AI summary by TwinMind
Unit 11: LNG Case 3, Video 4: Learning effects
MIT OpenCourseWare
8m 39s
Facility Relocation and Transportation Cost Analysis
- Explored possibility of relocating industrial facilities to distant locations to avoid dispatch/transport costs
- Solution: move to most distant place, transfer gas via pipeline instead of tanker trucks for finished products
- Pipeline solution could save money and increased expected value by 10% in analyzed case
- Trade-off identified: pipeline investment required upfront capital even if not fully utilized
Cost-Benefit Analysis of Pipeline Investment
- Pipeline flexibility required upfront investment creating potential disadvantage
- When pipeline invested but underutilized, extra costs reduced expected value from ~11 to 8-9 range
- Significant impact across operational range, but high demand scenarios very profitable
- Red line vs green line comparison showed no uniformly better option
- Flexibility investment has costs similar to insurance - pay premium for protection
Risk and Value Improvements
- Flexible design (with/without move) increased not just expected value but other measures
- Value at Risk improved 2-3x compared to fixed design
- Fixed design: 10% VaR of 1.8
- Flexible design: increased to 4-5 range
- Upside potential showed considerable improvements
- Changes affected entire distribution, not just averages - reduced risk while increasing opportunities
Learning Rates Impact Analysis
- Parametric study examined different learning rate scenarios (0% to various rates)
- Trade-off between economies of scale and learning effects
- Later modules cheaper than earlier ones as learning occurs, decreasing overall expansion costs
- Learning counterbalances economies of scale, increases discount rate effects
- Future construction becomes less expensive due to learning
Learning Rate Value Impact
- No move analysis: changing learning rates pushed maximum value to far end of curve
- High demand + future builds at cheap prices = tremendous advantages
- Expected value increase: ~20 to ~50 with learning rates (specific numbers not case-backed)
- Even modest 5% learning rate showed significant leverage: 20 to 28 expected value change
- Effect most powerful for low unit production (single units 1-5, not mass production like cars)
BP Case Study Example
- BP built 3 identical platforms in Caspian Sea near Azerbaijan
- Departure from traditional bespoke/tailor-made approach for different sites
- Contract disputes led to identical unit construction
- Reported ~40% savings in labor costs
- Workers knew what to expect, better scheduling, improved assembly order
- Learning curve effect similar to camping tent setup - dramatic improvement from first to subsequent attempts
Key Insights
- Repetition of modules promotes learning, most impactful for initial replications
- Learning can increase value significantly
- Modular repetition vs customization trade-offs crucial for project economics
