AI summary by TwinMind
We Built A Lie-Detector Skeleton From 1927
Tom Scott
7m 51s
Video Introduction & Context
- Video sponsored by CuriosityStream and Nebula original
- Filmed September 2020 following UK COVID-19 filming regulations
- Wide shot format due to safety protocols
Historical Background - Helen Adelaide Shelby Patent
- 1927: Helen Adelaide Shelby (Oakland, California) applied for patent
- Patent: "Apparatus for obtaining criminal confessions and photographically recording them"
- Essentially a lie detector for cases where suspect guilt was known but unprovable
- Device was never built or used until this experiment
- Modern updates: contemporary camera instead of bulky reel-to-reel film
- Built by Charles Arnold, staying true to original patent design
Experiment Setup
- Participants: Daniel, Tom, Chloe
- Test scenario: Cookie theft from table
- Host left room, one person stole cookie
- All participants obtained water bottles after incident
- Initial questioning without lie detector yielded all "no" responses
- Host suspected Daniel and Tom based on gut reaction
The Shelby Lie Detector Design
- Patent uses "very long and flowery language"
- Core mechanism: Hidden skeleton at end of box
- Curtain rises to reveal skeleton
- Designed to startle suspect with "genuine supernatural apparition"
- Interrogator asks questions from behind box in spooky voice
- Theory: Supernatural fear would compel truth confession
- Patent doesn't need to be good, just new
Testing Process & Results
Chloe's Test
- Placed in pitch-black box with infrared camera
- Reaction: Laughter, not fear
- "Oh no oh god I can read into my soul"
- Denied taking cookie
- No confession obtained
Tom's Test
- Has phobia of theme park characters
- Recognized the device from prior reading
- Initial fear: "Oh god oh geez"
- "I know what this is I am so upset"
- Denied taking cookie despite skeleton
- Called skeleton "surprisingly hospitable"
- No confession obtained
Daniel's Test
- Most dramatic reaction: "Full-on yell of terror"
- "Oh my god I hate every second of this"
- Denied taking cookie
- Fear subsided once skeleton appeared
- "It was a lot scarier before the skull showed up"
- No confession obtained
Experiment Conclusion
- Lie detector completely ineffective
- Actual truth: Daniel and Chloe split the cookie
- Host's initial guess was partially correct (two people involved)
- Device failure consistent with other lie detectors
- Helen Shelby "never lived to see her invention made real"
- "Perhaps that's for the best"
Promotional Content
- Nebula original featuring 5 creators competing for real money
- Participants: Real Engineering, Technicality (Alex), Wendover Productions, MinutePhysics
- CuriosityStream subscription: $2.99/month
- Includes Nebula access with ad-free content
- 26% discount on annual plan at curiositystream.com/tomscott
