Summary by TwinMind · 44m 44s
Summary by TwinMind · 44m 44s

Why Do Great Flood Myths Seem To Be Universal? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Why Do Great Flood Myths Seem To Be Universal? | STUFF YOU SHOULD KNOW

Stuff You Should Know

Stuff You Should Know

Live Show Announcement

  • Returning to SF Sketchfest at Sydney Goldstein theater
  • Friday January 21st, 7:30 PM in San Francisco
  • First live show in 2 years
  • Full vaccination required + masks
  • Tickets at sfsketchfest.com

Noah's Flood Story Origins

  • Universal flood story known across cultures
  • 1872: George Smith (Assyrian hobbyist) discovered Epic of Gilgamesh
    • Found cuneiform tablet with flood story predating Old Testament by several hundred years
    • God Enlil tells Utnapishtim to build boat (not Noah)
    • Reason: humans too noisy (vs. too wicked in Bible)
    • Similar elements: saving animals, birds sent to find dry land
  • Epic of Gilgamesh written 3,400 years ago
  • Story appears in Jewish Bible, Christian Old Testament, Quran

Historical Attempts to Prove Global Flood

  • Bible literalists sought scientific proof in 18th-19th centuries
  • Deluvialism: geological theory that physical world shaped by great flood
  • Mid-1800s: geological record disproved global flood theory
  • Evidence supports slow geological formation over long time periods

Universal Flood Myths Explanations

  • Study found 50 cultures with flood myths
  • Three main explanations:
    1. Single localized flood spread by migration
      • Proto-Indo-Europeans experienced flood near Caucasus Mountains
      • Group spread across Europe carrying flood story
      • Supporting evidence: no flood myths in sub-Saharan Africa
    2. Multiple localized floods
      • Flooding common throughout history
      • Each culture's "world" was smaller geographic area
      • Local floods interpreted as worldwide destruction
    3. Christian missionary influence
      • Missionaries spread Noah's story during colonization
      • Evidence: South Pacific flood myths changed after 1814 missionary contact
      • Maori myths shifted from tsunami-based to deluge-based stories

Geomythology Field

  • Emerged in 1960s as interdisciplinary approach
  • Trained geologists studying myths for historical natural disaster accounts
  • Combines geological evidence with cultural traditions
  • Challenges traditional dismissal of pre-scientific accounts
  • Works with paleobathimetry and paleo-hydrology

Scientific Evidence for Specific Floods

  • Chinese flood myth (4,000 years ago)
    • 2016 study correlated myth with geological evidence
    • Ancient landslide dammed river, created lake
    • Lake broke through dam after 6 months, caused massive flood
    • Emperor Yu's "water taming" = early engineering/dredging
  • Black Sea flood (7,000 years ago)
    • William Ryan & Walter Pittman theory
    • Mediterranean burst through Bosphorus Strait
    • Waterfall 200x volume of Niagara Falls
    • Water could flood Manhattan to 3,000 feet daily
    • Mediterranean coast moved inland 1 mile per day
    • Wiped out coastal settlements on both sides
  • Persian Gulf formation (7,500 years ago)
    • River valley flooded during ice age end
    • Advanced settlements suddenly appeared on gulf shores
    • Evidence: decorative pottery, stone houses, domesticated animals
    • Original settlements likely submerged (not yet found)
  • Doggerland submersion (8,500 years ago)
    • Land bridge connecting British Isles to Scandinavia
    • Storegga underwater landslide in Norway triggered massive tsunami
    • Submerged settlement traces found under North Sea
    • Brittany flood legend may reference this event
  • Pacific Northwest tsunami (1700 AD)
    • Magnitude 9 earthquake from Vancouver Island to Northern California
    • Ho and Quileute peoples' Thunderbird vs. Whale legend
    • Japanese Buddhist temple recorded tsunami arrival January 6, 1700
    • Geological evidence: trees still not growing back in affected areas

Mythology Patterns and Meanings

  • Common elements across cultures:
    • Man and woman (usually married couple) save animals
    • Divine warning precedes flood
    • Repopulation of Earth afterward
    • Birds sent to find dry land
  • Flood purposes in myths:
    1. Apocalyptic punishment - humans displeased gods
    2. Return to primordial ocean state - reset to original conditions
    3. Purification - rid world of evil, keep only good
    4. Angry gods - divine wrath unrelated to human behavior
    5. Human industriousness - people overcome natural disaster through cooperation

Alternative Psychological Explanations

  • Geza Roheim (1930s Hungarian psychoanalyst): flood myths from dreams caused by drinking water/urinating at night
  • Some myths literally describe gods urinating on Earth
  • Birth envy theories: men's jealousy of childbirth, amniotic sac bursting
  • Modern consensus: geomythology more satisfying than psychoanalytic explanations

Aqua Terra Concept

  • Term coined in 1990s
  • Describes lands exposed for 150,000 years during ice age
  • Human societies developed on these lands
  • Lost 7,000-7,500 years ago when sea levels rose
  • Examples: Doggerland, Persian Gulf valley