AI summary by TwinMind
What are land acknowledgments? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
44m 37s
Introduction and Context
- Podcast hosts Josh and Chuck discuss land acknowledgments with help from writer Livia
- Land acknowledgments are controversial due to clumsy implementation in most cases
- Example: acknowledgment before concerts/events stating performance takes place on First Nations land
- Topic is serious, contemporary, and emotionally charged - part of culture wars in America, Canada, Australia, New Zealand
- Purpose: acknowledge land was stolen, people forcibly removed, still suffering today compared to other groups
- Ideal form: prevent erasure from history, encourage action for redress
- Criticism from both political sides: right sees as "snowflake stuff," left sees as vapid virtue signaling
Historical Origins
- Australia: Welcome to Country ceremonies existed thousands of years ago
- Diplomatic protocol when tribes visited another's land
- Included poems, songs, smoking ceremonies
- 1976 Perth International Arts Festival: pivotal moment
- Maori and Cook Islander dancers demanded welcome by traditional land owners
- Richard Wally (Noongar people member) performed first modern welcome ceremony
- Spread gradually through 1980s-90s, initially among radical left politics
- 1990s Australia: self-reflection on Aboriginal treatment
- Welcome to Country evolved into land acknowledgments/acknowledgment of country
- National Indigenous Australians Agency created guidelines:
- Only indigenous people can do Welcome to Country on their traditional land
- Non-indigenous or other indigenous people do "acknowledgment of country"
North American Adoption
- Canada 2015: Truth and Reconciliation Commission report on residential schools
- Declared cultural genocide of indigenous children removal
- Justin Trudeau's platform emphasized reconciliation
- Land acknowledgments seen as "low hanging fruit" for reintroduction
- United States late 2010s (2017-2018):
- US Department of Arts and Culture (independent group) published guide 2017
- Founder Adam Horowitz: guide downloaded 7,000+ times
- Adopted by cities: Denver, Phoenix, Portland
- Used by National Park Service, NASA, Academy Awards, Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade, Democratic National Convention
- Timeline shows very recent American adoption (3-4 years)
Implementation Guidelines
- First step: examine company motivations
- Don't do for appearances or virtue signaling
- Must have genuine commitment beyond words
- Research requirements:
- Can't rely on Wikipedia or simple sources
- Indigenous peoples moved frequently, were forcibly removed
- Traveled with waterways, seasonal patterns
- Multiple groups may claim same land
- Text service available: 907-312-5085 for ZIP code lookup (basic starting point only)
- Collaboration essential:
- Reach out to indigenous groups
- Work together rather than extracting labor
- Follow their lead on content and approach
- Avoid having them write acknowledgment for you (compared to "thief having victim write receipt")
- Challenges: distill complex history into brief opening remarks
- Must fit at beginning of events (corporate retreats to hockey games)
- Poetry-like compression needed
- Balance detail with brevity
Expanded Formats
- Land and labor acknowledgments:
- Include enslaved labor that built cities/institutions
- University of Chicago example: mentions four forcibly removed nations plus Stephen A. Douglas's enslaved-labor-funded land donation
- Institutional vs. individual violence focus
- Most cities built on "way darker" foundations than initially apparent
Beyond Acknowledgments: Taking Action
- Political causes championed by Native Americans
- University free tuition programs for indigenous students
- Corporate hiring programs
- Individual actions:
- Attend Native American rallies for support
- Seattle's "Real Rent Duwamish" movement: pay rent to original inhabitants
- Ongoing issues requiring action:
- Native Americans most likely to live in poverty of any US group
- Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls (MMIWG) crisis
- Native American children frequently removed from families for white foster care without abuse evidence
- US has no Truth and Reconciliation process unlike Canada/Australia
Criticisms and Controversies
- Right-wing opposition:
- United Conservative Party of Canada banned them in Alberta
- Called "political correctness" or "wokism"
- Historical accuracy debates:
- Montreal Canadiens initially thanked only Mohawk nation
- Revised to include other tribes after historical challenges
- Debate over whether historical imperfection invalidates practice
- Conceptual problems:
- Indigenous peoples didn't conceive of land "ownership"
- "Stewardship" terminology may not fit all cultures
- Some cultures emphasized water bodies over land
- Risk of "noble savage" romanticization
- Implementation failures:
- Mispronunciation of tribal names
- Superficial research
- Corporate virtue signaling without real action
- Keeping violence/displacement history vague
- Perpetuating mythic past rather than addressing present
Land Back Movement
- 1980 Supreme Court: Black Hills stolen from Lakota, violated Fort Laramie Treaty 1868
- Court offered financial settlement
- Lakota refused money, still pushing for land return
- David Truer (Ojibwe writer) proposal: return 85 million acres of National Park land to tribal consortium
- Allow continued public access
- Restore indigenous hunting/farming rights
- Proven environmental benefits: indigenous management helps restore forests/ecosystems
- Minnesota example: 12,000 acres transferred to Leech Lake band of Ojibwe federal trust
- Individual landowners also returning small parcels
- "Real rent" movements: ongoing payments to original inhabitants
Media Recommendations
- Reservation Dogs TV show: indigenous-created comedy-drama about Oklahoma teenagers
- Betty Broderick story (1992 Meredith Baxter Birney film)
- Promising Young Woman movie
