AI summary by TwinMind
What Happens When We Deny People Abortions? | Diana Greene Foster | TED
TED
14m 4s
Personal Background and Research Motivation
- Speaker shares stories of two grandmothers with unwanted pregnancies in early 20th century
- Sally: newly married during Great Depression, traveled to Puerto Rico for illegal abortion, later had 3 children when financially secure
- Dorothy: high school graduate, pregnant by older golf instructor, conservative parents shunned her, went to Salvation Army home, gave birth and placed child for adoption
- These family experiences motivated speaker to become demographer studying unintended pregnancy causes/consequences
Supreme Court Context and Research Genesis
- 2007 Supreme Court Justice Anthony Kennedy allowed abortion restrictions based on claim that abortion harms women mentally
- Kennedy stated "no reliable data" existed but concluded "some women come to regret their choice" and experience "severe depression and loss of esteem"
- Speaker's team began data collection in 2008 to address this gap
Turnaway Study Design and Methodology
- Research team at UC San Francisco studied 30 abortion facilities across country
- Facilities selected for distance from other clinics (limited alternatives for late-term patients)
- Two comparison groups recruited:
- Women just under gestational limit who received abortions
- Women who arrived too late and were turned away
- Followed almost 1,000 women for 5 years with calls every 6 months
- Used scientifically validated questions measuring physical health, mental health, family well-being
- Both groups had similar baseline characteristics: mental health, physical health, socioeconomic status
Mental Health Findings
- No mental health harm from abortion found
- Women denied abortions showed:
- Higher anxiety
- Lower self-esteem
- Lower life satisfaction
- Mental health differences didn't persist long-term
- Both groups showed improvement in depression/anxiety symptoms over time
Physical Health Outcomes
- Worse physical health for women who carried pregnancy to term
- Childbirth associated with greater risks than abortion: hemorrhage, eclampsia, death
- Years later, women denied abortions had:
- Higher chronic pain
- More hypertension
- Overall worse physical health
Socioeconomic Impact
- Large differences favoring women who received abortions
- Women denied abortions experienced:
- Increased public assistance usage (insufficient to compensate for employment loss)
- Loss of full-time employment
- Higher rates falling below federal poverty level
- More debt
- Lower credit scores
- Greater chance of eviction and bankruptcy
- Economic trajectories similar for years before pregnancy, diverged significantly after
Life Aspirational Goals
- Differences in achieving future plans for women denied abortions:
- Breaking ties with abusive partners
- Finding high-quality romantic relationships
- Getting advanced educational degrees
- Financially supporting older children
- Having intended pregnancies later
Women's Reasons for Abortion
- Multiple reasons cited: housing, financial circumstances, relationship with partner, need to care for existing children
- Over 50% of abortion seekers nationally already parenting at least one child
- Women's concerns about finances, children, relationships, life aspirations proved justified in study outcomes
Long-term Satisfaction and Adoption Rates
- Over 95% of women who received abortions said it was right decision after 5 years
- Less than 10% of women who gave birth placed children for adoption
- Women who placed children for adoption most likely to report difficulty coping
- Contradicts Amy Coney Barrett's suggestion about "dropping babies off at fire stations"
Global Context and Policy Implications
- Speaker collaborated with scientists in Tunisia, Colombia, South Africa, Bangladesh, Nepal
- Same concerns about wanting children under right circumstances found globally
- International trend toward liberalizing abortion laws, unlike US imposing new restrictions
- Post-2022 Dobbs decision impacts:
- Large areas of Southern US and Midwest without legal abortion clinics
- Women with resources travel hundreds of miles or order medication online
- Minors, immigrants, those with restricted travel face documented hardships
Policy Recommendations
- Support for pregnant people regardless of decision:
- More generous, less punitive supports for low-income families
- Income supports
- Extended health care coverage periods
- Child care and parental leave
- Prevent economic-only abortion decisions while ensuring safe access for those who choose abortion
Personal Reflection on Grandmothers' Outcomes
- Sally (abortion): went on with life, had 3 children later, was warm, funny, wonderful mother
- Dorothy (gave birth): severe physical/emotional complications, struggled with relationships, never had more children despite wanting them, life took detour as teenager and never got back on desired track
- Speaker was close to Dorothy, held her hand when she died
