AI summary by TwinMind
What I learned from taking a train across the US
Vox
12m 57s
Historical Context of American Railroads
- US historically had largest, most well-funded rail network globally
- 1916: 254,000 miles of railroads (highest ever in US)
- Pennsylvania Railroad ("Penzy") was world's largest corporation at the time
- Railroads central to American life, built iconic stations (Penn Station, Grand Central)
- Luxury train travel featured chandeliers, barber shops, dining cars with gourmet food
- Menus included oysters, consommé, celery-fed duck
- Service rivaled Four Seasons hotels
Journey Experience - First Leg (LA to Chicago)
- 70-hour total journey time vs 5-6 hours by flight
- No sleeper cars available for first 2 days
- Basic accommodations, overhead lights on all night
- Food: microwaved Thai red curry street noodles (surprisingly good)
- No Wi-Fi available
- Sleep disrupted by iPad kids watching movies at full volume
- 45 hours to reach Chicago from LA
- 7-hour layover in Chicago Union Station
Decline of American Rail System
- Robber barons era: Cornelius Vanderbilt, Jay Gould, James Fisk, JP Morgan
- Ruthless, anti-labor, corrupt practices
- Built profitable rail empires but became universally hated
- Government response: heavy regulation
- Fixed rates for railroad companies
- Required permission for fare changes or service modifications
- Impact of competition:
- 1956: Only 4% of passenger travel by train
- 40 years earlier: 98% of passenger travel by train
- Rail companies regulated as monopolies despite losing monopoly status
Freight vs Passenger Operations
- Freight trains always profitable, passenger service never profitable
- Rail companies forced to provide passenger service as public benefit
- Government solution: separate passenger service from freight operations
Creation and Challenges of Amtrak (1971)
- Formed by combining all passenger services into one company
- "American train track" - designed as for-profit corporation
- Fundamental contradiction: tasked with profitability despite passenger service being unprofitable
- Initial funding: $40 million first year
- 2022 budget: $2.3 billion
- Federal Highway budget same year: $64.3 billion
- Total Amtrak subsidies (entire history) < one year of interstate highway funding
- Demonstrates America's transportation priorities
Journey Experience - Second Leg (Chicago to NYC)
- Private room with hidden sink feature
- More dynamic/bumpy ride than first train
- Reached Ohio at 2,600 miles, 50+ hours into journey
- Total journey time: 72 hours, 17 minutes
Benefits of Train Travel
- Environmental: 37% less emissions than flying (University of Pennsylvania study)
- Safety: 17 times safer than driving
- Comfort advantages over flying/driving:
- No TSA security
- No traffic delays
- Ability to walk around, stretch, read, nap
- Scenic views of countryside
- Private room accommodation
Current State and Future Potential
- Amtrak covers ~21,000 miles of passenger rail
- Sparse coverage, disconnected routes
- Wyoming and South Dakota have no train service
- Former Amtrak president Graham Claytor: "Only American public can save it when they say they want it"
- Potential for revolutionizing US travel if properly funded
Personal Reflection
- Overall pleasant, memorable experience despite initial hiccups
- Opportunity to see unseen parts of country
- Enjoyable aspects: staring out window, peaceful travel experience
- Returned to LA by flight next day
