AI summary by TwinMind
Why All Melodies Should Be Free for Musicians to Use | Damien Riehl | TED
TED
16m 16s
Speaker Background & Motivation
- Speaker: Lawyer since 2002, musician with bachelor's in music, technologist coding since 1985
- Colleague Noah Ruben: Brilliant programmer and musician
- Combined expertise in law, music, and technology creates unique perspective on copyright issues
George Harrison Copyright Case Analysis
- Harrison sued over "My Sweet Lord" vs Chiffons' "He's So Fine"
- Judge ruled subconscious copying violated copyright despite Harrison's denial of conscious copying
- Harrison paid substantial damages for allegedly unconscious infringement
- Case highlights fundamental problem: finite number of possible melodies
Core Theory: Finite Melodic Space
- Music has only 8 notes (do-re-mi-fa-so-la-ti-do) vs 117,000 words in English
- Accidental melody duplication much more likely than accidental paragraph duplication
- Visual art has infinite brush strokes, colors, subjects - music constrained to 8 notes
- Melodies exist as mathematical combinations since beginning of time
Technical Implementation
- Algorithm generates 300,000 melodies per second
- Exhausted every possible melody within defined parameters
- Hard drive contains "every melody that's ever existed and ever can exist"
- Automatic copyright protection upon writing to fixed tangible medium
Legal Implications & Copyright Paradox
- Pre-project: Songwriters had to avoid every existing song
- Post-project: All possible melodies now copyrighted by speakers
- Question: Have they infringed every existing melody? Will future songwriters infringe them?
- Solution: Placing all generated melodies in public domain
Melody Parameters & Scope
- Initial focus: 8 notes (white keys), 12 notes across, vocal range
- Expanded to 12 notes (including black keys) for jazz/classical
- Based on musicologist definitions of motifs vs longer melodies
- Analyzed litigated cases to determine relevant melody length
Case Studies of Musical Lawsuits
- Chiffons vs Harrison: "He's So Fine" vs "My Sweet Lord"
- Tom Petty vs Sam Smith: "Won't Back Down" vs "Stay With Me" - 10 notes difference, $2.8M settlement
- Radiohead "Creep" vs Hollies - forced co-songwriting credits
- Katy Perry case: $2.8M judgment despite testimony of never hearing original song
Current Music Landscape Crisis
- SoundCloud: 200 million songs uploaded
- Each song contains up to 10 melodies/motifs
- Basement musicians uploading to YouTube, Spotify, SoundCloud
- Mathematical dataset being exhausted exponentially
- Open melodic spaces shrinking rapidly
Access Problem in Copyright Law
- Two-part infringement test: 1) Valid copyright 2) Infringement occurred
- Infringement requires: a) Access to original b) Substantial similarity
- Access determination problematic - most cases fall in gray area
- Fact questions resolved only at trial end, not early dismissal
- Creates untenable position for accused songwriters
Proposed Legal Solutions
- Early evidentiary hearings to determine if melodies are copyrightable facts
- Shift burden of proof back to plaintiffs to prove access
- Recognize melodies as mathematical facts (like numbers) with thin/no copyright
- Eliminate concept of subconscious infringement for melody-only cases
Project Goals & Public Access
- Website: allthemusic.info - free download of all generated melodies
- Open source code available for expansion
- Preserve remaining "green spots" in public domain
- Enable songwriters to create without fear of melodic landmines
Chilling Effect on Creativity
- George Harrison stopped writing after trial, told Rolling Stone "every song sounds like something else"
- Current system creates fear among songwriters
- Paradox: Generated all melodies to give songwriters more freedom
- Goal: Allow future songwriters to make music without copyright fear
