AI summary by TwinMind

What Makes Someone Vote Against Their Political Party? | Sarah Longwell | TED

TED

11m 16s

Introduction - TV Show Survivor and Tribal Instincts

  • Sarah Longwell introduces herself, favorite show Survivor
  • Survivor format: people on desert island, make fire/shelter, form tribes, vote out members weekly
  • Show ran 45 seasons, versions in different countries
  • Show's popularity stems from relatable anxiety of tribal rejection
  • Social scientists/anthropologists: nothing more traumatic than being kicked out of tribe
  • Humans crave community, belonging - tribal instincts hardwired for survival
  • Current politics defined by partisan tribalism

Initial Resistance to TED Topic

  • TED gave topic "democracy over party" - asking people to go against tribe
  • Initially rejected topic after listening to thousands of American voters
  • Voters don't feel connection to democracy like they do to political team/partisan tribe
  • Most American voters don't think about democracy at all

2018 Experience - Traditional Republican Concerns

  • Longwell: "average traditional lesbian Republican" in 2018
  • Alarmed by Trump's impact on Republican party
  • Attempted to convince governor, congressmen to primary Trump
  • Politicians wanted to know if they could win primary against Trump
  • Started polling/focus groups to make case for Trump alternative

Focus Group Findings on Trump Support

  • Republicans liked Trump fine, thought he was funny, good businessman
  • Appreciated he "told it like it was," wasn't regular politician
  • Voters immune to Trump's anti-democratic behavior
  • Never heard voter say they liked Trump for "authoritarian vibes"
  • Voters didn't care about or recognize anti-democratic behavior:
    • Trump praising dictators
    • Hijacking foreign policy for political purposes (impeachment)
    • Using White House to enrich family
  • Trump member of their tribe = benefit of doubt
  • Even Republicans who disliked Trump recoiled at direct attacks
  • Especially attacks from outside tribe: deep state, media, Democrats, never-trumpers

Republican Voters Against Trump Strategy

  • Primaries ruled out, needed general election strategy
  • Required building permission structures for disaffected Republicans
  • Needed trusted messengers - but Republicans didn't trust institutions, experts, even Republican politicians
  • Breakthrough: video testimonials from regular Republicans explaining why couldn't vote Trump 2020
  • People listened because they trust "people like them" - tribe members without special expertise
  • Asked Republicans to send video stories (easier during pandemic - phone videos)

Building New Tribe

  • Initially difficult - people nervous about publicly opposing Trump
  • Feared neighbors, spouse, parents finding out
  • Tribalism makes people afraid to go against tribe
  • First 100 testimonials hard to obtain
  • Once launched "Republican voters against Trump" - testimonials flooded in unsolicited
  • People needed tribe to attach to for safety/security
  • "Safety in numbers" principle

Testimonial Content Analysis

  • None mentioned democracy
  • Talked about Republican values, why those values meant couldn't vote Trump
  • Discussed pain of voting for Democrats
  • Didn't say putting "democracy over party" but that's exactly what they did
  • Broke from tribe, voted against president threatening democracy

2022 Election Patterns

  • After January 6th attack on Capitol
  • Republican candidates running on "stolen election" platforms
  • Democrats talked about democracy, swing voters didn't
  • Swing voters focused on Republicans being "too extreme" - mainly abortion
  • Didn't view as democracy threat, just thought candidates were "nuts"

Democracy as "Air We Breathe"

  • Voters not talking about democracy doesn't mean they don't understand/value it
  • Democracy like air - ingrained in American identity
  • Hard to see when under threat
  • Can't just say "democracy" and expect shared understanding
  • Republicans: biggest threat to democracy = Democrats (rigged 2020 election)
  • Democrats: biggest threat = Republicans (attacked Capitol, denied election results)

Better Democracy Messaging Strategy

  • Need to talk about democracy better
  • Explain what democracy is and why it's good
  • Define liberal democracy components: pluralism, free speech, rule of law
  • Show how these underpin free society and American identity
  • Tell better story about America where politics isn't zero-sum
  • Create "big tribe" of America predicated on democratic values
  • Big enough to hold all smaller tribes: Progressive Bernie Bros, Evangelical Christians, lesbian Republicans

Political Coalition Building Approach

  • Precarious moment for American democracy
  • If democracy fails in America, harder for democracy to survive globally
  • Won't defeat dangerous Republican Party by telling people "democracy over party"
  • Must win elections through dominant political coalition
  • Use permission structures and trusted messengers
  • Focus on center-right and other margins
  • Short-term wins enable long-term democracy story telling

Conclusion - Opportunity in Voter Apathy

  • Voters not thinking about democracy = greatest opportunity
  • Chance to rekindle love of democracy for new generation
  • If successful, won't need to ask people to put democracy over party

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome