AI summary by TwinMind

Why Every 3nm Process Node is Different

Asianometry

14m 4s

TSMC N3 Process Node Variants

  • 2022 Technology Symposium announcement of N3 process node (marketed as 3nm)
  • Multiple N3 variants planned: N3, N3E, N3P, N3X
  • Reflects new reality: no single node does everything
  • Approach: pick and co-develop right node for specific product requirements

Moore's Law Glory Days (1980-2005)

  • 70% shrinkage of chip features every 2 years
  • Simple scaling in both X and Y directions
  • Designers created chips without considering fabrication constraints
  • Foundries handled shrinkage automatically

Lithography Limitations Era (2005+)

  • 2005: foundries hit fundamental limitations
  • 2001: 193nm laser came into production - essentially end of line
  • 157nm lithography failed to take off
  • EUV still years away
  • 130nm node: first to encounter problems
    • High defect rates from inadequate lithography
    • Previously: random/unavoidable defects (particles) were main issue
    • New issue: lithography-related errors gaining ground

Resolution Enhancement Techniques

  • Response to lithography struggles
  • Added tick marks at end of design lines (like serif fonts)
  • Made design lines bigger overall, easier to print
  • Introduced "guard rails" at chip design stage
  • Goals: avoid killer defects, achieve best yields

Power Performance Area (PPA) Metrics

  • Industry yardstick for chip evaluation
  • Power: consumption during usage/idling
  • Performance: maximum attainable frequency
  • Area: silicon area in square millimeters (or gate count)
  • Recent addition: Cost (PPAC metric)
  • Mobile market prioritizes low power usage and smaller areas

Design for Manufacturability (DFM)

  • First design stage guard rails
  • Arrived with 90nm node
  • Derived from resolution enhancement techniques from 130nm generation
  • Primary goal: work around 193nm lithography shortcomings
  • Key issue: corners never truly corners at nanoscale
    • Lithography physically incapable of making true corners
    • Always some curvature interfering with chip design
  • New rule: cannot put corner too close to transistor gate
  • Trade-offs: conservative approach = better yields but unused space/performance hit
  • 90nm node: 4x more design rules than 180nm node (just 2 generations prior)
  • 65nm and beyond: rulebooks kept growing
  • 193i immersion lithography didn't slow rule growth
  • Problems: rules introduced with little warning, one-way road of restrictions

Design Technology Co-Optimization (DTCO)

  • Emerged around 28nm process node
  • Tighter relationship between foundries and chip designers
  • Began with N20, N16, N14 nodes
  • Two key innovations: FinFET transistors and multi-patterning

FinFET Technology

  • 3D transistors replacing planar MOSFETs
  • Planar: gate sits between source and drain (flat structure)
  • FinFET: raises source/drain structure higher (3D fin)
  • Fin dimensions (height, width, length) affect power/performance/area/cost
  • Thinner/higher fins perform better, fit more in space
  • Risk: fin collapse or flop over

DTCO Process

  • Chip designer works directly with foundry process engineers
  • Goal: process node meeting project's PPAC targets
  • Step 1: specify exact parameters (fin thickness, height, distances between fins)
  • Still guided by 70% scaling targets from Moore's Law
  • Trade-offs across all four PPAC metrics
  • Example: low-power mobile chip prioritizes power and area metrics

Standard Cell Library Creation

  • Process engineers craft standard cell libraries from fin specifications
  • Standard cells: standardized groups of gates enabling logical functions (AND, OR, etc.)
  • Lego blocks of chip design, made up of fins
  • Sized with track heights metric
    • Higher track heights: more power, more area
    • Lower track heights: opposite trade-off

Scaling Example (N14 to N10)

  • Goal: 0.47x total area scaling for particular standard cell
  • N10 cell covers 0.47 of N14 cell area
  • Achievement breakdown:
    • Design contribution: 9 tracks to 7.5 tracks = 0.83x area scaling
    • Manufacturing contribution: triple patterning = 0.56x area scaling
    • Combined: 0.56 × 0.83 = 0.47x final goal

DTCO Implementation Characteristics

  • Process starts years before high volume manufacturing
  • Creates very different leading edge process nodes between foundries
  • Requires significant trust between foundries and customers
  • Information sharing: chip designers reveal design intentions, foundries share process complexity
  • Unlike DFM: foundry accepts more process complexity for designer flexibility
  • Bilateral trust and information flow

Future: System Technology Co-Optimization (STCO)

  • IMEC exploring next evolution beyond DTCO
  • Extends AMD's chiplet approach
  • Brings advanced packaging industries into collaboration circle
  • Goal: segregate parts that cannot shrink (I/O, analog components)
  • Uncertain if DTCO will mature into STCO
  • Need to account for previously overlooked functions for more PPAC gains

Industry Integration Trends

  • DTCO resembles old vertically integrated semiconductor makers (IDMs)
  • Past 30 years: academic/business discussion of industry split into two sides
  • Reality: leading edge foundries and designers working closer than ever
  • Contradiction between theory and practice

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome