AI summary by TwinMind
Unit 7: Drivers of Flexibility, Video 3: Discount rate and Learning Promote
MIT OpenCourseWare
10m 31s
Capacity Planning Strategies
- Two main approaches for growing demand (e.g., electricity):
- Choice A: Build large plant now for 20+ years ahead
- Based on economies of scale
- Example: Father's experience with India steel mills 30-40 years ago - pressure to build big, efficient plants
- Choice B: Build small now, add smaller units later as market grows
- Phase capacity according to market growth
- Key advantage: defer costs until needed
- Choice A: Build large plant now for 20+ years ahead
Discount Rate Impact on Investment Timing
- Building capacity when needed vs. all upfront creates cost advantages
- Example calculation:
- If discount rate = 10% or 8%
- Plant built 3 years later costs same 100 units nominally
- Present value discounted over 3 years = ~30% less (10% rate) or ~25% less (8% rate)
- Key principle: Deferring costs counterbalances economies of scale advantages
- Discount rate counterbalances economy of scale benefits
Engineering vs Economic Design Considerations
- Many engineering designs focus on technical optimization
- Don't factor in economic considerations adequately
- Ask "what's cheapest way to provide capacity" without considering timing economics
- References MIT homework assignment with specific numbers demonstrating this principle
- Economy of scale often not optimal from pure economic/productivity basis
Learning Effects
- Definition: Production of more units → lower unit cost per unit
- Camping tent analogy: First assembly takes long time, 10-15th time much faster due to learning
- Common industrial analysis: Compare costs of producing units (ships, cars, oil platforms)
- Cost of 1st design vs 2nd vs 3rd, etc.
- BP Azerbaijan case study:
- Standard practice: bespoke designs for each location/water depth
- Changed to 3 identical platform copies
- Result: Huge savings through learning
- Teams learned better sequencing of labor/materials, timing, assembly methods
- Learning includes both actual learning + design improvements/tweaks
- Makes future modular investments cheaper
- Adds to discount rate importance by reducing future costs
Competitive Gaming Strategy
- Sometimes important to make advance commitments as competitor signals
- Cortez Mexico example:
- Deliberately burned ships after landing
- Signal: "I'm committed, can't go back"
- Message to local allies: "I'll stay to support you against Aztec rulers"
- Morocco phosphate company example:
- Committed to add production capacity
- Signal to competitors: "We intend to be dominant world producers"
- Message: "If you build competing capacity, you'll lose - we'll be bigger, cheaper"
- Key principle: Eliminating flexibility can be strategic advantage
Framework Summary: Drivers For/Against Flexibility
- For flexibility: Uncertainty
- Against flexibility:
- Economies of scale
- Discount rate effects
- Learning effects
- Competitive gaming
- Conclusion: No single answer - must calculate and explore specific situations
- Multiple considerations must be weighed, not automatic rules
