AI summary by TwinMind
What Makes Someone Vote Against Their Political Party? | Sarah Longwell | TED
TED
11m 16s
Introduction - TV Show Survivor and Tribal Instincts
- Sarah Longwell introduces herself, favorite show Survivor
- Survivor format: people on desert island, make fire/shelter, form tribes, vote out members weekly
- Show ran 45 seasons, versions in different countries
- Show's popularity stems from relatable anxiety of tribal rejection
- Social scientists/anthropologists: nothing more traumatic than being kicked out of tribe
- Humans crave community, belonging - tribal instincts hardwired for survival
- Current politics defined by partisan tribalism
Initial Resistance to TED Topic
- TED gave topic "democracy over party" - asking people to go against tribe
- Initially rejected topic after listening to thousands of American voters
- Voters don't feel connection to democracy like they do to political team/partisan tribe
- Most American voters don't think about democracy at all
2018 Experience - Traditional Republican Concerns
- Longwell: "average traditional lesbian Republican" in 2018
- Alarmed by Trump's impact on Republican party
- Attempted to convince governor, congressmen to primary Trump
- Politicians wanted to know if they could win primary against Trump
- Started polling/focus groups to make case for Trump alternative
Focus Group Findings on Trump Support
- Republicans liked Trump fine, thought he was funny, good businessman
- Appreciated he "told it like it was," wasn't regular politician
- Voters immune to Trump's anti-democratic behavior
- Never heard voter say they liked Trump for "authoritarian vibes"
- Voters didn't care about or recognize anti-democratic behavior:
- Trump praising dictators
- Hijacking foreign policy for political purposes (impeachment)
- Using White House to enrich family
- Trump member of their tribe = benefit of doubt
- Even Republicans who disliked Trump recoiled at direct attacks
- Especially attacks from outside tribe: deep state, media, Democrats, never-trumpers
Republican Voters Against Trump Strategy
- Primaries ruled out, needed general election strategy
- Required building permission structures for disaffected Republicans
- Needed trusted messengers - but Republicans didn't trust institutions, experts, even Republican politicians
- Breakthrough: video testimonials from regular Republicans explaining why couldn't vote Trump 2020
- People listened because they trust "people like them" - tribe members without special expertise
- Asked Republicans to send video stories (easier during pandemic - phone videos)
Building New Tribe
- Initially difficult - people nervous about publicly opposing Trump
- Feared neighbors, spouse, parents finding out
- Tribalism makes people afraid to go against tribe
- First 100 testimonials hard to obtain
- Once launched "Republican voters against Trump" - testimonials flooded in unsolicited
- People needed tribe to attach to for safety/security
- "Safety in numbers" principle
Testimonial Content Analysis
- None mentioned democracy
- Talked about Republican values, why those values meant couldn't vote Trump
- Discussed pain of voting for Democrats
- Didn't say putting "democracy over party" but that's exactly what they did
- Broke from tribe, voted against president threatening democracy
2022 Election Patterns
- After January 6th attack on Capitol
- Republican candidates running on "stolen election" platforms
- Democrats talked about democracy, swing voters didn't
- Swing voters focused on Republicans being "too extreme" - mainly abortion
- Didn't view as democracy threat, just thought candidates were "nuts"
Democracy as "Air We Breathe"
- Voters not talking about democracy doesn't mean they don't understand/value it
- Democracy like air - ingrained in American identity
- Hard to see when under threat
- Can't just say "democracy" and expect shared understanding
- Republicans: biggest threat to democracy = Democrats (rigged 2020 election)
- Democrats: biggest threat = Republicans (attacked Capitol, denied election results)
Better Democracy Messaging Strategy
- Need to talk about democracy better
- Explain what democracy is and why it's good
- Define liberal democracy components: pluralism, free speech, rule of law
- Show how these underpin free society and American identity
- Tell better story about America where politics isn't zero-sum
- Create "big tribe" of America predicated on democratic values
- Big enough to hold all smaller tribes: Progressive Bernie Bros, Evangelical Christians, lesbian Republicans
Political Coalition Building Approach
- Precarious moment for American democracy
- If democracy fails in America, harder for democracy to survive globally
- Won't defeat dangerous Republican Party by telling people "democracy over party"
- Must win elections through dominant political coalition
- Use permission structures and trusted messengers
- Focus on center-right and other margins
- Short-term wins enable long-term democracy story telling
Conclusion - Opportunity in Voter Apathy
- Voters not thinking about democracy = greatest opportunity
- Chance to rekindle love of democracy for new generation
- If successful, won't need to ask people to put democracy over party
