AI summary by TwinMind

What Rising Rates ACTUALLY Mean For Your Investments

The Plain Bagel

13m 59s

Introduction & Context

  • Video sponsored by Blinkist (blinkist.com/theplainbagel - 1 week free + 25% off premium)
  • After decade+ of rock bottom interest rates (including negative rates in some areas), rates finally rising
  • First rate hike environment many retail investors will experience
  • Central bank policy rates core component of economy - as they rise, other rates follow (mortgages, bond yields, GICs, savings accounts)

Theoretical Impact of Rising Rates

  • Fixed Income/Bonds: Explicit negative relationship - as rates rise, bond prices fall
    • Example: $1 bond paying 3% yield becomes less attractive when 4-5% bonds available
    • Existing bondholders must sell at discount to offer competitive yield
    • Good for new buyers, bad for existing holders
  • Stocks: Generally viewed as broad negative for investment prices
    • Higher borrowing costs hurt consumers/companies with high debt levels globally
    • Should theoretically depress stock prices

Rate Hike Mechanics

  • Federal funds rate (US) = rate banks lend to each other
  • Central banks use tools to increase/decrease rates for monetary policy objectives
  • March rate hike pushes up all economy interest rates
  • Banks maintain spread between borrowing rate and lending rates
  • Affects: mortgages, corporate bonds, lines of credit, credit cards
  • Current environment: inflation rising after aggressive monetary stimulus + pandemic supply chain issues
  • Multiple rate hikes signaled as inbound

Stock Market Theory vs Reality

  • Theoretical negatives:
    • Consumers: reduced discretionary income from higher mortgage/car payments
    • Governments: higher debt servicing costs, potential spending cuts
    • Companies: lower revenues from budget-conscious consumers + higher interest expenses
    • Reduced business investment (new products, facilities, acquisitions) due to expensive debt
    • Valuation impact: rising fixed income yields draw money from stocks
    • Example: GIC going from 2% to 4-6% makes 8% stock return less attractive risk-reward
    • 10-year Treasury rate vs S&P 500 P/E ratio shows inverse relationship
    • Double whammy: compressed profit margins + lower valuations

Sector-Specific Impacts

  • Hardest hit (theoretically):
    • Growth stocks: require more capital (expensive as rates rise), valuations based on future profits 5-6 years out
    • Tech sector: embodiment of growth style
    • Bond-like securities: REITs, utilities focused on dividend yield
    • Real estate: more expensive property purchases
  • Expected beneficiaries:
    • Banks: borrowing costs rise but offset by greater earned interest
    • Insurance companies: bond portfolio declines but offset by higher interest earnings
    • Value stocks: already depressed valuations, current profits more valued in rising rate environment

Historical Data Reality Check

  • Surprising results: Stocks performed well during past rate hike cycles
  • Initial drop when rate hikes begin, but overall performance strong
  • Truist Advisory Services data: Past 12 rate hike cycles, S&P 500 averaged 9.4% annualized returns
  • S&P 500 average return 1957-2021: ~10.5%
  • Sector performance: Technology and real estate topped recent rate hike cycles (opposite of theory)

Why Theory Doesn't Match Reality

  • Interest rates have little predictive power over stock performance
  • Multiple variables influence performance simultaneously
  • Rate hikes often occur during robust economic activity
  • Companies may not see material profit growth impact despite slower economy
  • Market pricing: Investors price in rate hikes before they occur
    • Tesla, Palantir fell before first US rate hike in anticipation
    • If multiple hikes already priced in, actual hikes may not impact performance

Gold & Crypto Considerations

  • Gold: Theoretically rates should draw money from gold to fixed income
    • Gold prices do move against yields when graphed
    • But gold also inflation hedge - unclear overall movement with rising inflation
  • Crypto: First real rate hike cycle in crypto space
    • Only time will tell impact and if variable matters to performance

Current Environment Unique Factors

  • High debt levels: US federal debt-to-GDP ratio near all-time high of 125%
  • High stock valuations: approaching all-time highs
  • Rising rates identified as key contributor to past recessions
  • Chance of broader economic slowdown even if stocks perform okay
  • Context matters - current situation could lead to very different impact than historical

Investment Strategy Recommendations

  • Don't use rates alone as indicator for asset allocation cycling
  • Diversification: Spread across assets that perform well in both rising and falling rate environments
  • Active investors: Incorporate rate hikes into research
    • Review company debt levels in financials
    • Many firms report expected earnings impact from rate changes in filings
  • Don't ignore rising rates - significant for consumers and companies
  • Far from predictor of future performance

Sponsor Content

  • Blinkist features:
    • Mobile app summarizing nonfiction books
    • Read/listen to summaries under 15 minutes typically
    • 5000+ titles across various topics
    • Finance pieces including "The Black Swan" by Nassim Taleb
    • New features: podcast summaries (short casts), discounted full-length audiobooks
    • blinkist.com/theplainbagel - 1 week free + 25% off membership

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome