AI summary by TwinMind
What was the purpose of USAID? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW
Stuff You Should Know
39m 51s
USAID Dissolution and Current Events
- June 30th, 2024: final day for most USAID employees
- July 1st, 2024: USAID absorbed into State Department
- Secretary of State Marco Rubio announced new foreign aid agency called "America First"
- Bono, George W. Bush, Obama made statements opposing dissolution
- Bush proud of PEPFAR (President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief) - saved 25 million lives
- Obama called ending USAID "colossal mistake"
- Bono: "If this isn't murder, I don't know what is"
US Foreign Aid Overview
- US historically largest single humanitarian aid donor globally
- Supplied ~40% of humanitarian aid in 2024
- $4 trillion distributed since WWII (today's dollars)
- Foreign aid = 1% of total federal budget
- USAID portion = 0.5% of federal budget
- Three categories:
- Humanitarian assistance: 25% (medicine, food, shelter after disasters)
- Development assistance: 60% (democratic nation building)
- Security funding: 15% (foreign military/police training)
USAID Origins and Cold War Context
- Created 1961 by John F. Kennedy
- Built on Marshall Plan foundation (1947, $175 billion today's dollars)
- Influenced by MIT economists Walt Rostow and Max Millikan
- Kennedy initially opposed foreign aid as congressman
- Changed mind after 1951 7-week congressional trip to Pakistan, Israel, India, Malaysia, Thailand, Korea, Japan, French Indochina
- "The Ugly American" (1958) book major influence
- Criticized American diplomats in gated communities
- Advocated immersion in local culture/language
- Kennedy took out full-page NYT ad endorsing book
- Cuba falling to Castro (1959) created urgency
- Soft power strategy against Soviet/Chinese communist influence
- Kennedy sought 5-year budgets (rejected by Congress)
- Annual budget tied to congressional fights
Major USAID Successes
- Green Revolution (1960s):
- Led by Dr. Norman Borlaug
- Modernized agricultural practices in Asia
- Saved estimated 250 million lives from starvation
- Contrasted with China's Great Leap Forward (45 million deaths in 3 years)
- Smallpox eradication:
- Partnered with CDC
- Completely eliminated deadly childhood disease
- Only exists in Siberia and Atlanta labs today
- PEPFAR (President's Emergency Plan for AIDS Relief):
- Launched 2003 under Bush
- Saved 25 million lives
- Tuberculosis program: saved 58 million lives since 2000
- Malaria initiative: saved 12 million lives since 2000
- 48% decline in malaria deaths in participating countries
- Recent Lancet study: 91 million preventable deaths prevented since 2000
Major USAID Failures and Controversies
- Afghanistan disaster:
- $100+ billion in aid
- 40% went to government officials, warlords, drug lords, insurgents
- Money used to buy weapons to fight US
- $1.5 billion spent on opium transition program over 15 years
- Opium cultivation doubled 119% in Kandahar (2013-2015)
- Chemonics contract debacle:
- $9.5 billion contract (largest ever)
- Medical supplies delivery worldwide
- Poorly managed, false reporting, continued funding despite problems
- Alan Gross Cuba incident (2009):
- IT contractor sent to set up internet for Jewish community
- USAID illegal in Cuba, community didn't request service
- Gross arrested as spy, barely spoke Spanish
- US traded 3 Cuban spies from 1990s for his release
- Children of God Relief Institute Kenya:
- 2021 whistleblower reported child sex abuse cover-up
- USAID cut funding 2023, shared info with Kenyan police
Budget and Public Perception
- 2024 budget: $21.7 billion (0.3% of $6.8 trillion federal spending)
- Department of Defense: 13% of federal budget
- Department of Education: 4% (also being eliminated)
- Since 1980: USAID spending increased 106%, overall government spending ~200%
- Americans grossly overestimate foreign aid spending
- Think US spends 25% of budget on foreign aid
- Reality: ~1.2% in 2023
- 2019 Pew poll: 33% increase, 33% reduce, 33% keep same
Strategic and Political Implications
- USAID supports pro-democracy groups in authoritarian countries
- Provides implicit American protection for human rights activists
- Dissolution leaves vacuum for China to fill
- US: $3.8 trillion over 80 years since WWII
- China: $1 trillion in last 12 years
- Lancet estimates 14 million preventable deaths by 2030 due to cuts
- Loss of global goodwill and leverage
- Autocrats can now suppress democracy groups without US backing
