
    • Sold oatmeal, sugar, flour through cooperative store
  • Modern examples: Land O'Lakes, Ocean Spray
  • Platform co-ops combine 200-year-old cooperative model with digital platform model

Platform Cooperative Characteristics

  • Equal vote in decision-making for all members
  • Shared decision process on:
    • Customer charges
    • Worker pay
    • Data collection and sales
  • Scaling equality approach
  • Cleaning industry has 75% annual turnover
  • Esmeralda with Up and Go 3 years (almost since beginning)
  • Shared ownership includes intellectual property of software
  • Can create social franchise networks to compete against large tech companies

Diversity and Access Benefits

  • Up and Go mostly Latin American immigrants
  • Traditional VC funding for minority-women-led founder teams: single percentile success rate
  • Platform co-ops enable diversity in tech founders that wouldn't otherwise access funding

Global Platform Cooperative Movement

  • Hundreds of platform co-ops worldwide
  • More resilient in crisis, more productive, retain workers longer, often pay better
  • Platform Cooperativism Consortium at The New School NYC
  • Supporting 500 projects/businesses in 30+ countries

Specific Examples

Co-op Ride

  • Driver-owned taxi platform with 3,500 drivers
  • Drivers make 10-30% more than large ride-hailing platforms
  • Passengers pay 5% less
  • Already one of largest worker cooperatives in US

Fairbnb

  • Community-focused short-term rental alternative
  • Available in 120 cities/villages with 4,500+ hosts
  • Half commission goes to community projects
  • Example: food-distribution center in Genoa, Italy

Operational Structure

  • Hire management and tech workers like traditional companies
  • Key difference: operational rules decided by all members
  • Management executes collectively-decided rules

Sector Applications Beyond Labor

  • Transportation, mobility, short-term rental
  • Care sector, culture/arts, higher education, data economy
  • Cooperative data trusts concept
  • Social media cooperative where users own platform and decide data usage
  • No fiduciary duty to maximize profits allows privacy/transparency focus

Scaling Model Differences

  • Up and Go sales increased 97% from 2018-2019
  • Don't scale like traditional Silicon Valley companies
  • Not about going public or maximizing profits
  • Scale by creating networks of companies competing against large corporations
  • Scale more quickly through global co-op networks
  • Scale democracy through decentralized crypto networks/blockchain

Call to Action

  • Teach model in law schools and business schools
  • Entrepreneurs start platform co-ops instead of traditional tech platforms
  • Incubators include this model
  • Unions start platform cooperatives
  • Ethical social impact investors consider for equality legacy

Economic Diversity Conclusion

  • Not claiming to eradicate economic inequality forever
  • Need more variety in economy: small unionized private businesses, employee ownership
  • When markets fail and government safety nets break down, people cooperate
  • Examples: food cooperatives during crisis, platform co-ops for living wages
  • Historical examples addressing structural racism/inequality: Black Panthers Free Breakfast Program, AFL-CIO
  • Democracy spreading from countries to workplace