AI summary by TwinMind
Why everyone hates this concrete building
Vox
8m 2s
Etymology and Origins of Brutalism
- Name derives from French "béton brut" (raw concrete), not brutality
- Timothy Rowan, architectural history professor at UMass Amherst, provides expertise
- UMass Amherst known for brutalist architecture, home to "UMass Brute" campus organization
Key Architectural Pioneers
- Le Corbusier: Swiss-born French architect
- Built Unité d'Habitation apartment building in Marseille
- Left concrete surface raw in groundbreaking fashion
- Previously architects would sand, paint, or clean concrete surfaces
- Other notable brutalist architects: Marcel Breuer, Paul Rudolph, Tadao Ando, Louis Kahn
Brutalist Manifesto and Principles
- Reyner Banham (architecture writer/critic) established three core qualities:
- Memorability as an image
- Clear exhibition of structure
- Valuation of materials as found
- Contrasted with modernist architecture (Ludwig Mies van der Rohe)
- Modernist: sleek glass corporate skyscrapers with curtain walls
- Curtain walls: non-load bearing veneers hiding construction
- Critics called modernist buildings "fishbowls," resembling graph paper
- Brutalism emphasized honesty in materials and structure
Post-WWII Campus Expansion
- College attendance surged after WWII
- Veterans returned with government benefits for education
- Necessitated new university facilities for ballooning admissions
- Major brutalist campus developments:
- Yale: entire brutalist campus sections, received glowing New York Times reviews
- Harvard, UMass Dartmouth, UC San Diego, University of Chicago, Berkeley
- Universities wanted to depart from Gothic/Georgian models
- Previously modeled after Oxford/Cambridge for elite gentlemen
- Now showcasing world-class research university status
- UMass example: expanded from agricultural college to flagship research university
1970s Economic Downturn Impact
- US economy downturn halted new campus construction
- Maintenance of existing facilities neglected
- "Deferred maintenance" policies implemented
- No repairs, gutter cleaning, or air conditioning installation
- Maintenance deferred to future date
1980s Architectural Shift
- New construction era with definite pace change
- Robert Venturi designed university buildings with:
- Brighter colors
- Asymmetrical shapes
- Playful design elements
- Campuses chose demolition over renovation of brutalist buildings
Evans Hall Case Study (UC Berkeley)
- Described as "ugly depressing cross between giant square box and federal penitentiary"
- Campus spokesperson: no approved demolition project currently
- Process: relocating classrooms/offices, constructing new buildings, then proposing demolition
- Seismic rating against earthquakes cited as poor
- 22+ other campus buildings share same seismic rating
- Real considerations: real estate value, premium campus space
- Report criticism: Evans Hall "obstructs views to San Francisco," "incongruous with Beaux-Arts buildings in classical core"
Modern Brutalism Renaissance
- Dr. Rowan conducts brutalist building tours at his university
- Zillow named brutalism top trend to watch in 2024
- Cultural influence examples:
- $1,000 concrete West Elm coffee tables
- Jay-Z and Beyoncé paid $200 million for brutalist-inspired ocean house
- Social media impact: Instagram, Pinterest popularity
- Architecture photographs well, compared to "cats on the internet"
