AI summary by TwinMind
Why Everywhere in the US is Starting to Look the Same
Wendover Productions
20m 9s
Introduction: The Illusion of Plank Road
- Presenter claims to show Plank Road in Fredericksburg, Virginia - typical interstate exit area
- Reveals this was deception - footage actually from Portland Maine, Cookeville Tennessee, Marietta Georgia, El Paso Texas, Los Angeles California
- Interstate exit streets have consistent style across all 50 states
- Americans intuitively navigate these standardized environments (McDonald's, hotels, gas stations)
American Geographic Diversity vs Built Environment Homogeneity
- US has extreme geographic diversity (Utah vs Maine, Florida vs Alaska)
- People live vastly different lives (NYC vs North Dakota)
- Despite natural heterogeneity, built environments are eerily similar
- Anchorage could be Alabama, Columbus could be California
- Outside oldest areas, urban America being built exceptionally homogeneously
Five-Over-One Apartments: The Defining Building Type
- Five-over-ones dominate new urban/suburban development
- Similar appearance with "punchy names" (The Union, Uncommon)
- Building code designation: wooden type 5 fire-resistant building on type 1 concrete base
- Dot edges of downtowns, dominate new developments
- Blocky, unrelenting 90° angles, pushing to sidewalk edges
- Popping up everywhere from Maine to Montana
Building Code Origins of Five-Over-Ones
- US building codes vary by municipality but rarely differ in practice
- Small towns (500 people) lack resources for comprehensive building codes
- Most adopt International Building Code
- Originally limited wood buildings to 3 stories (post-Great Chicago Fire)
- Floor limits eased to 5 over decades
- 1990s codes required non-combustible materials, hampering wood cost advantage
- Key change: exception allowing flame retardant treated wood as "non-combustible"
- LA architect Tim Smith identified potential, built first 5-over-one
Zoning Practices Drive Profitability
- Building codes made structures possible, zoning made them profitable
- ~75% of US residential land zoned for single-family homes
- Western states trend higher due to younger, sprawling urban areas
Fort Collins Case Study
- College town 100,000+ north of Denver
- Perpetual housing need (students, growing population)
- Surrounded by flat, developable plains but no room for dense housing
- Most land zoned for single-family/duplexes
- Downtown already accounted for
- Historic areas protected, off-limits
- Commercial zones compete with businesses for prime real estate
- Result: Five-over-ones cluster in tiny high-density zones around campus
- Pattern not unique to Fort Collins
Housing Market Consolidation
- Of 293,000 large building housing units developed in 2019
- 94,000 (one-third) constructed by country's 25 largest developers
- Vicious cycle: limited multifamily-zoned land → higher prices → fewer developers can afford
- Even fewer can develop profitably given higher purchase prices
- Large developers enjoy economies of scale (shared walls, elevators, mechanicals, management)
Economic Advantages of Five-Over-Ones
- Cheaper per unit than alternatives
- Wood far less expensive than alternate materials
- Easier to work with, reducing labor costs
- Minimizes unionized tradespeople
- Out-compete smaller buildings in market
- Developers grow wealthier, expand across state lines
- Process becomes cheaper through recycled plans, specialized staff movement
- Greystar Real Estate's buildings look similar across time zones
Corporate Landlord Issues
- Five-over-ones almost always rental buildings
- Rarely affordable housing - Denver examples meet/exceed city average rent
- Corner underserved mid-market segment
- Can "get away with a lot" due to market position
- San Francisco example: Greystar $2,800/month one-bedrooms
- Increased rents/fees while cutting staffing/services
- Trash piled in hallways, residents borrowed showers during boiler outages
Current Construction Trends
- 2020 Census: US building more multifamily housing than any point this century
- Building material, style, size characteristics indicate five-over-ones make up vast majority
- Built for those not most acutely feeling housing shortage effects
- Argument: construction frees up units for displaced, but at "less than ideal cost"
Interstate Hotel Standardization
- Interstate exits dominated by Hampton, Holiday Inn, LaQuinta chains
- Rarely independent hotels - always same nationwide brands
- Sleep Inn Chiloquin Oregon identical "down to the inch" to Webster City Missouri
- 1,500 miles/2,500 km separation, exact same hotel
Franchise Business Model
- Sleep Inn owned by Choice Hotels International (7,000 properties globally)
- Company doesn't own hotels, only brands - they're franchiser
- Independent franchisee chooses from menu of brands
- Franchisee selects floor plan, pool inclusion, color scheme (4 options)
- Signs contract with approved contractors
- Franchise model cuts design costs, permitting issues, contractor vetting, management knowledge
- Allows "anyone to become hotelier" - exactly what Choice Hotels wants
- Financial constraint/risk transferred away from parent company
Consumer Preferences Drive Standardization
- Road trippers, pilots (10-hour mandated rest), consultants value consistency over uniqueness
- Uniqueness often has little value, might be negative for weary travelers
- Market research confirms independent hotels can't compete in mid-market
- Independent hotels focus on high-end where hotel is destination, not waypoint
- Cost savings from homogeneity + consumer apathy toward detriments
Franchise Prevalence Statistics
- 57% of US limited service restaurants operate as franchises
- Proportion rises with state poverty rates:
- New York: 31%, Massachusetts: 38%
- West Virginia: 71%, Mississippi: 78%
Global Business District Homogenization
- Four major business districts: Sydney, Santiago, London, Frankfurt
- Without firsthand knowledge, tough to differentiate
- 10 major multinational finance companies location analysis:
- London Canary Wharf: 9 of 10 companies
- Frankfurt Bank district: 8 of 10 companies
- Santiago "Sanhattan": 9 of 10 companies
- Sydney CBD: all 10 companies
- Same companies want same things globally (Sydney, Santiago, London, Frankfurt)
- People move between districts within companies
- Exact same companies signing leases globally
Root Cause: Globalization and Technology
- World encourages sameness regardless of location
- Human wants/needs unchanged from century ago - McDonald's would have succeeded in 1800s
- What changed: technology enabling global operations
- Pre-jet airplanes/internet: impossible to run global restaurant chains
- Local conditions previously dictated possibilities (e.g., can't grow tomatoes in Norway)
- Lacked long-distance cold chain supply lines
- Now: getting tomatoes anywhere, instructing staff globally "hardly a challenge"
Forces Driving Homogenization
- Globalization removed barriers (cargo ships, airplanes, internet cables)
- Forces encouraging difference disappeared
- Remaining forces: economies of scale, consumer preference for consistency, branding effectiveness, capital consolidation
- In world "devoid of walls" - pervasive power of sameness
Benefits of Standardization
- Yielded advances of modern age
- Average person's standard of living never higher
- Example: American Southwest growth enabled by standardized building materials
- Timber prices barely differ between Oregon Lowe's (forest-adjacent) and Arizona Lowe's (desert)
- Environment "devoid of difference" enables five-over-ones in Arizona or Oregon equally
The Problem with Sameness
- Consistency = convenience with cost
- Convenience and cost experienced by different parties
- Hotel example: owners get benefit (profitable business setup), locals bear cost (unique Oregon wilderness becomes "epitome of any Town USA")
- Creeping sameness not one big problem but "series of small problems experienced again and again by everyone"
- Small problems relating to bigger ones still problems
Call for Consideration
- Solutions respond to environments, humans part of urban environments
- If priorities change, environment changes, solutions change
- Few currently concerned (unsurprising in country building cookie-cutter suburbs for decades)
- Don't have to be content with reality just because it's happening
- Consider what common development style does to cities
- Consider whether we want same dining options in every town
- Consider the sameness
