AI summary by TwinMind
Why Buffett Bought TSMC
Asianometry
16m 25s
Berkshire Hathaway's TSMC Purchase
- $4.1 billion investment in Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC)
- Average purchase price: $68/share as of September 30, 2022
- Stock jumped 4% day of announcement, continued rising thereafter
- Now Berkshire's 10th largest position across entire company
- Uncertainty whether Warren Buffett or portfolio managers Todd Combs/Ted Weschler initiated purchase
- Combs and Weschler manage ~$34 billion of company money
- Smaller investments typically attributed to these managers
- Larger positions require Buffett approval
- Size suggests Buffett knew and approved
Buffett's Tech Investment Track Record
- Apple investment (2016): $36 billion initial bet, now worth $137 billion (~$100 billion gain)
- Started with 5.6% stake
- World's most profitable tech stock investment
- IBM investment (2011): Billions invested, took 7 years to fully exit
- Based on customer acquisition/retention thesis
- Considered poor investment decision
Berkshire's Investment Model
- Combines cheap leverage with growth-oriented stock purchases at discount
- Leverage source: Insurance float (premiums from insurance customers)
- Premiums only paid back when claims made
- Company invests float for investment income
- Annual leverage cost: 1.72% (3% below average US Treasury rate)
- Target: 10x pre-tax earnings ratio (10% pre-tax return)
- Strategy: Buy persistent earning streams using cheap leverage
- Explains massive energy/utilities division for scale
Value vs Growth Investment Philosophy Evolution
- Traditional "cigar butt" investing: Buy undervalued assets regardless of business quality
- Low price-to-book ratios
- One profitable "puff" from cheap purchase
- Current approach: Large companies with growth potential, temporarily undervalued
- Charlie Munger (2021): Cigar butt approach wouldn't scale as Berkshire grew
- Focus shifted to "investment values and great businesses temporarily under pressure"
Apple Case Study Analysis
- First quarter 2016 purchase metrics:
- Apple generated $68 billion pre-tax earnings (trailing 12 months)
- Market cap: ~$600 billion
- Market value to pre-tax earnings ratio: 8.8x (met 10x threshold)
- Berkshire managers' screening criteria:
- How many S&P names trading at 15x earnings in next 12 months?
- How many earning more in 5 years (90% confidence interval)?
- How many compound at 7% (50% confidence interval)?
- Key insight: iPhone ecosystem stickiness created recurring revenue flow
- Continued adding shares through Q2 2018 (75 million shares pre-split in Q1 2018)
- Current value: >$137 billion
TSMC Investment Analysis
- Purchase timing: Q3 2022 at average price $68.56
- Market cap decline: $729 billion (world's 8th largest company) to $353 billion
- Financial metrics (trailing 12 months):
- Pre-tax earnings: ~1 trillion NTD ($32-33 billion USD)
- Market to pre-tax earnings ratio: 11x (close to 10x target)
- Stock decline reasons:
- Geopolitical tensions (Taiwan/China)
- Macroeconomic concerns in semiconductor industry
- Higher interest rates affecting stock valuations
- Government intervention/export bans
- Chip subsidies and intensifying competition (Samsung, Intel)
TSMC Investment Strengths
- High margins: 60% gross margin in Q3 2022
- Strong returns: >40% return on assets and equity
- Substantial free cash flow (portion reinvested in capex)
- Maintained growth in 2022 despite challenging conditions
- Projected 2022 revenue: $76 billion
- November revenue growth: >50% year-over-year from Apple device chips
- Revenue model: Take orders, build factory, sell production
- Revenue-to-capex ratio: ~3x (revenues = 3x prior year capex)
- 2022: $76B revenue vs $26B 2021 capex = 2.82x
- 2023 projection: $100B revenue (based on $36B 2022 capex)
- Technology switching costs: Design-technology co-optimization creates customer lock-in
- Pricing power: Recently raised prices on core clients (Apple, Qualcomm)
- Patent portfolio: Top 10 US patent filers, >95% acceptance rate
- Macro trends: AI, cloud, electric vehicles driving semiconductor demand
Investment Disclaimer & Conclusion
- Not investment advice - presenter owns only S&P 500 index funds
- TSMC fits Berkshire's model: Solid tech leader, transparent, underpriced with underappreciated growth
- Stock has bounced back since Q3 2022
- Berkshire unlikely to buy more at higher prices
- Position worth monitoring for future developments
