AI summary by TwinMind

Where Does Your Sense of Self Come From? A Scientific Look | Anil Ananthaswamy | TED

TED

12m 32s

Personal Introduction and Context

  • Speaker met someone with schizophrenia episodes a decade ago
  • Person experienced changing sense of self, nebulous body boundaries, porous psychological self
  • Described as "altered sense of self" - different, not deficient
  • Acknowledged coping struggles with altered selves
  • Conversations with theologians, philosophers, neuroscientists led to understanding self's constructed nature

The Illusory Nature of Self

  • Self appears solid, unchanging, permanent but examination reveals questionable reality
  • Present when awake, disappears during sleep, reappears in dreams
  • Self is "slippery subject" - intuitively known but not as real as it seems
  • Self has no reality outside brain and body
  • Experiencing "I" may also be illusion - construction without constructor

Narrative Self and Alzheimer's Disease

  • Identity typically expressed through stories we tell others and ourselves
  • Stories considered sacrosanct but Alzheimer's reveals different reality
  • Alzheimer's progression:
    • Begins by affecting short-term memory
    • Impairs formation of short-term memory → prevents growth of narrative
    • Stories begin stalling upon disease onset
    • Eventually eats away at older long-term memories
  • Mid-stage Alzheimer's effects:
    • Patients can tell stories about themselves
    • Scramble up their narrative, mix up sequence of life episodes
    • Recall own stories inaccurately
    • Still a person experiencing scrambled narrative
  • End-stage effects:
    • Destroys narrative and much more
    • Unclear if someone still experiencing due to inability to communicate verbally
  • Demonstrates narrative self is brain/body construction that can be disrupted/destroyed

Body Ownership and Xenomilia

  • Basic feeling of owning our body and body parts seems undeniable
  • Xenomilia (foreign limb syndrome):
    • People feel body parts (usually extremities of hands/legs) don't belong to them
    • Opposite of phantom limb syndrome
    • Phantom limb: "animation without incarnation" (limb gone but animated in mind)
    • Xenomilia: "incarnation without animation" (limb present/healthy but feels foreign)
    • Brain/bodily processes for body ownership sense are misfiring
    • Serious consequences: people take extreme measures to amputate foreign-seeming body parts
  • Reveals sense of body ownership is construction that can go wrong

Sense of Agency and Schizophrenia

  • Normal sense of agency: implicit feeling of being agent of own actions (e.g., picking up cup)
  • Feeling of willing actions into existence
  • Schizophrenia effects:
    • May not always have sense of agency
    • Can do something without feeling like agent of that action
    • Possible to be someone who does something without accompanying sense of agency
  • Demonstrates sense of agency is also construction that can fail

Embodiment and Out-of-Body Experiences

  • Normal embodiment: feeling of being in body, anchored to body, occupying space volume, looking from behind eyes
  • Out-of-body experiences:
    • ~5% of general population experiences at some point
    • Feeling of being near ceiling looking down at own body
    • Mild versions replicated in labs
    • Result of misfiring brain processes
  • If out-of-body experiences are brain misfiring, then in-body experience is also construction that can come apart

Implications and Philosophical Perspective

  • Key insight: Everything we take as real about ourselves (bodies, stories) are not undeniable truths
  • When theologians/philosophers say self is illusion, this is partly what they mean
  • Remaining question: Who/what does the experiencing, even in altered selves?
  • Experiencing "I" doesn't disappear if few aspects of self disrupted
  • Unknown if experiencing "I" would disappear if all self aspects disrupted
  • Debate about experiencing "I" being illusion remains unresolved

Practical Applications and Wisdom

  • Individual response: Ideas feel liberating to some, heavy to others
  • Stories and emotions: Feelings/emotions modulated by stories, become part of stories
  • Narratives not just cognitive - live in bodies, bodies structure/shape stories
  • Letting go: Recognizing constructed nature allows holding less tightly to stories
  • Paradox: thing doing letting go is also thing that must be let go
  • Historical perspective: Marvel at efforts from Buddha under Bodhi Tree to modern philosophers/neuroscientists asking "who am I"

Empathy and Understanding

  • Debt to witnesses: Owe gratitude to those bearing witness to altered selves
  • Voluntary vs involuntary: Whether voluntary (monks/nuns meditating) or involuntary (biology/circumstance)
  • Robustness vs fragility: Self processes remarkably robust yet frighteningly fragile
  • Can crack at any time in anyone's life
  • Empathy imperative: Knowledge should make us empathetic toward those with altered selves
  • Reframing perspective: Altered selves not deficits or lack of normal attributes
  • Different ways of being exist
  • Willingness to confront self's constructed nature helps make sense of self for everyone

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome