AI summary by TwinMind
What is the Bechdel Test? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
42m 17s
Podcast Introduction and Setup
- Josh and Chuck from Stuff You Should Know discuss the Bechdel Test
- Credits Mark Mancini (HowStuffWorks), Vogue article, Douglas Lamon (Collider), Thomas Butt, Danielle Baronda (The Mary Sue)
- Mentions iHeart Network's "The Bechdel Cast" hosted by Caitlin Durante and Jamie Loftus
Casablanca Example and Test Definition
- Casablanca has 6 entries on AFI's 100 movie quotes list (most from single film)
- Classic movie with Lauren Bacall but no woman-to-woman conversations
- Bechdel Test three requirements:
- At least two named female characters
- Who talk to each other
- About something other than a man
Statistics on Gender Representation
- USC Annenberg study: 33.1% of speaking roles in top 100 grossing 2018 films went to women (67% to men)
- 2007: only 29.9% went to women (3% increase over 11 years)
- Majority of bit parts (cops, doctors, presidents, soldiers) typically filled by men
- Crowd scenes predominantly white men
- Kate Hagan (The Blacklist): "once you see this you can never unsee it"
Origins of the Bechdel Test
- Created by Alison Bechdel in 1985 comic strip "Dykes to Watch Out For"
- Panel titled "The Rule" with credit to Liz Wallace
- Became widespread online in 2000s through feminist and film communities
- Virginia Woolf connection: wrote about women characters only shown in relation to men
- Bechdel prefers "Bechdel-Wallace test" to credit her friend
Movie Examples - Failures
- AFI's top 100 movies (1916-2001): 70% failed Bechdel Test
- Recent failures: Thor: Ragnarok (2017), Avatar, La La Land, Girl with Dragon Tattoo, Gravity
- Best Picture winners: less than half passed historically
- 2020 nominees that failed: The Irishman, 1917, Ford vs Ferrari, Joker, Marriage Story, Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
- Since 2018: 5 of 6 Best Picture winners passed (Nomadland, CODA, Everything Everywhere All at Once, Parasite, Shape of Water)
Movie Examples - Surprising Passes/Failures
- Surprising passes: Goodfellas (mob wives scene), American Pie 2, Showgirls, Weird Science, Guardians of the Galaxy
- Jackie Brown example: strong female protagonist (Pam Grier) but fails test - shows test limitations
- Rear Window passes: Grace Kelly and Thelma Ritter investigate crime together
Test Limitations and Criticisms
- Martha Lausen (San Diego State): calls it "lowest possible bar" for assessing female character quality
- Gravity fails (no other female characters) vs American Hustle passes (sexualized portrayals)
- Test as conversation starter rather than definitive measure
- Pass/fail nature doesn't capture nuance of representation
Contemporary Issues and Broader Context
- 1985 creation during less feminist-friendly era in Hollywood
- Stalking portrayed as romantic in films (Lloyd Dobler example)
- Sexual assault as plot device
- Older women (31+) face casting difficulties, stereotypical roles
- Gina Davis Institute studies gender in media
- 6,000 films (2006-2009): zero showed women in actual positions of power
Alternative Tests and Improvements
- 2017 538 campaign: 12 industry women suggest improvements
- Four categories: behind camera, intersectional, protagonist, supporting cast
- Mako Mori test: female character with own narrative arc
- Sexy lamp test (Kelly Sue DeConnick): if character replaceable with lamp, story has problems
- Behind-camera representation worst performing area
Current Statistics and Progress
- 2023 USC Annenberg report (2022 data): 9% of top 100 films directed by women, 2.7% by women of color
- Female directors increase female speaking roles to 47.6% (vs 33.1% overall)
- Independent film performs better than Hollywood blockbusters
- TV historically better at female representation than movies
Solutions and Impact
- Vote with feet: don't support films failing important tests
- Sweden assigns gender bias ratings to films
- Importance of representation in shaping reality expectations
- Children's unconscious absorption of gender roles from media
