AI summary by TwinMind
What role does luck play in your life? | Barry Schwartz
TED
10m 17s
Personal Anecdote - Former Student's Daughter
- Former student called about daughter applying to Swarthmore
- Daughter was high school senior, excellent credentials (grades, board scores, extracurriculars)
- Speaker described her as "superstar" and "fabulous" - exactly type Swarthmore would want
- Despite qualifications, no guarantee of admission due to limited spots
- Not enough spots at elite institutions: Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Stanford, Google, Amazon, Apple, TED
Current College Admissions System Problems
- Colleges respond to scarcity by continuously raising standards
- Creates "crazy competition" among high school students
- Not adequate to be "good enough" - must be better than all other applicants
- System violates justice principle: people should get what they deserve
- Contributing to epidemic of anxiety and depression among teenagers
- "Wrecking a generation" with this competitive pressure
Proposed Solution: Lottery-Based Admissions
- Distinguish between applicants good enough to succeed vs. those who aren't
- Reject unqualified applicants
- Put all qualified applicants' names in hat, select randomly
- Apply lottery system to:
- College admissions
- Job offers at tech companies
- TED speaker selection
- Lottery wouldn't eliminate injustice but would be honest about it
- Would relieve pressure on high school students
Why Lottery Proposal Gets No Serious Discussion
- People hate idea that important life events happen by luck/chance
- Dislike that important things aren't under our control
- College admissions already functions as lottery - admissions officers just pretend otherwise
- Need honesty about randomness in selection processes
Personal Examples of Luck in Speaker's Life
Marriage
- 7th grade: family moved from New York to Westchester County
- Met girl who became friend → best friend → girlfriend → wife
- Married 52 years - "had very little to do with this, was lucky accident"
Career in Psychology
- College first semester: signed up for intro psychology class
- Didn't know what psychology was, just fit schedule and requirements
- "By luck" taught by superstar teacher, became psychology major
- Went to graduate school as result
Academic Position at Swarthmore
- Friend at Swarthmore quit professorship for medical school
- Job opened up, speaker applied and got it
- Only job ever applied for
- Spent 45 years teaching at Swarthmore
- Institution had "enormous impact" on career shape
TED Speaking Platform
- Giving talk in New York, audience member named Chris approached
- Asked if speaker wanted to give TED talk
- Speaker's response: "What's TED?"
- TED talks since watched by 20+ million people
Conclusion About Luck and Desert
- Speaker considers himself "lucky man" - marriage, education, career, platform
- Acknowledges deserving success, but notes many equally deserving people lack same success
- "Do people get what they deserve? Is society just? Of course not"
- Working hard and playing by rules "no guarantee of anything"
Philosophical Framework: John Rawls' Theory of Justice
- Rawls wrote "Theory of Justice" ~50 years ago
- Introduced concept of "veil of ignorance"
- Question: if you didn't know your position in society, what society would you create?
- Answer: when uncertain about entering at top or bottom, want "pretty damn equal" society
- Even unlucky should live "decent, meaningful, and satisfying lives"
Call to Action
- Addressed to "lucky successful people"
- Bring awareness back to communities
- Honor and care for people "just as deserving of success as we are but just not as lucky"
- Specific mention of pandemic heroes facing illness costs
- What responsibilities do we have to those who struggle, work hard, but are less lucky?
