AI summary by TwinMind
We Fell For The Oldest Lie On The Internet
Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell
13m 8s
Initial Discovery of Problem
- Kurzgesagt team used popular "fun fact": blood vessels = 100,000km, enough to wrap around planet twice
- Used in book, app, video content multiple times
- Someone asked for original source - team couldn't find it
- Google searches showed 100,000km or 60,000 miles consistently across websites, books, educational institutions, scientific papers
- No sources cited original research - most had no citations at all
- Number used inconsistently: some said capillaries only, others veins+arteries, others total length
Research Process Begins
- Team felt personal responsibility since they'd used the fact themselves
- Random Google searches yielded thousands of sites quoting number but no original source
- PubMed (biomedical science papers database) searches: zero results
- Different keyword combinations: nothing found
- Found scientific papers referencing number but still no original source
- Two biology textbook authors contacted - said number circulating for decades, they'd also like to know source
1990s Sources Discovery
- Narrowed search to last few decades starting with 1990s
- Found two books:
- "Vital Circuits" by Steven Vogel
- "Looking at the Body" by David Suzuki
- Dr. David Suzuki background: OG science communicator, PhD Zoology, 1970s Canadian TV, 29 honorary degrees, 52 books
- Suzuki's book stated: 96,000km (60,000 miles), 2.5 times around world - but no source cited
Contacting Dr. Suzuki
- Team wrote formal letter requesting original source
- Response after 3 weeks: Dr. Suzuki doesn't recall source, book written 30+ years ago, no files available
- Public information coordinator wished them luck
Steven Vogel's Book Investigation
- 1992 Popular Science book by Steven Vogel (Duke University biomechanics professor)
- Quote: "combined length of pipes 100,000km (60,000 miles), more than twice around Earth at equator"
- Book had 300 pages, 93 references with no indication which reference supported which claim
- Team decided to check all 93 sources one by one
Breakthrough Discovery
- Got "stupidly lucky" - decided to check sources from last to first
- First source checked was correct one: Scientific American article from 1959 "The Microcirculation of the Blood"
- 1959 article referenced original source: "The Anatomy and Physiology of Capillaries" (1922 book by August Krogh)
- August Krogh: Nobel Prize winner for medicine
Original Source Found
- Krogh's 1922 book was collection of lectures, highly praised by experts
- Original quote: "Supposing a man's muscles to weigh 50kg and his capillaries to number 2,000 per square mm, the total length of all these tubes put together must be something like 100,000km or 2½ times around the globe"
- Total surface area: 6,300 square meters
- Krogh was first to make real estimate based on actual experiments
Analysis of Krogh's Method
- Krogh's methodology: cut muscle samples from different animals, made rule-of-thumb assumptions
- His assumptions about capillary density in humans were "quite off"
- Used idealized body build: human weighing 143kg with 50kg pure muscle mass
- Calculation was "small and silly fact" done for fun/curiosity, not central to his work
- Number spread through scientific papers, became dogma, detached from original source
Modern Correction
- During team's year-long research, scientists quietly published new paper with accurate calculation
- New estimate: capillaries in human = 9,000-19,000km
- Impressive but not enough to go around world
Broader Implications
- Most sources still show wrong number (including Kurzgesagt's own video)
- Problem persists because fact-checking is extremely hard and time-consuming
- Scientists/communicators quote secondary sources when number seems safe and credible
- "Nice round numbers" stick in memory
- Beautiful/memorable facts survive longer online
- Misinformation persists because factoids easily repeated
- Takes significant energy to verify facts properly
