AI summary by TwinMind
Why America's North is Emptier Than Canada's South
RealLifeLore
30m 57s
Montana's Geographic Scale and Population Sparsity
- Montana: 4th largest US state, larger than Germany in area
- Population: only 1.14 million (2023) vs Germany's 84.5 million
- Population density: 2.9 people per sq km (3rd lowest in US after Alaska, Wyoming)
- Fewer people than New Hampshire (16x smaller than Montana)
- Only one city >100k: Billings (117,000 people)
- Would rank top 4 globally for lowest population density if independent country
Surrounding States' Similar Emptiness
- North Dakota: equivalent to Washington State size, 1/10th population
- Population density: 4.4 people per sq km (4th lowest US)
- Only city >100k: Fargo (131,000), located on Minnesota border
- South Dakota: ~900,000 residents total
- Largest city: Sioux Falls (202,000), located on Iowa/Minnesota border
- Wyoming: America's emptiest state after Alaska
- Population: 581,000 (2023), 10th largest state by area
- Largest town: Cheyenne (65,000)
- Combined Dakotas population = Manhattan population
- Montana + Wyoming + Nebraska + Idaho combined = Brooklyn + Queens + Staten Island
Canadian Prairie Provinces' Higher Density
- Alberta: population nearing 4.7 million
- More than twice Montana's population density
- Calgary: 1.64 million metro population
- Edmonton: 1.54 million metro population
- Edmonton: furthest north city in Americas >1 million people
- Manitoba: Winnipeg 840,000 people (more than all North Dakota)
- Saskatchewan:
- Saskatoon: 342,000 residents
- Regina: 250,000 people
- Top 5 Canadian prairie cities vastly larger than top 5 American northern interior cities
Geographic Factors: 98th Meridian Line
- Divides wet eastern US from arid western US
- East of line: 80% of US population, natural rainfall supports agriculture
- West of line: 20% of population in scattered dense islands
- Frontier cities straddle the divide: San Antonio, Austin, Oklahoma City, Omaha, Sioux Falls, Fargo
- Montana/Wyoming/Dakotas fall in dry zone between 98th meridian and Rocky Mountains
Mountain Ranges and Climate Patterns
- Western mountain ranges (Coast, Cascades, Rocky, Sierra Nevada) create rain shadow effect
- Pacific moisture released on westward mountain faces
- Dry winds blow down leeward side
- Eastern US receives Gulf of Mexico/Atlantic moisture, fails to penetrate past 98th meridian
- Montana/Wyoming/Dakotas: dry, arid, rugged, cold, very windy
- Lack of natural barriers = extremely windy conditions
Canadian Shield Geographic Barrier
- Covers nearly half of Canada
- Largest mass of exposed Precambrian rock on planet
- Glacial activity (2.6 million - 12,000 years ago) scraped away topsoil
- Exposed jagged bedrock with thin topsoil = poor for agriculture
- Largest settlement: Sudbury, Ontario (166,000 people)
- Forces Canadian population to live beyond shield boundaries
Early Canadian Settlement Patterns
- Concentrated around St. Lawrence River region
- Montreal: deepest navigable inland city from Atlantic until 1959
- St. Lawrence Seaway (1959): opened Great Lakes to ocean navigation
- Settlement crammed between Canadian Shield (north) and US border (south)
- Quebec City to Windsor corridor: >18 million people (>50% of Canadians)
- Great Lakes moderate climate, provide navigation access
Canadian Western Settlement Challenges
- 1200km of barren Canadian Shield separated prairies from eastern Canada
- Coast/Cascade mountains blocked access from Pacific
- American westward expansion pressured Canadian government to populate western provinces
- Palliser Expedition (1857-1859) surveyed western Canada
Aspen Parkland Discovery
- Three regions identified:
- Cold coniferous forest (north): inhospitable for agriculture
- Semi-arid steppe (south): extension of Great Plains
- Aspen Parkland (center): extremely rich, fertile narrow band
- Aspen Parkland: 150-300 miles wide, stretches from western Manitoba through Saskatchewan to Alberta
- Separate Peace River Country segment in northwestern Alberta
- Chernozem soil: preciously rare black soil type
- High moisture storage capacity
- High natural fertilizers (phosphorus, ammonia)
- Requires little external irrigation/fertilizer
- Highest concentrations globally in Ukraine and Canadian Aspen Parkland
Canadian Immigration and Agricultural Development
- Canadian government built railroads across shield to western fertile lands
- Recruited Ukrainian/Polish farmers from Russian/Austro-Hungarian empires
- 1896-1914: >2 million European/US settlers migrated to Canadian prairies
- Largest migration wave in Canadian history
- Canada has 3rd highest ethnic Ukrainian population globally
- Calgary, Edmonton, Saskatoon, Winnipeg founded in Aspen Parkland belt
- Manitoba/Saskatchewan/Alberta: >85% of Canada's arable land, >80% agricultural output
Oil Discovery and Development
- 1946: Canada produced 21,000 barrels/day, consumed 10x that amount
- 90% of oil imported from US
- February 1947: Leduc No. 1 well struck oil south of Edmonton
- First major conventional oil well in Canada
- Billions in investment poured into Alberta
- Within decade: Calgary/Edmonton populations doubled
- Alberta population growth: double-digit percentages every decade since
Oil Industry Structure
- Calgary: headquarters of Canadian energy companies
- Edmonton: oil hardware, refineries, processing facilities, pipeline hub
- Athabasca Oil Sands discoveries northeast/northwest of Edmonton
- Bitumen: semi-solid crude oil mixed with clay/sand/water
- Commercial development began late 1960s
- Oil sands reserves: 1.7 trillion barrels bitumen in place
- Comparable to world's proven conventional petroleum reserves combined
- 10% economically recoverable = Canada 3rd highest proven reserves globally
Modern Canadian Oil Production
- Alberta produces >80% of Canadian oil
- Canada: 4th largest oil producer globally (2022)
- More production than Iraq
- Behind only Russia, Saudi Arabia, US
- Pipelines run south to US Gulf Coast refineries
- Canada accounts for >50% of US petroleum imports (2022)
- Canada: 5th largest oil exporter globally
Alberta's Economic Success
- 2021 GDP per capita: $84,550 CAD (~$62,000 USD)
- Highest of any Canadian province
- Comparable to Florida
- Higher than Montana/Idaho
- Oil money invested in schools, highways, hospitals
- Highest Human Development Index (HDI) in Canada: 0.955
- Highest HDI in North America
- Only Iceland, Norway, Switzerland rank higher globally
Calgary-Edmonton Corridor
- 2nd most densely populated Canadian region (after Quebec-Windsor corridor)
- Home to >75% of Albertans
- >3.2 million people
- Greater than Vancouver metro population
- Roughly equivalent to Montana + North Dakota + South Dakota + Wyoming combined
- 2600km from Quebec-Windsor corridor
