AI summary by TwinMind
We’re Heading Into a New Cold War
Johnny Harris
14m 14s
Post-WWII US Global Leadership Era
- World exiting period of incredible growth and relative stability
- US rose to power as global leader after most destructive war in human history
- Created new structures: NATO, World Trade Organization
- Established rules based on Western philosophical values projected globally
- Rules about trade, economics, justice
- Soviet Union challenged order with different values/philosophies, own trading bloc
- USSR collapse in 90s left US and rich allies as sole rule setters
- US system of liberal values, democracy, free trade spread globally
US Global Policeman Role and Contradictions
- Being global superpower = global policeman role over 75 years
- US violated own values/norms/ideals that built global system on
- Cozying up to strongman dictators
- Throwing out democratically elected governments
- Fueling regional wars
- Stamping out communism globally
- Anyone not playing by America's rules cast as "insane pariah needing regime change"
- Despite double game, system created most peaceful period in human history
- Major empires don't fight like before
- Economic opportunity/growth incentivized alignment
- Nuclear weapons deterred great power conflicts
- American-led system meant stability, incredible trade, dramatic global poverty reduction
China's Rise and Alternative System
- China rose to second largest economy, world's largest military (by active forces)
- Most populous country until recently
- Views US as unfair global policeman only following rules benefiting them
- Sees Western value projection as modern colonialism
- Views US as hypocritical empire drunk on power since 1945
- Increasingly defensive due to decline
- Broken politics, divided people, complacency
Xi Jinping's Global Civilization Initiative (March 2023)
- Countries must "refrain from imposing own values/models on others"
- "Refrain from stoking ideological confrontation"
- Transactional system vs hypocritical rules-based order
- Built on common interests, beneficial deals, opportunistic alliances
- Not philosophical values like US system
- China now has military and money to ignore US rules, make own
US-China Competition and Decoupling
- Two great powers deeply economically entwined over 50 years
- Now slowly decoupling
- China planting seeds for new system globally
- State-backed money for infrastructure projects worldwide
- Creates Chinese presence, ties countries to Chinese debt
- Translates to future leverage
China's Diplomatic Breakthroughs
- March 2023: Chinese diplomats brokered peace deal between Saudi Arabia and Iran
- Two bitter rivals US couldn't reconcile
- Showed declining US influence in Middle East
- US still controls global economic/financial systems "for now"
BRICS Alternative Economic Block
- China working with Brazil, Russia, India, South Africa (BRICS)
- All major growing economies becoming more important next 2 decades
- Since 2009: stepping up cooperation
- Annual meetings
- New development bank for investments
- Policy coordination
- Potential rival to G7 countries (US-led order)
- Discussing shared currency between 5 economies
- Creating secondary world economy independent of US
- Quote: "Won't talk sanctions in 5 years - so many countries transacting in non-dollar currencies, won't have ability to sanction"
- Major challenge to US dollar as international trade standard
Ukraine War and Global Alignment
- Russia's invasion = major pushback against Western security/economic order
- Showed which countries fall on which side
- Most countries not taking sides - "non-aligned countries"
- 25 largest economies among non-aligned (per Economist Intelligence Unit)
- US working to keep them in system
- China trying to woo them to transactional system
New Cold War Characteristics
- Different from US-Soviet ideological capitalism vs communism divide
- Less black and white in globalized, interconnected world
- Non-aligned countries exploiting bidding war between superpowers
- Getting best trade/security deals possible
Country-Specific Examples
Brazil:
- Super close US ally but BRICS member with China
- Refused weapons sales to Ukraine
- President traveled Beijing April 2023
- Signed ~20 agreements on technology, trade, agriculture
- Asked Beijing help negotiate Ukraine war
- Playing both sides for own benefit
India:
- Gets cheap oil, nearly half weapons from Russia
- Quarter of weapons from Europe
- $200 billion US funding for Indian tech startups
Saudi Arabia:
- Gets almost all weapons from US
- China now top trading partner
- Late 2022: China-Saudi strategic partnership agreement
- More frequent leader meetings
- More trade, technology transfer, diplomacy
Turkey:
- NATO member, generally Western-aligned
- Strong economic ties to Russia
- China's Belt and Road Initiative runs through Turkey
- Courting Chinese investment in transportation, energy, mining
Pakistan:
- US-aligned partner in War on Terror
- $62 billion Chinese Belt and Road investment
- Economic corridor between Pakistan-China
Africa:
- Mostly non-aligned countries
- China giving huge loans, building bridges, ports, mines, railways
- Tying countries to future Chinese system
- China-Africa trade: $254 billion (2021)
- US-Africa trade: $44 billion (2021) - sixth of China's amount
- China's investment "swift and effective" in garnering allies
US Response Strategy
- High-level visits to counter Chinese influence:
- VP Kamala Harris to Africa (2023)
- Fed Reserve head Janet Yellen to Africa (2023)
- Secretary of State Anthony Blinken to Africa (2023)
- President Biden visited Saudi Arabia despite calling them "pariah state" on campaign trail
- Cutting China off from Western technology to hamper economic/military progress
- US and Asian allies encircling China militarily in Pacific
- Sending billions in weapons/infrastructure to China's backyard
Future Outlook
- Early days of new multipolar world
- Competition between established superpower vs rising superpower with different values
- Likely undoing of 70 years of globalization and interconnectedness
- Countries won't choose sides hastily
- Will play great powers against each other for best deals
- Unclear how long this strategy sustainable as tensions rise
- Moving into "uncharted waters"
