AI summary by TwinMind
Where Does Your Sense of Self Come From? A Scientific Look | Anil Ananthaswamy | TED
TED
12m 32s
Personal Introduction and Context
- Speaker met someone with schizophrenia episodes a decade ago
- Person experienced changing sense of self, nebulous body boundaries, porous psychological self
- Described as "altered sense of self" - different, not deficient
- Acknowledged coping struggles with altered selves
- Conversations with theologians, philosophers, neuroscientists led to understanding self's constructed nature
The Illusory Nature of Self
- Self appears solid, unchanging, permanent but examination reveals questionable reality
- Present when awake, disappears during sleep, reappears in dreams
- Self is "slippery subject" - intuitively known but not as real as it seems
- Self has no reality outside brain and body
- Experiencing "I" may also be illusion - construction without constructor
Narrative Self and Alzheimer's Disease
- Identity typically expressed through stories we tell others and ourselves
- Stories considered sacrosanct but Alzheimer's reveals different reality
- Alzheimer's progression:
- Begins by affecting short-term memory
- Impairs formation of short-term memory → prevents growth of narrative
- Stories begin stalling upon disease onset
- Eventually eats away at older long-term memories
- Mid-stage Alzheimer's effects:
- Patients can tell stories about themselves
- Scramble up their narrative, mix up sequence of life episodes
- Recall own stories inaccurately
- Still a person experiencing scrambled narrative
- End-stage effects:
- Destroys narrative and much more
- Unclear if someone still experiencing due to inability to communicate verbally
- Demonstrates narrative self is brain/body construction that can be disrupted/destroyed
Body Ownership and Xenomilia
- Basic feeling of owning our body and body parts seems undeniable
- Xenomilia (foreign limb syndrome):
- People feel body parts (usually extremities of hands/legs) don't belong to them
- Opposite of phantom limb syndrome
- Phantom limb: "animation without incarnation" (limb gone but animated in mind)
- Xenomilia: "incarnation without animation" (limb present/healthy but feels foreign)
- Brain/bodily processes for body ownership sense are misfiring
- Serious consequences: people take extreme measures to amputate foreign-seeming body parts
- Reveals sense of body ownership is construction that can go wrong
Sense of Agency and Schizophrenia
- Normal sense of agency: implicit feeling of being agent of own actions (e.g., picking up cup)
- Feeling of willing actions into existence
- Schizophrenia effects:
- May not always have sense of agency
- Can do something without feeling like agent of that action
- Possible to be someone who does something without accompanying sense of agency
- Demonstrates sense of agency is also construction that can fail
Embodiment and Out-of-Body Experiences
- Normal embodiment: feeling of being in body, anchored to body, occupying space volume, looking from behind eyes
- Out-of-body experiences:
- ~5% of general population experiences at some point
- Feeling of being near ceiling looking down at own body
- Mild versions replicated in labs
- Result of misfiring brain processes
- If out-of-body experiences are brain misfiring, then in-body experience is also construction that can come apart
Implications and Philosophical Perspective
- Key insight: Everything we take as real about ourselves (bodies, stories) are not undeniable truths
- When theologians/philosophers say self is illusion, this is partly what they mean
- Remaining question: Who/what does the experiencing, even in altered selves?
- Experiencing "I" doesn't disappear if few aspects of self disrupted
- Unknown if experiencing "I" would disappear if all self aspects disrupted
- Debate about experiencing "I" being illusion remains unresolved
Practical Applications and Wisdom
- Individual response: Ideas feel liberating to some, heavy to others
- Stories and emotions: Feelings/emotions modulated by stories, become part of stories
- Narratives not just cognitive - live in bodies, bodies structure/shape stories
- Letting go: Recognizing constructed nature allows holding less tightly to stories
- Paradox: thing doing letting go is also thing that must be let go
- Historical perspective: Marvel at efforts from Buddha under Bodhi Tree to modern philosophers/neuroscientists asking "who am I"
Empathy and Understanding
- Debt to witnesses: Owe gratitude to those bearing witness to altered selves
- Voluntary vs involuntary: Whether voluntary (monks/nuns meditating) or involuntary (biology/circumstance)
- Robustness vs fragility: Self processes remarkably robust yet frighteningly fragile
- Can crack at any time in anyone's life
- Empathy imperative: Knowledge should make us empathetic toward those with altered selves
- Reframing perspective: Altered selves not deficits or lack of normal attributes
- Different ways of being exist
- Willingness to confront self's constructed nature helps make sense of self for everyone
