AI summary by TwinMind
Why Build Higher?
Real Engineering
16m 32s
Historical Context of Building Heights
- Western World considered blasphemous to build higher than church spires for centuries
- Tower of Babel biblical story warned against reaching too close to heavens
- Church spires remained focal point of most western cities for centuries
- Trinity Church was largest building in New York until 1890
- New York World building (1890) marked end of cathedral-dominated skylines
- Joseph Pulitzer expanded business without finding large land on city outskirts
- Growing taller served practical purpose
Space Constraints Drive Building Height
- Demand for space drives up average building height in cities
- Hong Kong example:
- No super tall buildings but among highest average building heights globally
- Confined by sea on one side, Chinese border on other
- Very mountainous landscape limits buildable land
- Forces buildings to grow taller to accommodate population
- Airport expansion required leveling two islands to create artificial island
- Airport project added 1% to total surface area of Hong Kong
Urban Sprawl Problems
- Cities with available space typically expand outwards (urban sprawl)
- Urban sprawl requires little micromanagement - simply expand utilities/roads
- Easy solution but creates many problems, completely unsustainable
- Environmental and social impacts escalate as populations grow
Transportation Issues
- Increasing commute times with larger city diameter
- Difficult to serve suburban neighborhoods with adequate public transport
- Results in car-dependent cities (least efficient transport form)
- Social impacts: long commutes major controllable factor affecting happiness
- Average American spends 17,600 minutes behind wheel annually
- Equivalent to almost 37 extra days at traditional 8-hour job
- Direct impact on pollution and air quality
- Reduces cities' carbon footprint
Water Distribution Problems
- Urban sprawl creates water distribution issues
- Ireland: up to 50% treated water lost through pipe leakage
- 2010: 3.3 billion liters wasted in England and Wales through pipe leakage
- Reducing sprawl reduces pipe length needed, reducing leakage chances
Sustainable Building Design
- Self-sustaining water supplies becoming growing trend
- LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) certification
- Popular green building certification worldwide
- Rates resource efficiency in construction, energy use, water use
- Taipei 101 example:
- Awarded LEED platinum certificate
- Own dedicated water management systems and low-flow fixtures
- Decreased potable water consumption by 30% vs average building
- Saves 28 million liters portable water annually
- America landscape irrigation accounts for nearly 1/3 residential water use
- Totals nearly 9 billion gallons water per day
- More sustainable to have larger percentage LEED certified high-rise residential buildings
Economic Benefits of Building Up
- Urban sprawl requires expensive road/transport infrastructure maintenance (taxpayer funded)
- Building up more costly initially but cost/risk incurred by private contractors
- Cost of building up declines once reaching certain height
- Skyscraper fixed costs (land, legal fees, design) offset by building higher
- Example: 100 square meter plot, 40 stories = 2.5 square meters land per floor
- Design and material costs only increase around 40th floor
- Critical height likely to increase as technology improves
Technological Advances
- Burj Khalifa serves as technology demonstrator despite being wealth display
- Sears Tower (Willis Tower) held tallest record for 25 years
- Used bundled tube structure maximizing floor space
- Scaling to Burj Khalifa size would dominate structural elements, no natural light
- Burj Khalifa's buttress core provides structural integrity while maximizing window access and usable space
- Vital knowledge for allowing building heights to grow while keeping costs down
Regulatory and Planning Obstacles
New York City Zoning Evolution
- Early 20th century: building heights growing, wealthy residents unhappy
- Fifth Avenue filled with stately mansions (Carnegies, Rockefellers)
- Worried about dark canyons overshadowed by towers
- 1916 zoning resolution:
- Allowed height growth but restricted width as buildings grew
- Primary reason NYC buildings from era tapered toward top
- Measure to prevent blocking sunlight below
- Regulation had loopholes, architects exploited them
- 1916-1960: zoning code amended 2,500 times
- 1961 zoning resolution:
- Brought strict rules
- Introduced floor-to-area ratio rule restricting heights by district
- Floor-to-area ratio of 2 = two-story on full plot or four-story on half plot
- R1, R2, R3 districts (Staten Island, Jamaica Estates): 0.5 ratio
- R9, R10 districts (major Manhattan thoroughfares): 7.5 and 10 ratios
- Put pressure on designers for open plazas/public spaces around buildings
- Encouraged privately owned public space to ease density/claustrophobia
Washington DC Height Restrictions
- Height of Buildings Act of 1910: prevents buildings beyond 40 meters
- Incredibly restrictive, resulted in tallest structure being stone obelisk
- Despite small population, worst traffic in US
- INRIX study: Washington residents waste average 75 hours/year in traffic
- Second only to Los Angeles (81 hours/year average)
Case Studies
Los Angeles Urban Sprawl
- Key example of unchecked outward growth problem
- Featured in movie "Her" contrasting car-dominated sprawl with glossy high-rise future
- Film's LA vision: high-rise living/working, walking between buildings, extensive metro system
- Used digitally enhanced skyline mixed with Shanghai Pudong District shots
- Transformative change seems implausible in near future
Paris Transformation History
- Mid-19th century renovation example of city metamorphosis
- Pre-renovation described as "immense workshop of purification"
- "Misery, pestilence, and sickness work in concert"
- "Where sunlight and air rarely penetrate"
- "Of seven small infants, four die during course of year"
- Napoleon III gave money and power to Baron Haussmann
- Transformed narrow streets/dilapidated buildings into spacious boulevards
- Revamped streets, created two new parks
- Transformed Paris into "city of light" visited by 16 million tourists yearly
Modern Paris Housing Crisis
- Lack of central Paris housing caused prices so high only rich can afford
- Forces working-class families to city outskirts
- Creates huge wealth disparity between center and outskirts
- Social housing map shows largest percentages furthest from city center
- Gentrification forcing people further outside city limits
- Notable riots: 1968, 2006, recent year over new labor laws
- Main cause: Parisians' unwillingness to build over existing buildings
- Haussmann's renovation raised height restrictions from 16.5 to 19 meters
- 1965: height restrictions lifted, Montparnasse Tower constructed
- Tower loathed by Parisians, "sticks out like sore thumb"
- Construction resulted in height restrictions reduced to 25 meters for central Paris
- La Défense proves skyscrapers can be incorporated without destroying character
- Europe's largest purpose-built business district
- Houses 180,000 daily workers, only 25,000 permanent residents
- Little motivation to build high-rise for housing prices
Global Implications
- London criticized for same gentrification problems
- No easy way balancing preservation and growth
- Need pressure on leaders to consider solutions beyond cheap/easy routes
- Problems worsen as populations grow
- Great cities not static - constantly change and move with times
- Modern cities like New York and Singapore function because height enables huge numbers on small land
- World needs this approach as populations continue growing
