AI summary by TwinMind
What happens when biology becomes technology? | Christina Agapakis
TED
10m 58s
Introduction: The Briefcase Full of Poop
- 10 years ago: speaker was graduate student judging genetic engineering competition for undergrads
- Met Alexander Daisy Ginsburg, British artisan designer from University of Cambridge team
- She showed silver briefcase containing 6 multicolored turds
- Cambridge team engineered E. coli bacteria to sense environmental conditions and produce rainbow colors
- Arsenic in drinking water → green color output
- Concept: living probiotic drink and health monitor combined
- Bacteria would live in gut, sense conditions, produce colored output
- Cambridge team won International Genetically Engineered Machine (iGEM) competition
- This moment was turning point for speaker's career
Synthetic Biology Definition and Philosophy
- Speaker identifies as synthetic biologist
- Term sounds like oxymoron: how can biology (natural) be synthetic (artificial)?
- Synthetic biology pokes holes in boundary between natural and technological
- iGEM students annually engineer biology to be technology:
- Bacteria playing tic-tac-toe
- Multi-colored spider silk
- Self-healing concrete
- Tissue printers
- Plastic-eating bacteria
Traditional Genetic Engineering vs. Synthetic Biology
- Chameleon sign Minori's critique: genetic engineering insulting to proper engineering
- Traditional approach: "throwing concrete and steel in river, if someone can walk across, call it bridge"
- Synthetic biologists wanted to transform genetic engineering into real engineering discipline
- Goal: program cells and write DNA like engineers write software for computers
Speaker's Current Role and Mission
- Creative director at Ginkgo Bioworks synthetic biology company
- Unusual title for biotech company focused on programming life like computers
- Learned engineering is about people, not just equations/steel/circuits
- Mission: open new spaces for different kinds of engineering
- Questions explored:
- How to ask better questions about future technology
- How to have better conversations about technological desires
- Understanding social/political/economic reasons GMOs are polarizing
- Making GMOs people love
- Using biology for expansive, regenerative technology
Cultural Critique of Engineering
- Synthetic biologists shaped by culture valuing "real engineering" over "squishy stuff"
- Focus on circuits and computational aspects loses sight of biological magic
- Poop as technology: visceral, unforgettable vision of future
- Technology framed as question: "Is this future we actually want?"
- Promised future of chrome vs. fleshy future alternative
Biology as Technology and Identity
- Science fiction helps remember we're made of starstuff
- Biology is us: our bodies, what we eat
- Questions raised when biology becomes technology
- Future full of choices, could choose differently
- Implications for body, beauty, awareness, microbial world, eating habits
Cheese Project from Dissertation
- Made cheese using bacteria swabbed from between toes
- Collaborated with smell artist/researcher Sissel Tolaas
- Explored connections between bodies and cheese through smell and microbes
- Challenged thinking about bacteria in our lives vs. lab bacteria
- "We are indeed what we eat"
Technology vs. Biology Dichotomy
- Intersection often told as story of transcending fleshy realities
- Upload brain to computer = no more pooping (presented as good thing)
- Cultural assumptions:
- Computers: clean, rational, make sense
- Biology: messy, unpredictable tangle
- Science/technology: rational, objective, pure
- Humans: total mess
- Artists, designers, social scientists show softer lines between nature/technology/society
Political Dimensions of Science and Technology
- Prejudices, hopes, values embedded in science and technology
- Questions asked and choices made are political
- Science and technology are human, therefore political
- Controlling life for own purposes raises ethical questions
Victimless Leather Project
- Collaboration with artist Oron Catts and Ionat Zurr
- Engineered tiny leather jacket from mouse cells
- Questions raised:
- Is jacket alive?
- What does it take to grow and maintain?
- Is it really victimless?
- What does "victimless" mean?
Genetic Privacy and Identity
- Artist Heather Dewey-Hagberg created faces from DNA sequences extracted from sidewalk litter
- Questions about genetic privacy
- Whether DNA can really define us
Climate Change and Biological Solutions
- Fighting/coping with climate change
- Changing manufacturing using biological materials that grow and decay
- Changing our bodies or nature itself
- Changing systems reinforcing boundaries between science/society/nature/technology
- Current patterns unsustainable
Historical Case Study: Hawaiian Extinction
- European settlers brought cattle and scientists to Hawaii
- Cattle trampled and changed ecosystems
- Scientists catalogued species, often taking last specimen before extinction
- Example: Maui hau kuahiwi (Hibiscadelphus wilderianus)
- Named by Garrett Wilder in 1910
- Extinct by 1912
- Specimen housed at Harvard University herbarium with 5 million other specimens
Resurrecting Extinct Scents Project
- Extracted DNA from tiny sliver of Hawaiian plant specimen
- Sequenced DNA inside
- Resynthesized possible version of genes creating plant's smell
- Inserted genes into yeast to produce smell bits
- Collaboration with Ginkgo team, UC Santa Cruz, Daisy Ginsburg, Sissel Tolaas
- Created installation for people to experience reconstructed flower scent
- Connecting natural history with synthetic future
Conclusion: Evolution of Perspective
- 10 years ago: synthetic biologist worried genetic engineering was more art than science
- People too messy, biology too complicated
- Now: uses genetic engineering as art to explore interconnections
- Imagining different possible futures
- Fleshy future recognizes:
- Interconnections and human realities of technology
- Incredible power of biology: resilience, sustainability, healing, growth, adaptation
- Values necessary for future visions
- Technology shapes future, but humans make technology
- Decision about future is up to all of us
