Summary by TwinMind · 9m 48s

Summary by TwinMind · 9m 48s

What if mental health workers responded to emergency calls? | Leslie Herod

What if mental health workers responded to emergency calls? | Leslie Herod

TED

TED

Speaker's Background & Motivation

  • Speaker passionate about police ride-alongs globally (Amsterdam, Canada, Boston, Denver)
  • People call 911 for various reasons: lost cats, neighbor concerns, mental health crises
  • Core issue: people call 911 because they don't know alternatives
  • 911 calls can worsen situations: arrests, 72-hour holds, fines, criminal charges, potential death
  • Personal connection: sister in criminal justice system 30 years due to untreated trauma from sexual assault

Discovery of Eugene's CAHOOTS Program

  • Speaker passed "Caring for Denver" ballot measure for mental health/substance use services
  • Friend recommended Eugene, Oregon program
  • CAHOOTS: 4th emergency response option beyond firefighter/police/paramedic
    • Mental health professional + EMT in van responding to mental health calls
  • Key statistics: 50% of police brutality victims have disabilities (predominantly mental health)
  • Problem: police lack tools for mental health crisis response
  • Underfunded mental health services = jails/prisons as de facto mental health clinics

Eugene Ride-Along Experience

  • Speaker completed training, joined CAHOOTS team
  • Call: man in mental health crisis, middle-income neighborhood, normal setting
  • Situation details:
    • Man locked in bathroom with box cutters
    • Talking about ending his life
    • Wife reported he felt like burden to family
    • CAHOOTS team talked through door for 1 hour
    • Man wouldn't come out initially
  • Police involvement:
    • Called 30 minutes after CAHOOTS left
    • Police waited for CAHOOTS return
    • Police convinced man to surrender box cutters
    • Police retreated downstairs after securing weapons
  • CAHOOTS intervention:
    • Team knelt to man's eye level (non-threatening approach)
    • 3-hour conversation on couch
    • Addressed financial burdens (unpaid medical bills visible)
    • Discussed resources, man ate sandwich
    • Monitored vitals throughout
    • Man transformed by end of encounter

Criminal Justice System Analysis

  • Speaker's career focus: criminal justice reform
  • System scale: 7,000 prisons/jails, 2.3 million inmates
  • Mass incarceration affects millions (judges, attorneys, officers, cops)
  • Current approach: one-size-fits-all (not working)
  • Alternative scenario consequences: 72-hour hold, incarceration, death, financial stress
  • Annual statistics: 2 million booked into jails/prisons
  • National Alliance for Mental Health: 83% lack mental health care access
  • Core principle: right tool at right time

Denver's Implementation

  • Co-responder model launched 2016
  • STAR program launched June 2020 ("baby CAHOOTS")
  • Current staffing:
    • 22 co-responders (mental health professionals with law enforcement)
    • 11 caseworkers
    • STAR team: paramedic + mental health professional in mobile crisis unit
  • STAR team functions: stabilize, de-escalate, connect to ongoing care resources

Program Results

  • STAR statistics since June:
    • 1,000 calls handled
    • 0 police backup requests needed
  • Co-responder model: <2% ticket/citation rate
  • Police support: officers requesting STAR in their precincts
  • Additional benefit: officers using co-responders for their own mental health trauma
  • Improved officer safety and profession-wide safety

Philosophy & Conclusion

  • "Caring for Denver" foundation: caring at heart of approach
  • Process: listen to concerns, connect to needed resources
  • Approach: kind and logical
  • Core principle: not every problem needs police, not everyone should go to jail
  • Focus on people, empathy, humanity
  • Call for smart criminal justice using right tool at right time