AI summary by TwinMind

Why Buffett Bought TSMC

Asianometry

16m 25s

Berkshire Hathaway's TSMC Purchase

  • $4.1 billion investment in Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC)
  • Average purchase price: $68/share as of September 30, 2022
  • Stock jumped 4% day of announcement, continued rising thereafter
  • Now Berkshire's 10th largest position across entire company
  • Uncertainty whether Warren Buffett or portfolio managers Todd Combs/Ted Weschler initiated purchase
    • Combs and Weschler manage ~$34 billion of company money
    • Smaller investments typically attributed to these managers
    • Larger positions require Buffett approval
    • Size suggests Buffett knew and approved

Buffett's Tech Investment Track Record

  • Apple investment (2016): $36 billion initial bet, now worth $137 billion (~$100 billion gain)
    • Started with 5.6% stake
    • World's most profitable tech stock investment
  • IBM investment (2011): Billions invested, took 7 years to fully exit
    • Based on customer acquisition/retention thesis
    • Considered poor investment decision

Berkshire's Investment Model

  • Combines cheap leverage with growth-oriented stock purchases at discount
  • Leverage source: Insurance float (premiums from insurance customers)
    • Premiums only paid back when claims made
    • Company invests float for investment income
    • Annual leverage cost: 1.72% (3% below average US Treasury rate)
  • Target: 10x pre-tax earnings ratio (10% pre-tax return)
  • Strategy: Buy persistent earning streams using cheap leverage
  • Explains massive energy/utilities division for scale

Value vs Growth Investment Philosophy Evolution

  • Traditional "cigar butt" investing: Buy undervalued assets regardless of business quality
    • Low price-to-book ratios
    • One profitable "puff" from cheap purchase
  • Current approach: Large companies with growth potential, temporarily undervalued
  • Charlie Munger (2021): Cigar butt approach wouldn't scale as Berkshire grew
  • Focus shifted to "investment values and great businesses temporarily under pressure"

Apple Case Study Analysis

  • First quarter 2016 purchase metrics:
    • Apple generated $68 billion pre-tax earnings (trailing 12 months)
    • Market cap: ~$600 billion
    • Market value to pre-tax earnings ratio: 8.8x (met 10x threshold)
  • Berkshire managers' screening criteria:
    • How many S&P names trading at 15x earnings in next 12 months?
    • How many earning more in 5 years (90% confidence interval)?
    • How many compound at 7% (50% confidence interval)?
  • Key insight: iPhone ecosystem stickiness created recurring revenue flow
  • Continued adding shares through Q2 2018 (75 million shares pre-split in Q1 2018)
  • Current value: >$137 billion

TSMC Investment Analysis

  • Purchase timing: Q3 2022 at average price $68.56
  • Market cap decline: $729 billion (world's 8th largest company) to $353 billion
  • Financial metrics (trailing 12 months):
    • Pre-tax earnings: ~1 trillion NTD ($32-33 billion USD)
    • Market to pre-tax earnings ratio: 11x (close to 10x target)
  • Stock decline reasons:
    • Geopolitical tensions (Taiwan/China)
    • Macroeconomic concerns in semiconductor industry
    • Higher interest rates affecting stock valuations
    • Government intervention/export bans
    • Chip subsidies and intensifying competition (Samsung, Intel)

TSMC Investment Strengths

  • High margins: 60% gross margin in Q3 2022
  • Strong returns: >40% return on assets and equity
  • Substantial free cash flow (portion reinvested in capex)
  • Maintained growth in 2022 despite challenging conditions
  • Projected 2022 revenue: $76 billion
  • November revenue growth: >50% year-over-year from Apple device chips
  • Revenue model: Take orders, build factory, sell production
  • Revenue-to-capex ratio: ~3x (revenues = 3x prior year capex)
    • 2022: $76B revenue vs $26B 2021 capex = 2.82x
    • 2023 projection: $100B revenue (based on $36B 2022 capex)
  • Technology switching costs: Design-technology co-optimization creates customer lock-in
  • Pricing power: Recently raised prices on core clients (Apple, Qualcomm)
  • Patent portfolio: Top 10 US patent filers, >95% acceptance rate
  • Macro trends: AI, cloud, electric vehicles driving semiconductor demand

Investment Disclaimer & Conclusion

  • Not investment advice - presenter owns only S&P 500 index funds
  • TSMC fits Berkshire's model: Solid tech leader, transparent, underpriced with underappreciated growth
  • Stock has bounced back since Q3 2022
  • Berkshire unlikely to buy more at higher prices
  • Position worth monitoring for future developments

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome