AI summary by TwinMind
What is Real? (Lee Smolin) | AI Podcast Clips
Lex Fridman
22m 17s
Definition of Reality and Realism
- Opening question: "What is real?" - how do we distinguish reality from human perception/imagination
- Smolin's position: believes in world independent of human existence, experience, knowledge - calls this "the real world"
- Realism defined: belief in external world independent of our existence, perception, belief, knowledge
- Physicist realist: believes possible to have completely objective description of each fundamental process
- Determinism question: Smolin could accept fundamental world with chance, thinks "theories can change without warning" - future is open
- Fundamental laws of physics themselves might change
Human Perception and Brain Processing
- What we experience is constructed by brains in active mode
- Don't see raw world - see very processed world through our brains
- Behind experience there's still real world ("mirror veil")
- Two questions about consciousness:
- Does conscious mind play role in making things become real? (Smolin: doesn't think so)
- Can naturalist/realist view explain existence of consciousness? (hopes so, but doesn't yet)
Tools for Understanding Reality
- Humans naturally curious like cave ancestors - look at sun, moon, stars
- Make up stories and explanations quickly for survival ("is that a tiger?")
- Act fast on incomplete information - often wrong, fool ourselves and others
- Being "right" means coming closer to exact description of real world
- Relative scale: more right vs less right, not absolute right/wrong
Critique of Scientific Method
- Influenced by Paul Feyerabend (student of Karl Popper)
- No single scientific method exists
- Feyerabend argued: any proposed rule for science can be shown to need violation for progress
- Science as community bound by ethical precepts: don't lie, report all results
- Scientific training consists mostly of checking methods (error-prone humans need tools)
- PhD = ability to form convincing case colleagues can't "shout down"
Experimental Validation Complexity
- Not simple relationship between experiment and hypothesis/theory
- Galileo tower experiment example:
- Ball drops at base of tower
- Aristotelian: proves earth not moving
- Galileo: principle of inertia explains this while earth moves
- Need interconnected cases, took centuries (till Newton 1687) for transition from Aristotelian to new physics
Scientific Revolution and Progress
- Major scientific revolution: 1890s-1940s (possibly extending to 1970s)
- Key discoveries: relativity, electromagnetism confirmation, atomic structure, quantum mechanics (1905-late 1920s)
- This partial revolution basis for modern electrical technology, electrification of cities
- Fundamental physics since early 1970s lacks similar story of triumphs/practical applications
Anti-Realism in Quantum Physics
- Many quantum physics inventors were anti-realists
- Lived in perilous times between world wars, cultural trends influenced thinking
- Niels Bohr's view: science purpose not objective description of nature in our absence
- Purpose: extension of conversations, describe our interactions with nature
- Free to use terms like particle, wave, causality, time, space if useful
- Shouldn't believe these correspond to what nature would be like without us
Future of Understanding Reality
- Smolin finds anti-realist storytelling compelling but hopes stories will lead to discovering real world
- Perfect understanding question for people 5,000 years in future
- Currently nowhere near complete understanding
- Question of cognitive limits for descendants of apes - also for distant future
- References David Deutsch's universality arguments about explanation and mathematical systems
- Universality of mathematics/computing might enable unlimited understanding
- "We're doing okay so far" but must wait to see if limits exist
