AI summary by TwinMind

When TSMC Sued SMIC and Won

Asianometry

16m 57s

Background and Context (2003)

  • TSMC facing competition from SMIC (Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corporation)
  • SMIC founded 2000 in Shanghai by Richard Chang
  • Growing suspiciously fast, stealing TSMC talent
  • TSMC suspected theft beyond just employees

Semiconductor Process Development Complexity

  • Thousands of manufacturing steps: etching, ion implantation, chemical mechanical polishing
  • New process node requires: R&D, equipment selection/integration, recipes, design rules
  • Recipes include: equipment settings, temperature, pressure, materials, duration
  • Trial and error process knowledge kept as trade secrets (not patented)
  • Typical China foundry timeline: 21-30 months for new process node

SMIC's Suspicious Speed

  • Founded April 2000
  • Broke ground August 2000 on Fab 1 (12,511 sq meters)
  • Completed June 2001
  • Equipment installation: 2 months
  • 0.18 micrometer process ready: 4 months later (zero non-conformances)
  • Volume production January 2002: 500 200mm wafers/month, scaling 2000/month
  • Total timeline: 6 months equipment to high volume production
  • Comparison: Grace Semiconductor announced 18-21 months for same process
  • Narrowed China tech gap from 4-5 generations to 1-2 generations in one year

Initial Legal Actions (2002-2003)

  • Early 2002: TSMC filed Taiwan lawsuit to prevent employee poaching
  • Won injunction but no mainland enforcement power
  • December 2003: Filed US lawsuit
  • SMIC structured as Cayman Islands corporation for US IPO (2004)
  • Significant portion of SMIC chips imported to US
  • Sought permanent ban on SMIC semiconductor imports to US

Evidence of Trade Secret Theft

Technical Analysis

  • Forensic analysis of Broadcom 0.18 micrometer chip made by SMIC
  • Logic process copied from TSMC
  • SMIC codename for TSMC recipes: "BKM1" (Best Known Method One)

Key Personnel Cases

C.Y. Shu (Technology Transfer Manager)

  • Managed TSMC trade secret records
  • Weekend before resignation (September 2001): observed photocopying piles of documents from Fab 4
  • Requested electronic/hard copies of thin film process improvements
  • Fab 4 made 0.18 micrometer semiconductors (same as SMIC Fab 1)

Katie Leo (Corporate Spy)

  • TSMC quality/reliability program manager until February 2001
  • Secretly joined SMIC July 2000 as founding project manager
  • Solicited key employees with 50,000-80,000 shares/stock options
  • CEO Marco Mora email: "I need help from you to pull out information from WSMSC and TSMC"
  • Email included specific list of technologies to copy from exact fabs
  • Convicted of corporate espionage in Taiwan, fled to PRC

Charles Chan (Broadcom Account Manager)

  • Had access to TSMC pricing, margins, technical specifications
  • Left March 2002 for SMIC
  • Used knowledge to help SMIC land Broadcom as client

Marketing Strategy

  • SMIC marketed as "TSMC compatible"
  • Claimed technologies so similar customers needed little design work to switch

Legal Proceedings and Settlements

2005 Settlement

  • SMIC paid $175 million over 6 years ($30M first 5 years, $25M sixth year)
  • Significant impact: SMIC made $120M profit in 2004, turned $66M loss in 2005
  • 6-year cross-licensing agreement
  • SMIC agreed to return stolen documents

2006 Breach and New Lawsuit

  • August 2006: TSMC filed for additional $130 million
  • SMIC never returned documents, continued copying
  • Revealed 15,000 documents totaling 500,000 pages
  • SMIC copied "word for word, line for line, diagram for diagram, even typographical error for typographical error"
  • November 2006: SMIC counter-sued in Beijing

2009 Final Resolution

  • California jury ruled SMIC breached agreement and stole trade secrets
  • $1 billion damages, permanent US ban on SMIC products
  • Richard Chang resigned
  • Final settlement: SMIC paid $200 million + granted TSMC 10% stake
  • TSMC gained say in rival's operations, incentive to keep company alive

Long-term Consequences

  • Lawsuit hamstrung SMIC's technological progress for decade
  • Customer trust issues with convicted plagiarist
  • Inability to innovate without understanding underlying technology
  • SMIC remained constant follower, lost precious development time
  • Only recently began independent development efforts

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome