AI summary by TwinMind
What Are the Rules of War? Just War Theory
CrashCourse
12m 6s
Introduction and Historical Context
- Speaker: Ellie Anderson, Crash Course Political Theory
- Personal context: eighth-grader during March 2003 Iraq invasion
- Bush administration made public case for war using Just War Theory framework
- Just War Theory: ethical framework for determining when war is acceptable and how it should be fought
Origins and Framework of Just War Theory
- Historical roots: 13th-century Italian philosopher Thomas Aquinas established foundation
- Two main Latin categories:
- Jus ad bellum: "what should a nation consider before going to war?"
- Jus in bello: "how can a nation make sure the war they're already fighting stays just?"
Jus Ad Bellum - Six Criteria for Going to War
- All six criteria must be met (not just one or two)
Criterion 1: Just Cause
- Need good, moral reason for war
- Self-defense widely accepted justification
- Bush administration approach:
- 2002 State of Union (4 months after 9/11): warned about Saddam Hussein's hostility
- VP Dick Cheney: "no doubt Saddam Hussein now has weapons of mass destruction...amassing them to use against our friends, allies, and us"
- Distinction between actions:
- Pre-emptive: evidence enemy about to attack
- Preventive: enemy might attack (harder to justify)
- Iraq case: preventive rather than pre-emptive (no definitive WMD proof)
Criterion 2: Right Intention
- Cause vs intention: cause starts it, intention is the goal
- Must ultimately achieve something good
- Bush administration stated intentions:
- Protect Americans from future attack
- Depose Saddam Hussein
- Bring democracy to Iraq
- Hussein's brutality: poison gas attack on Kurdish village killed 5,000 suspected disloyal people during 30-year rule
- Complications:
- UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan: invasion violated UN charter
- Millions protested globally (largest peace demonstration since Vietnam War)
Criterion 3: Legitimate Authority
- Only nations can declare war, not individuals
- U.S. case: easily met
- Complications: what constitutes legitimate nation/authority?
- Example: Israel-Gaza war 2023 - legitimacy disputes
Criterion 4: Likelihood of Success
- Reasonable chance of success required
- Prevents waste of human life and resources
- Challenge: defining what success looks like
- Deposing Saddam Hussein?
- Destroying potential WMDs?
- Establishing democratic government?
Criterion 5: Proportionality
- War must do more good than harm
- Compare two futures: with war vs without war
- Peace achieved must be greater than if war never started
- Requires "crystal ball" predictions
Criterion 6: Last Resort
- Try every other means before war
- Diplomatic options must be exhausted
- March 17, 2003: Bush ultimatum - Saddam and sons leave Iraq within 48 hours
- March 20, 2003: Iraq War officially began after Hussein non-compliance
Jus In Bello - Ethics During War
Legitimate Targets Only
- Enemy combatants fair game, civilians spared
- Doctrine of double effect: serious harm acceptable only as side effect of doing good
- Military facility bombing acceptable even if civilian casualties likely (unintended)
- Targeting civilians for terror unacceptable
- Reality: 200,000+ Iraqi civilians killed during 8-year conflict
Proportionality in Combat
- Damage (people, infrastructure, environment) must be proportionate to ends achieved
- "Morally ambiguous math"
Necessity of Actions
- Each wartime action must be necessary
- Challenged by Abu Ghraib prison treatment of political prisoners in Baghdad
Assessment of Iraq War Justification
- Public opinion: Pew Research Center - 62% Americans believed war not worth fighting
- Scholarly analysis: Christian Enemark and Christopher Michaelsen concluded war unjustified across Just War criteria
- Defenders: VP Dick Cheney (2018 Cornell University): "world better place without Saddam...president had all justification needed"
Challenges and Complications
Cultural Perspectives
- Different moral perspectives on prisoner treatment
- Varying definitions of "humane" rules of engagement
Technology Impact
- Drones enable video game-like targeting
- Lethal autonomous weapon systems use AI for targeting/destroying enemies
- Complicates Just War theory questions
Feminist Critique
- Lucinda Peach: women historically excluded from war discussions
- Disregards life-altering impacts on women and children globally
Evolution of Just War Theory
- Jus post bellum (justice after war): recent philosophical addition
- Questions: "What's right thing to do when war is over?"
- Requirements:
- Hold combatants accountable for wartime actions
- Establish rules of peace
- Theory continues evolving after millennia
Conclusion
- Determining truly just war extremely difficult
- Just War Theory more than simple checklist
- Serves as lens to interrogate leaders' decisions
- Tool for questioning history, present, and future
