AI summary by TwinMind

We Need To Stop Lying About Git

Theo - t3․gg

18m 15s

Initial Controversial Statement

  • Tweet about CS graduates not knowing basic git commands being "astounding"
  • Expected lukewarm reception but generated significant backlash
  • Audience poll: 1 (not spicy), 2 (spicy), 3 (should be canceled) - mostly 1s with sarcastic 3s

Personal Git Experience & Context

  • Started using git before learning to code for Minecraft server file management
  • Only had one incident in 15-year career where deleted uncommitted code
  • Witnessed classmates' fear when deleting code without version control
  • School friends asking "what's a commit?" when code was deleted

CS Degree Purpose Clarification

  • CS degrees exist primarily for programming jobs (95% of graduates)
  • Only alternatives: coding jobs or research/education
  • Degrees existing solely for academia are "perpetually self-fulfilling prophecy"
  • Universities market CS degrees for coding job preparation
  • Personal experience at RPI: engineering school but CS in science department
    • Required bio instead of circuits due to science major classification

University Git Exposure Examples

  • RPI had awesome open source program requiring git usage
  • Taught many students git, witnessed terrible practices
  • One student insisted on UI-only git usage:
    • Coded algorithms in Python
    • Added random numbers to filenames
    • Drag-and-dropped files to GitHub via web interface
  • This behavior described as "begrudgingly dragging heels" rather than using git

Curriculum Integration Suggestions

  • Not advocating dedicated git courses or semester-long classes
  • Proposed solution: require git for homework submission
    • Custom git server at school
    • Two-page PDF instruction
    • No git submission = failing grade
  • Make it prerequisite for completing assignments
  • Doesn't take long to learn enough git for solo school environment

Hiring Standards Position

  • No developer should be hired without basic git knowledge
  • Would accept SVN knowledge as compromise if candidate willing to learn git quickly
  • Version management understanding essential after 4 years of software writing
  • Analogy: equivalent to not knowing IDEs, only using notepad
  • Acceptable: using Sublime instead of VS Code (tool preference)
  • Unacceptable: no version control knowledge whatsoever

Version Control as Core Concept

  • Version control should be "1,000%" familiar by job-seeking time
  • Not about specific git technology but version control concept
  • Git currently most justifiable version control to learn
  • Students should feel "insecure and embarrassed" if they don't know git
  • "Unacceptable to write software for years and not know how version control works"

Industry Reality Check

  • Git is "literal underpinning" of 99% of serious software development
  • Essential for collaborative work
  • CS graduates not knowing git indicates:
    • No desire to learn beyond curriculum
    • Couldn't be bothered researching industry requirements
  • Should be barrier to hiring
  • Engineers typically learned git 10+ years ago, not discussed in hiring

Hacker News Controversy

  • Tweet front-paged on Hacker News for entire day
  • Generated significant pushback and debate

Common Counterarguments Addressed

  • "CS degrees teach general knowledge, not specific skills"
    • Response: Version control is fundamental, not a fad
  • "Git is just a tool, not a discipline"
    • Response: Basic tools should be known (file system navigation analogy)
  • "Git isn't even 20 years old"
    • Response: Current students are 20 or younger, git is older than them
  • Mechanic analogy: mechanic not knowing hammer usage is unacceptable

Technology Adoption Comparison

  • Elementary/middle schools using Google Docs for 10+ years
  • Universities still not using git in curriculum
  • Question: Why more willing to adopt proprietary software than universally used open source?

Gen Z Technology Gap

  • Many use phones/iPads more than computers
  • Chromebook usage common
  • Many don't know file system navigation
  • File management and git knowledge both essential

Industry Examples & Exceptions

  • Facebook uses Mercurial (rare exception)
  • Most companies use some form of version control
  • Almost all use git specifically
  • Any codebase without VCS is "almost ideological"

Educational System Critique

  • Software engineering classes focused on theory (UML, SOLID, DRY, KISS, Agile, Scrum)
  • Mostly "waste of time" with no practical programming
  • Missing practical tools education

Hiring Manager Perspective

  • Looking for people good at learning and self-improvement
  • 4 years of coding without learning git indicates poor learning initiative
  • Diverse interests should naturally lead to discovering tools and ecosystems
  • 99% of programming paths lead to git exposure

Current Job Market Reality

  • New graduates competing with laid-off experienced developers
  • Experienced developers definitely know git
  • Need to appear close to "industry veteran" level
  • Choice between hiring laid-off Facebook employees (know Mercurial + git) vs fresh graduate with no version control proof
  • Obvious hiring decision favors experienced candidates

Historical Context

  • Year 2000: expensive industry tools, open source alternatives used
  • Today: open source IS the industry standard
  • No excuse for not learning standard tools

Final Position

  • Git not about being "better engineer" but baseline requirement
  • Same necessity as having IDE for writing code
  • Need VCS for managing code after writing
  • 99% use git, so just use git
  • Described as fundamental baseline, not advanced skill

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome