AI summary by TwinMind

Used Golf Balls (Replay) | The Economics of Everyday Things

Freakonomics Radio Network

17m 14s

Golf Ball Loss Statistics and Market Overview

  • 25+ million Americans golf annually
  • Average golfer loses 4-5 balls per round
    • Bad players lose more, good players lose fewer
    • Lesan Wanigatunga (struggling golfer) loses ~6 balls per round
  • US golfers lose 300 million golf balls annually
    • If laid end-to-end would stretch NYC to Hong Kong
  • Used golf ball market estimated at $200 million industry

New Golf Ball Pricing and Performance

  • Low-end golf balls: $20/dozen
  • High-end tour performance balls (Pro V1, Callaway Chrome Soft, TaylorMade TP5): $50/dozen average
    • Individual premium balls cost $4-5 each
  • Tournament search time limit: 3 minutes
  • Casual play: until playing partners complain
  • Etiquette: move on even for $5 ball

Historical Development of Used Ball Market

  • Early 1900s: "Ball hawks" trained dogs to find balls
    • Sold for 10 cents each at clubhouses
    • Seen as petty thieves without course permission
  • Market transformation early 2000s:
    • Internet/e-commerce advent
    • Improved golf ball technology
    • Titleist Pro V1 launch changed industry
      • Solid core construction, urethane coating
      • More consistent and durable
      • Competitors followed with better materials/technology
      • Improved cover insulation = longer-lasting performance underwater

Major Market Players

  • PG Golf (largest company)
    • Sells 50 million used balls annually
    • Website: lostgolfballs.com
    • Owned by same conglomerate as Titleist
    • Sells same balls repeatedly
  • Smaller companies: Golf Ball Planet, Golf Ball Monkey, Golf Ball Nut
  • Two Guys with Balls (Lesan Wanigatunga's company)
    • Started 7 years ago in neighbor's garage
    • Simple website operation

Golf Ball Recovery Operations

Ball Hawker Company (Todd Hutchinson)

  • 20+ years tobacco industry executive turned golf ball entrepreneur
  • 70 golf course contracts in Florida
  • 2-year exclusive agreements with courses
  • Pays courses 12 cents per ball
  • Courses motivated more by cleanup service than money
    • Members pay $1 million+ just to join
  • Visits each course 3-4 times annually
  • Collects 20,000-40,000 balls per visit

Collection Methods and Locations

  • Open areas: woods, preserves, rough
  • Water hazards (primary source)
    • Right-handed golfers = balls tend right
    • Lakes on right side = higher ball concentrations
  • Some companies use tractors for water recovery
  • Most use freelance divers

Professional Golf Ball Diving

Working Conditions

  • Blind diving in murky water
  • Zero visibility once bottom disturbed
  • 8-10 hours daily work
  • Hooked to floating oxygen tanks (hookas)
  • 2-minute dives yield ~300 balls each
  • Good day: 7,000 balls recovered = $800 earnings
  • Full-time divers can earn six figures annually

Safety Hazards

  • At least 6 divers died in recent years retrieving golf balls
  • William Reyerson drowned at Ponte Vedra Inn & Club (2021)
  • Ball Hawker fined $56,000 by OSHA for safety violations
  • Now employs full-time land monitor
  • Threats: snakes, alligators, zero visibility
  • Safety equipment: paintball guns to scare alligators

Items Found Besides Golf Balls

  • Cell phones, umbrellas, old dial phones, bongs
  • Golf clubs (frequent finds)
  • Clothing still on hangers (domestic disputes)
  • General trash cleanup service

Processing and Sales

Cleaning and Sorting

  • Potato washer processes 4,000 balls in 5 minutes
  • 12 rollers with brushes
  • Sorted by brand and model
    • Each brand has up to 20 different models
  • 10,000+ custom balls saved (pictures, comments, bachelor parties)
  • Categorized by condition

Pricing Structure

  • Ball Hawker pays divers 10-12 cents per ball
  • High-end balls (Pro V1s) sell for ~$2 each online
    • ~50% of new ball price
  • Top-end balls: $60/dozen new vs $30/dozen used
  • Revenue: $400,000 per million top-end balls sold
  • Only 20% of recovered balls in flawless condition

Wholesale and Retail Operations

Two Guys with Balls Business Model

  • Bypasses diving/cleaning/sorting
  • Buys pre-processed balls in bulk
  • Pays 15 cents to $1.25 per ball (top quality Pro V1)
  • 50% profit margin on website sales
  • Win-win: affordable alternative for golfers

Nighthawks (Unauthorized Collectors)

  • Hunt balls without course permission
  • Hobby/side hustle operation
  • Play golf without buying new balls
  • Donate extras to junior golf programs
  • Cottage industry: special glasses, flashlights, binoculars
  • Often work with legitimate companies
  • Bring 10,000+ balls to companies like Ball Hawker

Performance and Environmental Impact

Ball Performance Studies

  • Informal experiments show used balls don't impact golfer performance
  • Some golfers remain skeptical of used ball performance
  • Perception: water exposure affects performance

Environmental Benefits

  • Golf balls don't degrade in water
  • Sustainable reuse/recycling
  • Balls go through multiple cycles: sold → lost → retrieved → resold
  • Same balls potentially sold multiple times to same customers

Industry Perspective

  • Todd Hutchinson: "Like Easter egg hunting"
  • Manufacturing companies dislike used ball competition
  • $60 new vs $30 used creates significant market disruption

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome