AI summary by TwinMind
Where is Kim Jong-Un?
PolyMatter
15m 20s
Kim Jong-Un's 2020 Disappearance
- April 11, 2020: Last public appearance at Workers' Party meeting
- Missed grandfather's birthday celebration (first time in 9 years in power)
- Disappeared for almost 3 weeks (20 days total)
- May 1st: Returned to inspect fertilizer factory outside Pyongyang
Media Escalation and Rumors
- Daily NK reported cardiovascular operation recovery (single unnamed source)
- CNN headline: "U.S. Source: North Korean leader in grave danger after surgery"
- MSNBC anchor (700,000 followers) tweeted news
- Media executive posted two candles on Weibo
- Photoshopped image of Kim Jong-Il's body with Kim Jong-Un's face circulated
- Fake video of Chinese military vehicles "rushing to border" (actually filmed in Jiangsu)
- South Korean lawmaker gave death 99% probability
- Senator Lindsey Graham: "shocked if he's not dead or incapacitated"
- Major South Korean newspaper published formal death announcement
- Reuters reported Beijing dispatched medical experts
- South's National Intelligence Service repeatedly denied unusual activity
Media Corrections and Backtracking
- Daily NK issued correction: based on single unnamed source
- CNN changed headline to more cautious language
- Previous tweets and posts deleted
- Media position: "he's either dead... or alive"
Possible Explanations for Absence
- Cardiovascular procedure theory
- New small mark on right wrist potentially indicating procedure
- Using golf cart (also used after 6-week absence in 2014 from ankle injury)
- Coronavirus outbreak hiding theory
- Pyongyang residents rushing to stock grocery stores
- Limited information due to lack of foreigners and minimal Chinese border travel
North Korean Leadership History
- 71 years existence: only 3 people, 1 family ruled DPRK
- Kim Il-Sung: 1948-1994 (46 years in power)
- During his reign: Japan had 21 Prime Ministers, Britain 11, US 9 presidents
- Age 60: began succession planning, chose son over brother
- Dictionary definition of 'hereditary succession' changed from "reactionary custom"
- Kim Jong-Il became Supreme Commander Korean People's Army 1991
- 1994: Heart attack killed Kim Il-Sung, smooth power transfer to son
- First hereditary transfer in Communist country
Kim Jong-Il's Complex Family Structure
- 1966: First marriage (father's request), daughter 1968, divorced 1969
- Secret second relationship: son Kim Jong-Nam
- Third marriage: two daughters
- Fourth relationship with dancer: daughter Yo-Jong, sons Jong-Chol and Jong-Un
- Children kept in separate walled residences in Pyongyang
- Jong-Nam sent to Geneva boarding school, youngest three to Bern
Succession Complications Under Kim Jong-Il
- Jong-Nam initially favored as eldest son
- May 2001: Caught entering Japan with fake Dominican Republic passport (Disney trip)
- Jong-Nam's mother (Moscow-based) vs Jong-Un's mother (politically ambitious)
- Jong-Nam offered deal: marry, have child, leave North Korea (moved to Macau)
- Jong-Chol considered too quiet/unmotivated
- Jong-Un chosen despite mother's issues (born Japan, never legally married, sister defected)
- 2008: Kim Jong-Il's stroke, Jong-Un officially chosen successor 5 months later
- December 17, 2011: Kim Jong-Il died of heart attack, Jong-Un inherited power at age 28
Current Succession Challenges
- No obvious next-in-line
- Three reported children, oldest only 10 years old
- Kim Jong-Un's poor physical health (5'7", 300 pounds, chain-smoker)
- 2017: Kim Jong-Nam assassinated at Kuala Lumpur airport
- Carrying $120,000 cash, suspected CIA informant
- Had 12 vials of antidotes
- Son Kim Han-Sol currently in hiding
Potential Successors
Kim Yo Jong (sister)
- Public role as brother's assistant
- Stands behind him at meetings, hands him pens
- 2018 Winter Olympics: stood for South Korean anthem, cheered unified-Korea flag
- High power accumulation and proximity indicates trust
- Kim family blood but patriarchal culture challenges
- Valuable asset to current leadership
Choe Ryong Hae (supposed father-in-law)
- Member of: party standing committee, central committee, military commission
- Deputy of Supreme People's Assembly
- Most powerful senior officials
- Lacks family blood/financial access
- Decades to build coalition for potential seizure
Kim Jong-Chol (older brother)
- Found in Pyongyang playing guitar or at Eric Clapton concerts
- No apparent political ambitions
Information Reliability Issues
- Limited sources: select few insiders living abroad
- Example: Kenji Fujimoto (former Kim family sushi chef)
- Few calibration opportunities
- North Korea disinterested in confirming/denying rumors
- Dilemma: can't totally disregard information but can't accept wholeheartedly
Historical Precedent for Transitions
- Kim Jong-Il's death December 2011: world oblivious for 51 hours
- South Korean president flew Tokyo, met PM, returned during transition
- Defense minister in meeting when announcement made
- Obama administration admitted being "largely bystanders"
- Smooth transition, no chaotic power struggle
- 25 million citizens didn't flood Chinese border
