AI summary by TwinMind
What Is Good Art? : Crash Course Art History #6
CrashCourse
11m 35s
Introduction to Art Value
- Question: What makes artwork "good" - why Rosa Bonheur's horse painting in Metropolitan Museum vs. third-grade artwork
- Art value shifts based on viewer, culture, time periods
- Constantly changing minds about what constitutes good art
- Multiple ways to determine value beyond monetary price
Non-Monetary Value Aspects
- Message conveyed by artwork
- Historical context and fit
- Emotional impact on viewers
- Example: Personal connection to father's bird sculpture vs. toaster
Aesthetics and Beauty Standards
- Beauty as value marker - shaped by cultural standards and trends
- Examples: Coil Shaki monolith and Michelangelo's David - both beautiful in their respective contexts
- Beauty standards vary by culture and time period
Innovation and New Perspectives
- Art doesn't always aim for beauty - can accomplish other goals
- Dorothea Lange case study:
- 1942 California photo of Japanese American children at internment camp
- Rose to prominence in 1930s photographing migrant workers during Great Depression
- Contracted by US government for rural poor documentation
- Famous "Migrant Mother" photo
- After Pearl Harbor, documented forced removal of Japanese Americans
- Photo shows children with fear, identification tags emphasizing dehumanization
- Government censored many photos, kept from public view for decades
- Now housed at Oakland Museum of California, digitized in "Exposing Injustice" presentation
- Art provokes sorrow, pain, sympathy, remorse - not just pleasure
Artwork Lore and Reputation
- Mona Lisa case study:
- Not always world's most valuable artwork
- Overshadowed by Da Vinci's other works (Last Supper) for most of its life
- August 21, 1911: Stolen from Louvre, hidden under thieves' clothes
- Museum staff took 26 hours to realize theft
- Made worldwide headlines, missing for 2 years
- Thief caught trying to sell in Florence gallery
- Returned to Louvre 1914 with new reputation as most famous artwork
- Lore influences perception of worth
Art Criticism Evolution
- 18th century European art criticism major influence on art history
- Critics like Denis Diderot and Étienne Léonard de Saintien
- Believed art should have moral/philosophical messages
- Excluded works not fitting their definitions (Korean tea bowl example)
- Dismissed Rococo style as reflecting loose morals of French aristocrats
- Promoted classical art as serious and substantial
- Led to neoclassical art wave
20th Century Shift
- Abstract art emergence without ethical messages
- Clement Greenberg (American art critic):
- Good art pushes boundaries, breaks tradition
- Supported abstract pieces like Piet Mondrian painting
- Bad art was "kitsch" - tasteless, overly sentimental, commercialized
- Criticized Norman Rockwell's 1941 "Freedom from Want" as mass appeal art
- Critics' opinions have ripple effects on art styles and public perception
Museums and Collections
- Museum collections based on opinions and biases
- Guggenheim Museum started as Solomon R. Guggenheim's private collection
- Gap between perceived museum value and actual experience
- Mona Lisa: 30,000 daily visitors, less than 1 minute viewing time, 2.5 feet tall, often disappointing experience
Conclusion on Art Value
- No objective answer to what makes art good or bad
- Cultural context provides deeper understanding
- Art valuable beyond price, fame, critical acclaim
- Evaluation says more about ourselves and cultural contexts than the art
- Breaking down barriers allows appreciation of different periods and cultures
- Art in homes and communities has value even if not in prestigious museums
