AI summary by TwinMind
What should an electric car sound like?
Vox
5m 18s
Introduction to EV Sound Problem
- Traditional internal combustion engines inherently produce noise
- Air intake, exhaust, vibration, fuel combustion all create sound
- Carmakers spent decades trying to reduce noise but never eliminated it
- Electric vehicles are nearly silent by nature
- World built around automobiles relies on sound for safety
- Drivers expect audible feedback
- Pedestrians and cyclists listen for approaching cars
- Absence of sound creates safety hazards
AVAS Regulatory Requirements
- 2019: EU and US mandated EVs/hybrids play artificial sounds
- Acoustic Vehicle Alerting System (AVAS) uses hidden speakers
- Different global standards but common rule framework for sound designers
Volume/Sound Pressure Parameters
- AVAS must reach minimum decibel levels
- Volume increases with vehicle speed
- At 30+ km/h: tire/wind noise becomes louder than AVAS
- AVAS can fade out at higher speeds
Pitch Modulation Requirements
- Higher pitch as vehicle speeds up
- Lower pitch as vehicle slows down
- Allows passersby to judge vehicle speed by sound alone
Frequency Regulations
- Must hit minimum volume levels at high AND low frequencies
- High frequencies: cut through low-frequency background noise
- Low frequencies: cut through high-frequency background noise
- Most challenging constraint for sound designers
- Makes creating pleasant-sounding designs very difficult
Sound Design Challenges and Solutions
- Core challenge: create sounds that aren't too quiet but aren't annoying
- Easy to be alarming, very difficult to achieve good sound quality without annoyance
Technical Approach
- Designers create short, perfectly looping samples
- Samples play faster/slower based on vehicle speed
- Simple linear relationship doesn't match dynamic combustion engine sounds
- Linear pitching sounds predictable, uninteresting, artificial
- Like spinning LP player faster - sounds weird when pitched too fast
Advanced Design Techniques
- Layer additional samples, filters, modulations
- Triggered by specific driving conditions (full-throttle acceleration)
- Samples can be made from anything:
- Musical instruments (didgeridoo used for Cadillac)
- Entire orchestras with literal driving sound scores
- Combustion engine-inspired sounds
Skeuomorphism in EV Sound Design
- Design philosophy: new technology resembles real-world counterpart
- Historical examples:
- Early electric lights mimicked candles
- Early mobile apps mimicked physical objects
- Early 1900s patent: putting half horse on front of vehicle to make cars look familiar
- EVs don't need noise but must bridge gap from noisy cars to different-sounding future
- Designers working out what this transition should sound like
