AI summary by TwinMind

What Does It REALLY Mean To Do Things That Don't Scale? – Dalton Caldwell and Michael Seibel

Y Combinator

18m 51s

Introduction & Core Concept

  • Michael Cybel with Dalton Caldwell discussing "do things that don't scale"
  • Term popularized by PG essay from 2013, advice given to YC founders for years
  • Founders often confused about concept
  • Definition: doing something provocatively manual where founder personally does tasks, not relying on code or scalable processes

Reddit Example - Fake Users Strategy

  • Day one: Reddit existed as blank site with no links, no users
  • Scalable approach would be: launch subreddits → run ads → hire influencers → big launch with hundreds of thousands signups
  • What Steve & Alexis actually did:
    • Built tool allowing them to submit links with extra username field
    • Started inventing different usernames and submitting links themselves
    • Day one when emailed to 6 friends, looked like page full of users (actually only 2 users)
  • Steve's milestone stories:
    • First day someone else submitted (not day one)
    • Got drunk, forgot to load morning's fake links, feared blank site
    • Opened site next morning - enough real users submitting that site wasn't blank
    • Estimated 20-30 real people at that point

DoorDash Example - Founder Deliveries

  • Food delivery requires hundreds of orders daily at scale
  • Founders got started by doing all deliveries themselves
  • No need to hire drivers, build driver app, or recruit drivers
  • When miracle order came in, founders would drop everything and deliver food personally
  • Benefits of founder delivery approach:
    • Delight users through personal service
    • Race to restaurant, ensure correct order, add extras
    • Personal thank you from founder
    • No driver network management needed
    • Direct user feedback: "here's your burrito, I'm the founder, do you like it, would you order again?"
  • Tony (DoorDash founder) reportedly still does deliveries occasionally

Cruise Example - Basic Autonomous Vehicle

  • Cruise recently allowed general public to ride in driverless cars
  • When Cruise was in YC, V1 built by Kyle's team in 3 months
  • Retrofitted Audi with basic features:
    • Big red button on driver's seat floor (purpose unexplained but clearly important)
    • Only worked on highway
    • Basically adaptive cruise control that stayed in lane
    • Not more sophisticated than that
  • Memorable test ride moment: Kyle said "oh a shadow, let's see how car handles that"
  • Google had cars with fancy equipment while Kyle had Audi that couldn't handle shadows
  • That's how it starts

CEO Role in Early Stages

  • Job of CEO/co-founders: do shittiest, worst, low-status work possible
  • Opposite of typical CEO mental model (visionary, powerful)
  • Must learn to love and embrace the work
  • Pre-product market fit job: make everything happen personally
  • Be personally accountable for entire system running end-to-end
  • Many founders mistakenly emulate late-stage CEOs (Elon Musk, Mark Zuckerberg)
  • Smart people often not cut out for founder role because they don't want to do manual work
  • Special type: smart but willing to get hands dirty

Customer Support & Front Lines

  • Founder's actual job: answering customer support emails
  • Dealing with angry customers who hate them
  • No one else to yell at in tiny startup
  • Every DoorDash order screw-up meant founders personally apologizing
  • Founders want to put others on front lines but founders ARE the front lines
  • More scalable to have others handle, but "doing things that don't scale" means embracing the suck

Learning Advantages

  • Learn what others unwilling to learn → build better product
  • Serve customers better than incumbents
  • Senior management at big companies not on front lines
  • They use researchers/outsourced customer surveys
  • Front-line founders learn 10x more

Social Pressure & Friends

  • Friends at Google with free food, laundry, bus mock founder work
  • "You're hand delivering food? Hand adding links to your website?"
  • Friends think founder is idiot for starting company
  • This stage screens out most people because it sucks
  • If easy to start company, more people would do it
  • Few Googles exist because this stage is barrier
  • Not lack of good ideas, innovation, or funding - lack of people willing to do this stage

Big Tech Company Training Problem

  • Many young founders think they need big company experience first
  • Google/Facebook interviews focus on scalable algorithms
  • Inside big tech: rolling out to millions, scalability beaten into head
  • Only scalable solutions considered good solutions
  • Unscalable feature requiring 100x more servers would be rejected
  • Every product/feature viewed through scalability lens
  • This training actually harmful for early startup stages
  • Helpful for late stage but not early stage
  • College grads without big tech experience never told to worry about scalability
  • Big tech founders can't launch because nothing's perfect
  • Incentive structure at big companies: don't launch unscalable features

Founder Mindset & Expectations

  • Biggest challenge: screwed up expectations
  • Founders think "I launch it and then it's gonna work"
  • Should go in with mindset: "I don't care if it takes two years to work"
  • Maintaining motivation is 3/4 of the game
  • What founders want to discuss vs. what they need help with are different
  • Should ask about: emotional well-being, maintaining motivation, high stress, criticism
  • Many unprepared for internet criticism
  • Many startups die because founders run out of gas, get sad, want to return to Google jobs

Motivation & Reality Check

  • Motivation not about how shitty something is, but expectations vs. reality
  • Dalton tells college kids: "this life sucks, like getting punched in face every day"
  • Real face punch, not fake - memorable for rest of life
  • Still have bad dreams about startups
  • Hardest thing they've ever done and probably will ever do

Key Principles Summary

  • Expect it to be counterintuitive
  • People around you won't understand, will actively think you're stupid
  • Friends will stage interventions
  • Expect to look way different than larger competitors
  • You are primary actor, not acting through others - you are the doer
  • Don't copy well-funded competitors' strategies
  • Focus on getting one customer before trying for thousands
  • Delivering one burrito separates you from the pack
  • Actually doing something puts you in top half of startup founders
  • Get first customer to come back - measure retention

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome