AI summary by TwinMind
Why Bing Isn't a Failure (& the Future of the Internet)
PolyMatter
10m 23s
Bing's Surprising Market Performance
- Despite public perception of failure, Bing captures significant market share
- 33% of US internet searches use Bing
- 26% market share in UK
- 17% market share in Canada
- Generates $5 billion annual revenue through advertising
- Makes actual profit unlike Twitter/Snapchat
- Revenue comparable to YouTube's 2016 performance with no competitors
Microsoft's Strategic Advantage Through Windows Dominance
- 82% of world's computers run Windows OS
- Default settings drive user behavior
- People don't change default browsers/search engines due to ignorance/apathy
- Internet Explorer succeeded despite poor reputation through Windows bundling
- Edge browser follows same strategy
- Small Windows adjustments affect hundreds of millions of devices
Tech Giants' Control Hierarchy Battle
- Apple-Google revenue dynamics
- Google pays Apple $3 billion annually to remain default iOS search engine
- iOS devices (12% of market) generate 75% of Google's mobile ad revenue
- Apple attempted independence with Apple Maps (failed)
- Siri switched from Google to Bing temporarily
- Control hierarchy pyramid structure:
- Bottom: Plugins, extensions, mods, hacks (highest risk)
- Middle: Websites (browser-dependent)
- Apps (OS-dependent)
- Top: Physical devices (ultimate control)
Hardware Control as Ultimate Goal
- Jeff Bezos strategy: Get Amazon devices in users' hands regardless of profit
- Fire phone, Kindle Fire tablets, Echo devices make little/no profit
- Strategic importance outweighs immediate profitability
- Windows Phone persistence explained by control objectives
- Companies like Facebook hate dependency on phone manufacturers
Data Collection and Internet Control
- Higher control position = more data collection capability
- Facebook's "Free Basics" internet initiative (2013)
- Marketed as global internet access charity
- Survey results: 65% Nigerians, 61% Indonesians believe "Facebook is the internet"
- Only provides access to Facebook and select approved websites
- No net neutrality - strategic user acquisition disguised as philanthropy
Google's AMP Technology Control Strategy
- Accelerated Mobile Pages (AMP) positioned as speed improvement
- Reality: Control mechanism over website content
- Google hosts websites, strips "garbage" code
- Requires adding Google tracking code (same "garbage" it removes)
- Websites refusing AMP rank lower in search results
- Forces websites to cede control to Google
Internet Decentralization Threat
- Current internet beauty: No single company controls everything
- Google and Facebook goal: Become the internet, not just dominate it
- Risk to open internet where anyone can learn/create without permission
