AI summary by TwinMind
What Xi Jinping Says About Alleviating Poverty
Asianometry
7m 57s
Xi Jinping's Role in Ning De
- Served as Communist Party chief of Ning De, Fujian province 1988-1990
- Medium-sized city with 2.8 million population, one of China's poorest cities
- Economy primarily agricultural subsistence farming
- Speeches from this period compiled as study materials for party faithful
Ning De's Economic Challenges
- Located in Fujian province, historically one of China's poorest regions
- Starved for resources from central government
- Economy largely unmodernized, heavily reliant on farming
- Unproductive agricultural land
- Described as "older revolutionary Soviet era with large minority populations"
- Recognized as having impoverished counties, receives preferential policy treatment
- Chronic poverty stretching back centuries
- Major export: people emigrating for work
- Han populations in Singapore and Taiwan originated from Fujian
- Local economy runs on remittances from overseas workers
- "Fujian the Philippines of China"
Xi's Development Philosophy
- Don't look to government for solutions
- Central government not positioned to help everyone in new economic era
- Differs from Mao revolutionary years when government provided everything
- Railway example: "Railways need huge funds, up to state planners to decide where/when to build"
- Acknowledged government won't funnel resources to poor areas
- Threaded needle between bad news and preventing social unrest
Economic Development Strategy
- "Super modest plan to riches" - long-term development through small steps
- Three-pronged approach:
- Develop three types of foreign-funded enterprises according to abilities
- Work on trade with Taiwan using traditional ports and coastal towns
- Create unique features in opening to outside world
Foreign Investment Approach
- Liberalize previously closed markets to attract foreign investment
- Offer cheap labor costs, tax breaks, reliable resources
- Beyond tax breaks: "Tax exemptions and deductions not as attractive as thought"
- Foreign companies want to make money and do business easily/smoothly
- Critical factors: reliable resources (water, electricity), government cooperation
- Taiwan Semiconductor example: reliable resources more important than tax breaks
Value Chain Development
- Upgrade existing capabilities to move up value chain
- Farm example: apple growers receiving grants to produce apple pies for higher margins
- Agriculture identified as Ning De's comparative advantage
- "Go beyond traditional farming under natural economy constraints"
- "Step up to big agriculture in comprehensive commodity economy"
Specialized Industry Development
- Target leading industries by town specialization:
- Gu Tien: deep processing of mushrooms
- Jerome: pharmaceuticals
- Shop: massage tools and seaweed/nori processing, mustard root
- Phuong: electrical machinery and ferro alloys
- Growth in leading industries drives upstream/downstream development
- Company town model: single large company employs majority of residents
Results and Current Status
- Economy developed in subsequent decades
- Ning De remains agricultural but scaled value chain
- Exports: fruits, specialty teas
- Aquaculture industry developed due to shallow seas
- Exports: yellow croakers, oysters, clams
- People remain poor, lagging behind provincial peers
- GDP per capita: ~$8,600 USD vs Fujian province average $14,000
- Population declining: lost 4,000 people from 2016-2017
- Brain drain to Shanghai, Shenzhen, Beijing for better opportunities
Broader Implications
- Ning De represents many Chinese towns/cities/provinces struggling with urbanization inequality
- Chinese economy advancing toward complex manufacturing/services
- Risk of leaving smaller areas further behind
- Questions about hope for poverty alleviation in such areas
