AI summary by TwinMind

Understanding Quantum Mechanics #6: It's not just a theory for small things

Sabine Hossenfelder

8m 3s

Common Misconception About Quantum Mechanics Scale

  • Most people think quantum mechanics only applies to small things/short distances
    • Atomic spectral lines, electrons through double slits, nuclear decay
    • Belief: big things behave normally, small things show quantum weirdness
  • Misconception understandable since we don't experience quantum effects daily
  • Reality: quantum mechanics applies to everything regardless of size

Large-Scale Quantum Examples

  • The Sun: shines via nuclear fusion requiring quantum tunneling
    • Must fuse two positively charged nuclei that repel each other
    • Without tunneling, fusion wouldn't work
    • Sun definitely not small
  • All Matter Around Us: exists only because of quantum mechanics
    • Without quantum mechanics, atoms wouldn't exist
    • Classic problem: electrons circling nucleus should emit electromagnetic radiation, lose energy, fall into nucleus quickly
    • Atoms would be unstable without quantum mechanics

Quantum Explanation of Atomic Stability

  • Electrons not particles localized at specific points
  • Described by wave-functions showing probability of electron location
  • Probability distribution focused on shells around nucleus
  • Shells correspond to different energy levels/"orbitals"
  • Misleading term: electrons not actually orbiting in loops

Planetary vs Atomic Orbits Comparison

  • Planets do emit radiation and fall into sun
    • Gravitational force (not electromagnetic) causes gravitational waves
    • Gravitational waves carry away energy, gradually shrink orbital radius
    • Gravitational force much weaker than electromagnetic force
    • Effect extremely small, doesn't noticeably affect planetary orbits
  • Observable in binary star systems
    • Two stars circling at short distance
    • Energy loss from gravitational radiation causes spiral into each other
    • Gravitational waves first indirectly confirmed this way
    • Nobel Prize awarded 1993

Planetary Orbit Quantization

  • Planetary orbits are quantized like electron orbits
  • For large objects: shells so close together, gaps unmeasurably small
  • Wave-function of planets very well localized
  • Excellent approximation to treat planets as balls/points moving on curves
  • For electrons in atoms: this approximation terribly bad

Laser Technology as Quantum Evidence

  • Lasers work by pumping energy into crystal/gas
  • Creates "population inversion" - electrons mostly in unstable energy levels
  • Electron drops to stable state, emits photon
  • Photon causes another electron to drop ("stimulated emission")
  • Mirrors around crystal/gas amplify signal
  • Light emitted is coherent and strongly focused
  • Requires quantized atomic energy levels to function

Long-Distance Quantum Effects: Zeilinger's Experiments

  • Anton Zeilinger famous for many quantum experiments
  • 2008 Canary Islands experiment: entanglement over 144 kilometers
    • Produced entangled photon pairs on La Palma
    • Sent one photon to Tenerife (144 km away)
    • Other photon circled in optical fiber on La Palma
    • Measured polarization on both photons
    • Unambiguously demonstrated persistent entanglement
  • Proves quantum mechanics not theory for short distances only

Why Quantum Effects Seem Limited to Small Objects

  • Weird quantum stuff (entanglement, uncertainty, wave-particle duality) really tiny for big/warm objects
  • Physicist definitions: "warm" = few degrees above absolute zero, "big" = exceeding molecule size
  • Decoherence ruins quantum effects for big/warm objects
    • Frequent interactions with environment (air, radiation)
    • Can slow decoherence by controlling environment closely
    • Keep objects cool and in ultra-high vacuum

Large-Scale Quantum Demonstrations

  • Big molecules showing quantum behavior
    • Current record: ~2000 atoms (~40,000 protons, neutrons, electrons)
  • Bose Einstein Condensates
    • Clouds of atoms cooled to very low temperature
    • Combine to one coherent state with quantum effects throughout
    • Current record: few hundred million atoms

Fundamental Principle

  • No limit in size/weight/distance where quantum effects suddenly stop
  • Everything has quantum effects, including humans
  • Effects so small for large objects that they're unnoticeable

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome