AI summary by TwinMind
Unbundling IBM Freed the Software Industry
Asianometry
17m 43s
Early Software Industry Origins (1950s-1960s)
- Companies got software through three main ways in early computing era
- Develop in-house with small teams (ENIAC: 6 women programmers; IBM FORTRAN: 10 people)
- Cooperative sharing through organizations like SHARE (1955)
- Founded by Rand Corporation, Lockheed Aircraft, North American Aviation
- Collaboration on scientific applications for IBM 704 computer
- IBM 704: 12,000 floating point operations/second, incompatible with 701
- Hardware maker libraries (IBM's Consolidated Functions Ordinary 1962/62 CFO)
- Designed for IBM 1401 tape computer
- Set of applications for life insurance billing/accounting
- Customers adapted procedures to fit software package
Early Software Companies Formation
- Computer Usage Company (CUC) - first acknowledged software company (1955)
- Founded by pair of IBM programmers
- Went public 1960, used IPO proceeds to acquire own computer
- Applied Data Research (ADR) - founded by 7 Sperry Rand programmers
- First "software product company" selling packages
- RCA quoted $25,000 for flowchart program, turned down
- Created AutoFlow - first commercial software package
- Developed Version Control System "Librarian"
- Most early companies: 1-2 person shops selling services to former employers
- Required minimal startup: notepad, pencil, rented computer time
IBM's Bundling Strategy
- IBM rented computers monthly as complete solution bundles
- Included free learning materials, classes, engineering/maintenance
- System engineers provided as advisers
- Policy: "do whatever it takes to get customer using computer"
- Bundle costs hidden in rental pricing - customers paid through monthly fees
- Created expectation of free software among customers
- Suppressed competition by controlling data processing offering prices
- "Extra shift" charges for multi-day computer usage
- Front-loaded customer costs, later substantial profits
- Profits funded new customer acquisition/onboarding
System 360 Launch and Competitive Response (1964)
- IBM System 360: third generation computer line replacing jumble of older systems
- Development since 1961, most ambitious IBM product
- Range of 6 computers spanning low to high end
- Key feature: scalability with same operating system/interface
- Software written for any 360 worked on all models
- Financial impact: IBM generated $2.5 billion rental income (1966)
- Competitors (CDC, GE, Honeywell) combined: $500 million
- RCA Spectra 70 response
- Claimed compatibility with System 360 applications
- Threat: customers could switch to RCA, keep IBM software
- Reality: compatibility claims proved false
Internal IBM Unbundling Debates
- By late 1960s: 1/3 of IBM R&D costs spent on software development
- Arguments for unbundling:
- Selling software seen as massive opportunity
- Software development costs becoming unsustainable
- Arguments against (1965 memo):
- "Single combined price" was "greatest competitive advantage"
- Unbundling would multiply areas susceptible to competition
- Would increase number of hardware/service competitors
- Would result in business loss from higher prices/increased competition
- Legal protection concerns: patents, trade secrets, copyright, licensing - no great options
Antitrust Pressure and Legal Challenges
- IBM knew bundling looked like illegal tie-in sales under Sherman Antitrust Act
- Early as 1965: expected government would declare bundling illegal
- December 1968: CDC sued IBM over market practices including bundling
- 5-year lawsuit over bundling and "ghost computers" (System 360 Model 92)
- Successful attempt to block CDC sales
- Rumors of DOJ investigation into possible lawsuit
- IBM felt unlikely to win antitrust challenges
The Unbundling Decision (1968-1969)
- December 6, 1968: IBM announced vague "changes in charging for data processing equipment"
- June 23, 1969: Official unbundling announcement
- Separate pricing for system engineering services, hardware, software
- New pricing effective 1970
- Customer expectations: 25% hardware price cuts
- Reality: 3% discount (based on 4,000 programmers out of 130,000 employees)
- Popular response: skeptical about paying for previously "free" software
Software Industry Explosion Post-Unbundling
- Number of software companies exploded after 1969
- Insurance software market examples:
- Cybertech Computer Products (employed original 62 CFO programmer)
- TRW Computing Corporation (1969 startup)
- Initially extended 62 CFO functionality
- Later provided entirely new services like underwriting automation
- 1972 industry survey: 81 vendors, over 275 software packages
Government Antitrust Case
- January 1969: DOJ filed United States vs IBM lawsuit (days before LBJ left office)
- Trial statistics:
- 860 deposition witnesses
- 14,400 pages of transcript
- $50-100 million cost for both parties
- Called "antitrust division's Vietnam"
- After 13 years: US government dropped lawsuit
- Impact: threat removed "heavy lid" on growing software industry ready to compete globally
