AI summary by TwinMind
We Need More Sustainable Packaging, Like, Yesterday | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
50m 40s
Introduction and Context
- Josh and Chuck discuss packaging waste as environmental topic
- Episode fits with recent bottled water, littering, ultra-processed foods episodes
- Building environmental content bucket over podcast career
- Recording in 2022, addressing current packaging waste crisis
Scale of Packaging Waste Problem
- 28% of US Municipal Solid Waste is packaging/containers
- 2018 recycling rates: 54% of packaging waste recycled (up from 10% in 1960)
- Landfill waste by material:
- Plastic: 10 million tons landfilled out of 15 million total
- Wood: 7 million out of 12 million
- Aluminum: 1 million out of 2 million (50% recycling rate)
- Paper/cardboard: 5 million out of 42 million (excellent recycling rate)
- Aluminum described as "infinitely recyclable"
- Plastic waste particularly problematic due to lightweight but high volume
Historical Context of Packaging
- Pre-1800s: minimal waste, extensive reuse/recycling
- Items shipped in wooden crates, glass bottles, cloth wrapping
- People fixed broken glass with sodium silicate (water glass)
- Regular garbage pickup didn't exist until mid-1800s
- Food waste composted or fed to livestock
- 1856: corrugated cardboard invented in England for hat stiffening
- 1890: Nabisco first to sell individual packaged foods
- 1906: Kellogg's first cereal box
- 1936: steel beer cans introduced by Coors
- 1959: switch to aluminum cans
- 1963: pull-tab cans introduced
- 1965: plastic grocery bags introduced
- Late 1960s: Glad bags popularized
- 1985: plastic bags 24¢ per thousand vs paper bags 30¢ per thousand
- 1986: Plastic Grocery Sack Council promoted 17 reuses for bags
Modern Packaging Issues
- Crown Royal example: paper bag → box → velvet bag → bottle
- Binax COVID tests reduced packaging size (similar to CD longbox reduction)
- Excessive plastic clamshell packaging for tools
- Tamper-proof packaging trend started by Tylenol poisoner
- McDonald's pioneered single-use food packaging (eliminated dishwashers/waiters)
- McDonald's phased out foam packaging after 40 years
- McDLT packaging was breaking point for foam acceptance
Amazon and E-commerce Impact
- COVID increased home delivery demand significantly
- Oceana report: Amazon generated 600 million pounds plastic packaging waste (2020)
- 24 million pounds ended up in waterways/oceans
- Amazon disputes calculations but doesn't show counter-data
- Plastic film air pillows can be recycled at grocery store plastic bag collection points
- Amazon implements better packaging when legally required (India, Germany)
- Don't put plastic bags in regular recycling bins (causes processing problems)
Meal Kit Services
- Mixed environmental impact
- Up to 24 individual packages per box
- Foam insulation boxes, chemical ice packs
- Blue Apron: 85% recyclable packaging, drain-safe ice packs
- 2019 study: Blue Apron 33% less emissions than grocery store equivalent
- Reduced food waste benefit vs packaging waste concern
Sustainable Packaging Innovations
- Corn-based plastic (PLA - polylactic acid):
- Not petroleum-based
- Requires industrial composting (not backyard compostable)
- Diverts corn from food system
- Mushroom/mycelium packaging:
- Alternative to styrofoam
- Grown on agricultural refuse
- Can be shaped exactly as needed
- Scalability and 7-day production time challenges
- Algae/seaweed packaging:
- Tom Ford contest: $1M+ prize for plastic alternatives
- 5 of 8 finalists were algae/seaweed-based
- Sway company (Berkeley) grows seaweed
- Restorative to marine ecosystems
- Some varieties edible after use
- Can retain antimicrobial properties
Regulatory Solutions
- Polluter pays principle (1972): manufacturers responsible for waste costs
- Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR): lifecycle responsibility
- Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD): 10 governments have EPR legislation (US not included in 1996)
- US examples: paint recycling, used car oil return programs
- India's competitive system: recycling percentage requirements with tradeable credits
State-Level Legislation
- 2021: EPR for Packaging Network coalition
- States: California, Colorado, Hawaii, Maryland, New Hampshire, New York, Oregon, Vermont, Washington
- Maine passed fund-based system: manufacturers pay sliding scale based on recyclability
- California 2022 law (strictest in US):
- By 2032: all packaging recyclable or compostable
- 25% packaging reduction required
- 65% recycling rate requirement
- Industry must create oversight organization
Political Challenges
- Preemptive bans on plastic bag bans in multiple states
- Cost concerns: companies may pass expenses to consumers
- Political division prevents unified action
- Ballotpedia.com lists states with preemptive bans
Alternative Shopping Bags
- Cotton totes problematic: pesticides, forced labor, high environmental footprint
- One study: cotton tote needs 54 years daily use to offset environmental impact
- Anya Hindmarch designer bags:
- 2007: "I'm not a plastic bag" cotton tote
- Later: "I am a plastic bag" made from recycled plastic
- Recycled plastic bags preferred over cotton
Recycling Infrastructure
- CHARM (Center for Hard to Recycle Materials) in Atlanta
- Accepts: shredded documents, car batteries, paint cans, computers
- Similar facilities exist in most major cities
- Grocery store plastic bag collection points accept film plastics
