AI summary by TwinMind
Why China Wants Russia To LOSE Ukraine War
The Infographics Show
14m 41s
Russia's Economic Deterioration During Ukraine War
- Initial sanctions barely impacted economy due to booming energy revenues from Western purchases
- Western price caps now gutting government revenues
- Allows Russia enough leeway to avoid global energy crisis
- Insufficient profit margins for Russia
- Break-even state for Russia's greatest revenue source
- Russia taxes oil income according to Brent crude price rather than own pricing
- Cannibalizing own energy industry to finance war
- Oil sales to India demanded in rupees instead of rubles
- Massive stockpile of Indian rupees with limited international use
- Most nations trade in dollars/euros
- Can't use rupees for needed Indian goods
- Effectively worthless unless rupee becomes global reserve currency
Military Hardware and Weapons Shortages
- Catastrophic shortage of products for advanced weapons manufacturing
- Semiconductor sanctions forcing military to scavenge chips from consumer goods (dishwashers)
- Forced to buy drones from Iran under unfavorable deals
- Extremely reliant on advanced components from around world
- Russian defense industry producing only ~20 tanks per month
- Questionable state of modernity for produced weapons
- Cold War equipment stocks increasingly running out
China's Calculated Support for Russia
- Greatly expanded Russian energy imports post-Western sanctions
- Allows Russia to use Chinese financial institutions for transactions
- US intelligence confirms Chinese defense firms providing vital equipment
- No heavy equipment transfers despite Putin's requests during meetings with Xi Jinping
- Chinese state-owned defense companies shipping:
- Spare parts for combat jets
- Navigation equipment
- March-July 2023: Over $12 million in drones and drone parts
- China claims not selling weapons (technically true)
- Claims dual-use items are "above board" (objectively false per US intelligence)
Energy Trade Dynamics
- China now largest importer of Russian oil (dethroned India March 2023)
- Imports twice the liquefied petroleum gas compared to 2021
- Crude oil imports: ~1.65 million barrels/day
- Western insurance sanctions on Russian oil transport
- Lost access to European tanker fleets and international fleets
- China providing 18 super tankers, insured 16 third-party vessels (2023)
- Shipped 15 million metric tons crude oil
Currency Manipulation and Economic Dependence
- Most Russia-China transactions now conducted in Chinese Yuan
- Russian exports in Yuan: 0.5% pre-war → 14% today
- Chinese Yuan rose to 2.7% of global foreign exchange reserves (2022)
- First time Yuan most used currency in China for cross-border transactions globally
- Russia left with huge Yuan reserves with limited global trade utility
- Forced dependency on Indian rupees and Chinese Yuan
- Only two currencies Russia has in significant reserves
China's Ambiguous Political Support
- Quick to correct "No Limits partnership" statement to avoid offending West
- Tepid support calling for "equitable peace for both sides"
- 12-point peace plan deliberately ambiguous
- Point 1: Observe sovereignty, independence, territorial integrity of all countries
- Unclear if supports returning Ukrainian sovereignty to annexed provinces
- Presented after Russia annexed eastern Ukraine
- China's position "pleasantly ambiguous" to own benefit, Russia's detriment
Historical Context and Territorial Ambitions
- China-Russia relations varied from warm friendship to mutual distrust during Cold War
- China now dwarfs Russia economically, politically, militarily
- Russia's only remaining advantage: nuclear arsenal (efficacy questioned after Ukraine performance)
- China remembers territory stolen by Russian Empire (1858)
- Humiliating treaties forced on Qing Dynasty
- Russian Manchuria includes Amur Oblast, southern half Khabarovsk Krai
- Territory strategically important, rich in energy resources and water
- China experiencing significant droughts, water shortages
Russian Far East Strategic Importance
- Contains massive quantities unexplored/untapped energy resources
- Would dramatically bolster Chinese economy
- Secure overland energy supply route directly to China
- Critical concern: US Navy could blockade 60% of China's seaborne energy imports
- Secure land routes would enable aggressive foreign policy goals (Taiwan invasion)
Demographic and Economic Infiltration
- 2014: Russia's Arctic development plan excluded Chinese involvement
- Russia now dependent on Chinese financing for infrastructure/energy exploration
- Chinese investments in Russian Far East vastly outstrip Russian federal government investments
- Legal/illegal immigration creating increasingly Chinese population
- Feared: 20-30 years more ethnic Chinese than Russians in Russian Far East
- 113 million Chinese in neighboring provinces
- Tensions between local Russians and Chinese populations
Specific Incidents and Tensions
- Deep resentment over Chinese tourists (rude, patronize only Chinese businesses)
- 2019: Fever pitch tensions over Chinese bottling plant on Lake Baikal
- World's deepest lake, 20% global freshwater supply
- Would block local water access, ship water to China
- Russian outrage led to plans deemed illegal in Russian court
- 2023: Beijing approved official maps showing surrendered territory under Chinese control with old Chinese names
China's Ultimate Strategy
- Needs Russia to lose war catastrophically
- Crippling loss would bring political upheaval
- Chaos would allow China to move on Russian Far East
- Consolidate hold before fractured Russian state could react
- Ironically mirrors Russia's justification for Ukraine invasion (protecting ethnic populations)
- China could use same justification in decade or two
- Would be significant setback for liberal world order relying on US Navy control of Chinese trade
