AI summary by TwinMind
What did Einstein mean by “Spooky Action at a Distance"?
Sabine Hossenfelder
10m 33s
Common Misconception About Einstein's "Spooky Action"
- Most internet sources (Wikipedia, Science Magazine, YouTube) claim Einstein's "spooky action at a distance" referred to entanglement
- Author argues this interpretation is incorrect
Origin of "Spooky Action at a Distance" Phrase
- Phrase comes from Einstein's letter to Max Born, March 1947
- Einstein acknowledged quantum mechanics' statistical formalism captures "significant truth"
- Einstein's concern: "I cannot seriously believe in quantum mechanics because the theory is incompatible with the requirement that physics should represent reality in space and time without spooky action at a distance"
Quantum Mechanics Fundamentals
- Everything described by complex-valued wave function (ψ)
- Probabilities calculated by taking absolute square of wave function
- Wave function itself unobservable - only measurement outcomes observed
- Key issue: measurement with uncertain outcome requires instantaneous wave function update
- Update happens simultaneously everywhere
- Appears faster than speed of light
Einstein's 1927 Solvay Conference Example
- Single electron beam directed at screen with tiny hole
- Wave function diffracts symmetrically in all directions
- Equal probability for electron detection anywhere
- Upon measurement, electron found at one specific point
- Einstein called this "entirely peculiar mechanism of action at a distance"
- Wave function on left side must "know" particle detected on right side
- Called "peculiar" in 1927, later "spooky"
Development to EPR Paper (1935)
- Single particle example unclear about what acts on what
- Einstein, Podolsky, Rosen examined two entangled particles
- Need at least two particles to demonstrate measurement on one affecting the other
- This led to famous 1935 EPR paper
Entanglement vs Spooky Action Distinction
- Entanglement itself unproblematic - just correlation type
- Correlations can be non-local without action at a distance
- Sock analogy: red/blue socks in envelopes
- Opening one envelope reveals other's color
- Correlation created locally, spans large distances
- No spooky action involved
- Ball-wall momentum example: correlations exist everywhere
Quantum Entanglement Specifics
- Particle with spin zero decays into two particles (±1 spin)
- One goes left, one right
- Total spin conserved
- Before measurement: both possibilities exist simultaneously
- Entanglement correlations stronger than non-quantum correlations in certain circumstances
- Correlations created locally
Wave Function Collapse Issue
- Einstein's real concern: measuring one particle changes wave function of other particle
- Unlike sock example where properties predetermined
- Quantum mechanics: predetermined properties cannot create sufficiently strong correlations
- Incompatible with experimental observations
- Experiments done after Einstein's death confirmed this
Einstein's 1948 Follow-up Letter
- Measurement on wave function = physical intervention
- Such intervention cannot immediately influence distant physical reality
- Conclusion: quantum mechanics "incomplete and indirect description of reality"
- Will be "replaced by complete and direct one"
- Einstein didn't think quantum mechanics wrong - thought it incomplete
Author's Interpretation
- "Spooky action at a distance" referred to measurement update, not entanglement
- Einstein was "exceedingly careful" in expressing himself
- Most physicists dismissed his concerns too readily
Sponsor Content
- Brilliant.org interactive courses on science/mathematics
- Recommended courses: linear algebra, quantum objects
- Link: brilliant.org/sabine
- First 200 subscribers get 20% off annual premium subscription
