AI summary by TwinMind

Why All Melodies Should Be Free for Musicians to Use | Damien Riehl | TED

TED

16m 16s

Speaker Background & Motivation

  • Speaker: Lawyer since 2002, musician with bachelor's in music, technologist coding since 1985
  • Colleague Noah Ruben: Brilliant programmer and musician
  • Combined expertise in law, music, and technology creates unique perspective on copyright issues

George Harrison Copyright Case Analysis

  • Harrison sued over "My Sweet Lord" vs Chiffons' "He's So Fine"
  • Judge ruled subconscious copying violated copyright despite Harrison's denial of conscious copying
  • Harrison paid substantial damages for allegedly unconscious infringement
  • Case highlights fundamental problem: finite number of possible melodies

Core Theory: Finite Melodic Space

  • Music has only 8 notes (do-re-mi-fa-so-la-ti-do) vs 117,000 words in English
  • Accidental melody duplication much more likely than accidental paragraph duplication
  • Visual art has infinite brush strokes, colors, subjects - music constrained to 8 notes
  • Melodies exist as mathematical combinations since beginning of time

Technical Implementation

  • Algorithm generates 300,000 melodies per second
  • Exhausted every possible melody within defined parameters
  • Hard drive contains "every melody that's ever existed and ever can exist"
  • Automatic copyright protection upon writing to fixed tangible medium

Legal Implications & Copyright Paradox

  • Pre-project: Songwriters had to avoid every existing song
  • Post-project: All possible melodies now copyrighted by speakers
  • Question: Have they infringed every existing melody? Will future songwriters infringe them?
  • Solution: Placing all generated melodies in public domain

Melody Parameters & Scope

  • Initial focus: 8 notes (white keys), 12 notes across, vocal range
  • Expanded to 12 notes (including black keys) for jazz/classical
  • Based on musicologist definitions of motifs vs longer melodies
  • Analyzed litigated cases to determine relevant melody length

Case Studies of Musical Lawsuits

  • Chiffons vs Harrison: "He's So Fine" vs "My Sweet Lord"
  • Tom Petty vs Sam Smith: "Won't Back Down" vs "Stay With Me" - 10 notes difference, $2.8M settlement
  • Radiohead "Creep" vs Hollies - forced co-songwriting credits
  • Katy Perry case: $2.8M judgment despite testimony of never hearing original song

Current Music Landscape Crisis

  • SoundCloud: 200 million songs uploaded
  • Each song contains up to 10 melodies/motifs
  • Basement musicians uploading to YouTube, Spotify, SoundCloud
  • Mathematical dataset being exhausted exponentially
  • Open melodic spaces shrinking rapidly

Access Problem in Copyright Law

  • Two-part infringement test: 1) Valid copyright 2) Infringement occurred
  • Infringement requires: a) Access to original b) Substantial similarity
  • Access determination problematic - most cases fall in gray area
  • Fact questions resolved only at trial end, not early dismissal
  • Creates untenable position for accused songwriters

Proposed Legal Solutions

  • Early evidentiary hearings to determine if melodies are copyrightable facts
  • Shift burden of proof back to plaintiffs to prove access
  • Recognize melodies as mathematical facts (like numbers) with thin/no copyright
  • Eliminate concept of subconscious infringement for melody-only cases

Project Goals & Public Access

  • Website: allthemusic.info - free download of all generated melodies
  • Open source code available for expansion
  • Preserve remaining "green spots" in public domain
  • Enable songwriters to create without fear of melodic landmines

Chilling Effect on Creativity

  • George Harrison stopped writing after trial, told Rolling Stone "every song sounds like something else"
  • Current system creates fear among songwriters
  • Paradox: Generated all melodies to give songwriters more freedom
  • Goal: Allow future songwriters to make music without copyright fear

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome