AI summary by TwinMind
Why are adverts so loud?
Tom Scott
7m 58s
Introduction - Advertisement Loudness Comparison
- Demonstrated two NordVPN adverts with different perceived loudness
- Calm advert had higher decibel measurement but sounded quieter
- Shouting advert with background noise/music had lower decibels but sounded louder
Physics of Sound - How Sound Travels
- Tree falling example: air movement through pushing and vibration
- Sound waves: air molecules bumping into each other, not air traveling
- Ear anatomy: sound funneled through ear canal to eardrum
- Three smallest bones (hammer, anvil, stirrup) amplify vibrations through leverage
- Cochlea (snail shell shaped) converts to electrical impulses for brain interpretation
Physicist vs Psychologist Perspective
- Physicist: air movements = sound
- Psychologist: only sound when interpreted by brain
- Tree falling with no listener: physicist says sound exists, psychologist says it doesn't
- Both correct using same word for different meanings
Sound Wave Properties
- Two key values: amplitude (pressure per peak) and frequency (time between peaks)
Amplitude and Pressure Measurement
- Pressure measured in pascals
- Regular air at sea level: ~100,000 pascals (atmospheric pressure)
- Human ear detection threshold: 20 micropascals
- Sound pressure levels:
- Whisper: 2 millipascals
- Traffic noise: 200 millipascals
- Screaming directly in ear: 20 pascals (hearing loss territory)
Decibel Scale Explanation
- Linear scale impractical due to enormous differences
- Logarithmic scale: each vertical block = 10x previous
- Decibel system: 20 micropascals = 0 bells baseline
- Each 10x pressure increase = 2 bells (20 decibels)
- Multiple decibel scales exist (sound engineers use intensity vs pressure)
Human Sound Perception vs Measurement
- Brain doesn't interpret 10x pressure change as 10x louder
- Traffic noise feels louder than whisper but amplitude is 100x greater
- Logarithmic decibel scale matches human sound perception
Frequency and Human Hearing
- Frequency: peaks per second (Hertz)
- Human range: 20 Hz to 20,000 Hz (decreases with age)
- Most sensitive range: 2,000-5,000 Hz (perceived as louder)
Fletcher-Munson Curve (1933)
- Harvey Fletcher and William Munson research
- Different sounds at different levels, measured perception
- Now called "equal loudness contour"
- Low frequencies need greater amplitude to feel equally loud
LUFS (Loudness Units Full Scale)
- Audio engineering measurement system
- Accounts for equal loudness contour and duration of loud sounds
- Scientific measurement of perceived loudness vs air movement
Broadcasting Standards
- YouTube target: -14 LUFS
- Automatic volume adjustment if content exceeds limit
- European Union: -23 LUFS target for broadcasters (adverts vs programs)
- US: no specific guidelines, rarely enforced matching rule
Movie/TV Audio Strategy
- Can't turn loud sounds above limit for impact
- Must turn dialogue/other sounds down
- Creates contrast for explosive moments
Advertiser Approach
- No need for nuance, want maximum audibility
- Aim for loudest possible throughout duration
Conclusion
- First advert: higher amplitude (more decibels) but didn't feel louder
- Second advert: lower sound pressure but higher perceived loudness
- Modern measurement: LUFS matter more than decibels
