AI summary by TwinMind
What Rising Rates ACTUALLY Mean For Your Investments
The Plain Bagel
13m 59s
Introduction & Context
- Video sponsored by Blinkist (blinkist.com/theplainbagel - 1 week free + 25% off premium)
- After decade+ of rock bottom interest rates (including negative rates in some areas), rates finally rising
- First rate hike environment many retail investors will experience
- Central bank policy rates core component of economy - as they rise, other rates follow (mortgages, bond yields, GICs, savings accounts)
Theoretical Impact of Rising Rates
- Fixed Income/Bonds: Explicit negative relationship - as rates rise, bond prices fall
- Example: $1 bond paying 3% yield becomes less attractive when 4-5% bonds available
- Existing bondholders must sell at discount to offer competitive yield
- Good for new buyers, bad for existing holders
- Stocks: Generally viewed as broad negative for investment prices
- Higher borrowing costs hurt consumers/companies with high debt levels globally
- Should theoretically depress stock prices
Rate Hike Mechanics
- Federal funds rate (US) = rate banks lend to each other
- Central banks use tools to increase/decrease rates for monetary policy objectives
- March rate hike pushes up all economy interest rates
- Banks maintain spread between borrowing rate and lending rates
- Affects: mortgages, corporate bonds, lines of credit, credit cards
- Current environment: inflation rising after aggressive monetary stimulus + pandemic supply chain issues
- Multiple rate hikes signaled as inbound
Stock Market Theory vs Reality
- Theoretical negatives:
- Consumers: reduced discretionary income from higher mortgage/car payments
- Governments: higher debt servicing costs, potential spending cuts
- Companies: lower revenues from budget-conscious consumers + higher interest expenses
- Reduced business investment (new products, facilities, acquisitions) due to expensive debt
- Valuation impact: rising fixed income yields draw money from stocks
- Example: GIC going from 2% to 4-6% makes 8% stock return less attractive risk-reward
- 10-year Treasury rate vs S&P 500 P/E ratio shows inverse relationship
- Double whammy: compressed profit margins + lower valuations
Sector-Specific Impacts
- Hardest hit (theoretically):
- Growth stocks: require more capital (expensive as rates rise), valuations based on future profits 5-6 years out
- Tech sector: embodiment of growth style
- Bond-like securities: REITs, utilities focused on dividend yield
- Real estate: more expensive property purchases
- Expected beneficiaries:
- Banks: borrowing costs rise but offset by greater earned interest
- Insurance companies: bond portfolio declines but offset by higher interest earnings
- Value stocks: already depressed valuations, current profits more valued in rising rate environment
Historical Data Reality Check
- Surprising results: Stocks performed well during past rate hike cycles
- Initial drop when rate hikes begin, but overall performance strong
- Truist Advisory Services data: Past 12 rate hike cycles, S&P 500 averaged 9.4% annualized returns
- S&P 500 average return 1957-2021: ~10.5%
- Sector performance: Technology and real estate topped recent rate hike cycles (opposite of theory)
Why Theory Doesn't Match Reality
- Interest rates have little predictive power over stock performance
- Multiple variables influence performance simultaneously
- Rate hikes often occur during robust economic activity
- Companies may not see material profit growth impact despite slower economy
- Market pricing: Investors price in rate hikes before they occur
- Tesla, Palantir fell before first US rate hike in anticipation
- If multiple hikes already priced in, actual hikes may not impact performance
Gold & Crypto Considerations
- Gold: Theoretically rates should draw money from gold to fixed income
- Gold prices do move against yields when graphed
- But gold also inflation hedge - unclear overall movement with rising inflation
- Crypto: First real rate hike cycle in crypto space
- Only time will tell impact and if variable matters to performance
Current Environment Unique Factors
- High debt levels: US federal debt-to-GDP ratio near all-time high of 125%
- High stock valuations: approaching all-time highs
- Rising rates identified as key contributor to past recessions
- Chance of broader economic slowdown even if stocks perform okay
- Context matters - current situation could lead to very different impact than historical
Investment Strategy Recommendations
- Don't use rates alone as indicator for asset allocation cycling
- Diversification: Spread across assets that perform well in both rising and falling rate environments
- Active investors: Incorporate rate hikes into research
- Review company debt levels in financials
- Many firms report expected earnings impact from rate changes in filings
- Don't ignore rising rates - significant for consumers and companies
- Far from predictor of future performance
Sponsor Content
- Blinkist features:
- Mobile app summarizing nonfiction books
- Read/listen to summaries under 15 minutes typically
- 5000+ titles across various topics
- Finance pieces including "The Black Swan" by Nassim Taleb
- New features: podcast summaries (short casts), discounted full-length audiobooks
- blinkist.com/theplainbagel - 1 week free + 25% off membership
