AI summary by TwinMind
Unit 5: Mechanics of Simulation, Video 6: Simulation and Value Flexibility "on" Project
MIT OpenCourseWare
9m 33s
Bidding Process Structure
- Two-stage bidding process with development penalties
- Big penalty if company kept site without developing it
- Peru wanted to prevent large copper companies from acquiring then delaying development
- Companies might use other assets first, delay this project until convenient
- Peru needed jobs, exports, investment immediately
- Timeline requirements:
- Phase 1: 2 years to explore geology, topography, access, technical aspects
- Phase 2: Must spend 3 years developing project before getting profits
- Flexibility: Could walk away after exploration phase or commit to development
- After development: Produce metal as long as ore lasts
NPV Analysis Components
- Multiple uncertainty factors affecting NPV:
- Ore quality and quantity (2% copper vs 1% copper, other associated materials)
- Mining costs
- Metal prices after extraction and market delivery
- Copper price distributions
- Data requirements:
- Technical cost model estimates (factory/plant/smelter operations)
- 25-year market data projections based on historical data
- Expert judgment from test drilling
- Drilling costs: ~$1 million per drill hole (thousands of feet through rock)
Mine Parameters and Assumptions
- Mine life: 20 years
- Rationale: At discount rates used, value beyond 20 years minimal given other uncertainties
- Could have calculated longer but deemed not worthwhile
- Price modeling: Zinc and copper prices via stochastic process and lattice analysis
- All parameters modeled using probabilistic distributions and Monte Carlo simulations
Historical Copper Price Context
- Major price jump occurred due to China's massive infrastructure commitment
- Cities, apartment buildings, railroads requiring extensive copper for electrical wire
- Created huge demand surge with clear before/after price levels
- Question remains whether elevated prices will persist long-term
Simulation Methodology
- Monte Carlo simulation with 2000+ iterations
- Drew from various probability distributions for all uncertainty factors
- Calculated NPV distribution for each scenario
- Repeated process to generate comprehensive NPV distribution
Results Without Flexibility
- Mean NPV: $500 million
- Potential loss: Up to $1 billion
- Potential gain: Up to $3-4 billion
- Assessment: Very risky investment without flexibility option
Results With Flexibility (Abandon Option)
- Walk-away option: If project looks unprofitable after 2-year exploration, abandon
- Only positive outcomes considered (negative scenarios eliminated by walking away)
- NPV with flexibility: $800 million
- Flexibility value calculation: $819 million - $550 million = $269 million
- One-time abandon decision: No multiple exit opportunities
Strategic Implications
- Flexibility to abandon worth ~$269 million (quarter billion)
- Bidding strategy must consider competition and flexibility value
- Real options analysis demonstrates significant value of managerial flexibility
