AI summary by TwinMind

What Happened to Singapore's TSMC?

Asianometry

16m 42s

Company Origins and Formation (1987-1999)

  • Singapore Technologies Group (STG) selected to spearhead Singapore's semiconductor entrance in 1987
  • Technology transfer agreement with US fabless semiconductor maker Sierra Semiconductor
  • Originally hoped for support from Sierra and National Semiconductor, but National dropped out
  • Restructured to copy TSMC's independent foundry business model after seeing its success
  • Spun off integrated circuit design house, moved forward as pure foundry
  • Rebranded as Chartered Semiconductor Manufacturing (CSM) in 1999
  • Went public on NASDAQ and Singapore stock markets in 1999
  • Restructured in 2000 as majority government-backed entity under sovereign wealth fund Temasek

Technology Development and Early Growth (1987-1994)

  • Sierra transferred 3.0 micron process technology and trained 100 Singaporean technical staff
  • Process technology was outdated, needed rapid advancement
  • Established in-house R&D lab immediately
  • Rapid technology progression:
    • 1990: 1.5 microns
    • 1991: 1.2 microns
    • 1992: 0.8 microns
    • 1993: 0.6 microns
    • 1994: Deal with Toshiba for 0.5 micron process technology

Expansion and Government Support (1990s)

  • Rapidly expanded production facilities throughout 1990s
  • Built 5 foundries on 60 hectares in northern Singapore
  • Plans drawn for up to 25 foundries assuming success
  • Expanded product assortment for complete turnkey solutions
  • Singapore government provided:
    • Tax incentives and subsidies for multinationals
    • Training cost funding for companies
    • State-run university programs for electrical engineers
  • Achieved third place in foundry industry behind TSMC and UMC

Market Pressures and Competition (2000s)

  • Caught in pincer movement that squeezed them out of market
  • Chinese foundries entered market in 2000:
    • Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corporation (SMIC) most notable
    • Founded by former TSMC vice president
    • Leveraged government subsidies and cheaper costs
    • Same technology licenses available to them as CSM
  • TSMC brought battle to Singapore in 1998:
    • Joint venture with Phillips Electronics to start SSMC
    • Invested 2 billion Singapore dollars over 3 years
    • Trailing edge but good enough for many customers

Financial Performance Decline

  • Could not differentiate product from cheaper Chinese and Taiwanese competitors
  • Gross margin indicators:
    • 2005: 11% gross margin
    • 2003: -17.5% gross margin (down year)
    • Same period TSMC: 44% gross margins
  • Needed to reach leading edge to differentiate product

Samsung Entry and Technology Race (2005)

  • Samsung announced standalone foundry business entry in 2005
  • Leveraged immense resources and expertise
  • Quickly rocketed to second place ahead of CSM and UMC
  • Already biggest electronics and semiconductor company globally
  • Owned largest share of digital memory oligopoly
  • Had captive customer base despite claimed division separation

Escalating Costs and Technical Challenges

  • Leading edge fab costs escalated dramatically:
    • 2005: $3 billion (6x higher than 1995)
    • 2020: TSMC's N5 fab cost $17 billion
    • N3 process fab estimated at $19.5 billion
  • CSM tried partnering with IBM to develop new edge processes
  • Partnerships slowed product development, fell behind curve
  • Technology partners licensed learnings to competitors within few years

Final Struggles and Acquisition (2009)

  • Singapore government allocated hundreds of millions but needed billions
  • 22 years of consecutive financial losses
  • Abu Dhabi's Global Foundries acquisition strategy:
    • Build global semiconductor champion using oil profits
    • Buy multiple foundries to assemble global giant
    • Teach UAE citizens STEM skills and business savvy
  • September 2009: Global Foundries offered 2.68 Singapore dollars per share
  • Price only 2 cents higher than closing price
  • Total acquisition: 2.5 billion Singapore dollars (1.8 billion USD)
  • Temasek backed deal, no premium needed
  • Stock had risen 100% in previous months

Global Foundries Outcome

  • Never executed successfully on business strategy
  • Could not reach necessary scale for escape velocity
  • TSMC and Samsung locked in premium customers at deep technical level
  • Post-2010 advanced processes only available from TSMC or Samsung
  • Required separate teams for each foundry
  • 2018: Global Foundries ended 7nm development, focused on specialized processes

Strategic Assessment and Lessons

  • Singapore had strong foundation:
    • Established strategy
    • Deep multinational connections
    • Well-educated, disciplined workforce
    • Competent, patient government
  • Semiconductor market like "race with no finish line"
  • Competitors keep pushing finish line further
  • Questions about benefit to ordinary Singaporeans:
    • Significant percentage of jobs went to highly paid expat foreigners
    • Limited change throughout 22 years of losses
  • Singapore semiconductor sector continues as significant part of economy
  • Creates jobs, exports, profits for partners
  • "Home runs rare and hard to make, doubles and singles can be perfectly fine"

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome