AI summary by TwinMind

What role does luck play in your life? | Barry Schwartz

TED

10m 17s

Personal Anecdote - Former Student's Daughter

  • Former student called about daughter applying to Swarthmore
  • Daughter was high school senior, excellent credentials (grades, board scores, extracurriculars)
  • Speaker described her as "superstar" and "fabulous" - exactly type Swarthmore would want
  • Despite qualifications, no guarantee of admission due to limited spots
  • Not enough spots at elite institutions: Harvard, Yale, Princeton, Stanford, Google, Amazon, Apple, TED

Current College Admissions System Problems

  • Colleges respond to scarcity by continuously raising standards
  • Creates "crazy competition" among high school students
  • Not adequate to be "good enough" - must be better than all other applicants
  • System violates justice principle: people should get what they deserve
  • Contributing to epidemic of anxiety and depression among teenagers
  • "Wrecking a generation" with this competitive pressure

Proposed Solution: Lottery-Based Admissions

  • Distinguish between applicants good enough to succeed vs. those who aren't
  • Reject unqualified applicants
  • Put all qualified applicants' names in hat, select randomly
  • Apply lottery system to:
    • College admissions
    • Job offers at tech companies
    • TED speaker selection
  • Lottery wouldn't eliminate injustice but would be honest about it
  • Would relieve pressure on high school students

Why Lottery Proposal Gets No Serious Discussion

  • People hate idea that important life events happen by luck/chance
  • Dislike that important things aren't under our control
  • College admissions already functions as lottery - admissions officers just pretend otherwise
  • Need honesty about randomness in selection processes

Personal Examples of Luck in Speaker's Life

Marriage

  • 7th grade: family moved from New York to Westchester County
  • Met girl who became friend → best friend → girlfriend → wife
  • Married 52 years - "had very little to do with this, was lucky accident"

Career in Psychology

  • College first semester: signed up for intro psychology class
  • Didn't know what psychology was, just fit schedule and requirements
  • "By luck" taught by superstar teacher, became psychology major
  • Went to graduate school as result

Academic Position at Swarthmore

  • Friend at Swarthmore quit professorship for medical school
  • Job opened up, speaker applied and got it
  • Only job ever applied for
  • Spent 45 years teaching at Swarthmore
  • Institution had "enormous impact" on career shape

TED Speaking Platform

  • Giving talk in New York, audience member named Chris approached
  • Asked if speaker wanted to give TED talk
  • Speaker's response: "What's TED?"
  • TED talks since watched by 20+ million people

Conclusion About Luck and Desert

  • Speaker considers himself "lucky man" - marriage, education, career, platform
  • Acknowledges deserving success, but notes many equally deserving people lack same success
  • "Do people get what they deserve? Is society just? Of course not"
  • Working hard and playing by rules "no guarantee of anything"

Philosophical Framework: John Rawls' Theory of Justice

  • Rawls wrote "Theory of Justice" ~50 years ago
  • Introduced concept of "veil of ignorance"
  • Question: if you didn't know your position in society, what society would you create?
  • Answer: when uncertain about entering at top or bottom, want "pretty damn equal" society
  • Even unlucky should live "decent, meaningful, and satisfying lives"

Call to Action

  • Addressed to "lucky successful people"
  • Bring awareness back to communities
  • Honor and care for people "just as deserving of success as we are but just not as lucky"
  • Specific mention of pandemic heroes facing illness costs
  • What responsibilities do we have to those who struggle, work hard, but are less lucky?

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome