AI summary by TwinMind
Unit 11: LNG Case 4, Video 5: Final Analysis
MIT OpenCourseWare
5m 28s
Design Comparison Analysis
- Evaluated various design options: fixed design vs flexible design with move/no-move options
- Assessed designs under multiple criteria:
- Expected value
- Downward risk
- Upward risk
- Standard deviation
- Capital expenditure (initial capex)
- Highlighted best solutions according to each criteria in bold
- Flexible designs generally performed best across most criteria
Capital Expenditure Considerations
- Initial capex particularly significant - what you put down upfront
- Once built and operational, investors gain confidence and more willing to invest additional money
- Reducing initial capex can be very important for project viability
- After construction, risk assessment becomes clearer
Standard Deviation Exception
- One exception to flexible design superiority: standard deviation criteria
- Fixed designs often have less variance in possible returns
- Flexible designs expand boundaries and push out standard deviation
- Robust designs (small standard deviations) can be worst economically
- Illustrates tension: robust designs important for precision applications (steel axles to railroad wheels, signal tuning)
- For flexibility projects: want to maximize best possibilities, increase high return potential
- Operating against notion of smallest standard deviation when pursuing flexibility
Economies of Scale vs Learning Effects
- Analyzed scale factor from high alpha (no economy of scale) to lowest economy of scale
- Examined various learning rates and flexibility value
- Key relationships:
- As economies of scale decrease → flexibility becomes more valuable
- High economies of scale → flexibility benefits diminish or disappear
- As learning increases → flexibility becomes better
- Less aggressive economy of scale + more learning = better outcomes
- Sweet spot exists: some learning + not too heavy economy of scale
Key Takeaways from LNG Case
- Flexible design can provide clear economic benefits
- Benefits driven by:
- Discount rate effects
- Learning effects
- Building on modular designs
- Modular designs mitigate economy of scale disadvantages
- Actual expected value of compact project under uncertainty < deterministic estimation
- Analysis demonstrates plausible scenarios where flexible design advantageous
