AI summary by TwinMind

What happens when biology becomes technology? | Christina Agapakis

TED

10m 58s

Introduction: The Briefcase Full of Poop

  • 10 years ago: speaker was graduate student judging genetic engineering competition for undergrads
  • Met Alexander Daisy Ginsburg, British artisan designer from University of Cambridge team
  • She showed silver briefcase containing 6 multicolored turds
  • Cambridge team engineered E. coli bacteria to sense environmental conditions and produce rainbow colors
    • Arsenic in drinking water → green color output
    • Concept: living probiotic drink and health monitor combined
    • Bacteria would live in gut, sense conditions, produce colored output
  • Cambridge team won International Genetically Engineered Machine (iGEM) competition
  • This moment was turning point for speaker's career

Synthetic Biology Definition and Philosophy

  • Speaker identifies as synthetic biologist
  • Term sounds like oxymoron: how can biology (natural) be synthetic (artificial)?
  • Synthetic biology pokes holes in boundary between natural and technological
  • iGEM students annually engineer biology to be technology:
    • Bacteria playing tic-tac-toe
    • Multi-colored spider silk
    • Self-healing concrete
    • Tissue printers
    • Plastic-eating bacteria

Traditional Genetic Engineering vs. Synthetic Biology

  • Chameleon sign Minori's critique: genetic engineering insulting to proper engineering
  • Traditional approach: "throwing concrete and steel in river, if someone can walk across, call it bridge"
  • Synthetic biologists wanted to transform genetic engineering into real engineering discipline
  • Goal: program cells and write DNA like engineers write software for computers

Speaker's Current Role and Mission

  • Creative director at Ginkgo Bioworks synthetic biology company
  • Unusual title for biotech company focused on programming life like computers
  • Learned engineering is about people, not just equations/steel/circuits
  • Mission: open new spaces for different kinds of engineering
  • Questions explored:
    • How to ask better questions about future technology
    • How to have better conversations about technological desires
    • Understanding social/political/economic reasons GMOs are polarizing
    • Making GMOs people love
    • Using biology for expansive, regenerative technology

Cultural Critique of Engineering

  • Synthetic biologists shaped by culture valuing "real engineering" over "squishy stuff"
  • Focus on circuits and computational aspects loses sight of biological magic
  • Poop as technology: visceral, unforgettable vision of future
  • Technology framed as question: "Is this future we actually want?"
  • Promised future of chrome vs. fleshy future alternative

Biology as Technology and Identity

  • Science fiction helps remember we're made of starstuff
  • Biology is us: our bodies, what we eat
  • Questions raised when biology becomes technology
  • Future full of choices, could choose differently
  • Implications for body, beauty, awareness, microbial world, eating habits

Cheese Project from Dissertation

  • Made cheese using bacteria swabbed from between toes
  • Collaborated with smell artist/researcher Sissel Tolaas
  • Explored connections between bodies and cheese through smell and microbes
  • Challenged thinking about bacteria in our lives vs. lab bacteria
  • "We are indeed what we eat"

Technology vs. Biology Dichotomy

  • Intersection often told as story of transcending fleshy realities
  • Upload brain to computer = no more pooping (presented as good thing)
  • Cultural assumptions:
    • Computers: clean, rational, make sense
    • Biology: messy, unpredictable tangle
    • Science/technology: rational, objective, pure
    • Humans: total mess
  • Artists, designers, social scientists show softer lines between nature/technology/society

Political Dimensions of Science and Technology

  • Prejudices, hopes, values embedded in science and technology
  • Questions asked and choices made are political
  • Science and technology are human, therefore political
  • Controlling life for own purposes raises ethical questions

Victimless Leather Project

  • Collaboration with artist Oron Catts and Ionat Zurr
  • Engineered tiny leather jacket from mouse cells
  • Questions raised:
    • Is jacket alive?
    • What does it take to grow and maintain?
    • Is it really victimless?
    • What does "victimless" mean?

Genetic Privacy and Identity

  • Artist Heather Dewey-Hagberg created faces from DNA sequences extracted from sidewalk litter
  • Questions about genetic privacy
  • Whether DNA can really define us

Climate Change and Biological Solutions

  • Fighting/coping with climate change
  • Changing manufacturing using biological materials that grow and decay
  • Changing our bodies or nature itself
  • Changing systems reinforcing boundaries between science/society/nature/technology
  • Current patterns unsustainable

Historical Case Study: Hawaiian Extinction

  • European settlers brought cattle and scientists to Hawaii
  • Cattle trampled and changed ecosystems
  • Scientists catalogued species, often taking last specimen before extinction
  • Example: Maui hau kuahiwi (Hibiscadelphus wilderianus)
    • Named by Garrett Wilder in 1910
    • Extinct by 1912
    • Specimen housed at Harvard University herbarium with 5 million other specimens

Resurrecting Extinct Scents Project

  • Extracted DNA from tiny sliver of Hawaiian plant specimen
  • Sequenced DNA inside
  • Resynthesized possible version of genes creating plant's smell
  • Inserted genes into yeast to produce smell bits
  • Collaboration with Ginkgo team, UC Santa Cruz, Daisy Ginsburg, Sissel Tolaas
  • Created installation for people to experience reconstructed flower scent
  • Connecting natural history with synthetic future

Conclusion: Evolution of Perspective

  • 10 years ago: synthetic biologist worried genetic engineering was more art than science
  • People too messy, biology too complicated
  • Now: uses genetic engineering as art to explore interconnections
  • Imagining different possible futures
  • Fleshy future recognizes:
    • Interconnections and human realities of technology
    • Incredible power of biology: resilience, sustainability, healing, growth, adaptation
  • Values necessary for future visions
  • Technology shapes future, but humans make technology
  • Decision about future is up to all of us

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome