AI summary by TwinMind

Why Everywhere in the US is Starting to Look the Same

Wendover Productions

20m 9s

Introduction: The Illusion of Plank Road

  • Presenter claims to show Plank Road in Fredericksburg, Virginia - typical interstate exit area
  • Reveals this was deception - footage actually from Portland Maine, Cookeville Tennessee, Marietta Georgia, El Paso Texas, Los Angeles California
  • Interstate exit streets have consistent style across all 50 states
  • Americans intuitively navigate these standardized environments (McDonald's, hotels, gas stations)

American Geographic Diversity vs Built Environment Homogeneity

  • US has extreme geographic diversity (Utah vs Maine, Florida vs Alaska)
  • People live vastly different lives (NYC vs North Dakota)
  • Despite natural heterogeneity, built environments are eerily similar
  • Anchorage could be Alabama, Columbus could be California
  • Outside oldest areas, urban America being built exceptionally homogeneously

Five-Over-One Apartments: The Defining Building Type

  • Five-over-ones dominate new urban/suburban development
  • Similar appearance with "punchy names" (The Union, Uncommon)
  • Building code designation: wooden type 5 fire-resistant building on type 1 concrete base
  • Dot edges of downtowns, dominate new developments
  • Blocky, unrelenting 90° angles, pushing to sidewalk edges
  • Popping up everywhere from Maine to Montana

Building Code Origins of Five-Over-Ones

  • US building codes vary by municipality but rarely differ in practice
  • Small towns (500 people) lack resources for comprehensive building codes
  • Most adopt International Building Code
  • Originally limited wood buildings to 3 stories (post-Great Chicago Fire)
  • Floor limits eased to 5 over decades
  • 1990s codes required non-combustible materials, hampering wood cost advantage
  • Key change: exception allowing flame retardant treated wood as "non-combustible"
  • LA architect Tim Smith identified potential, built first 5-over-one

Zoning Practices Drive Profitability

  • Building codes made structures possible, zoning made them profitable
  • ~75% of US residential land zoned for single-family homes
  • Western states trend higher due to younger, sprawling urban areas

Fort Collins Case Study

  • College town 100,000+ north of Denver
  • Perpetual housing need (students, growing population)
  • Surrounded by flat, developable plains but no room for dense housing
  • Most land zoned for single-family/duplexes
  • Downtown already accounted for
  • Historic areas protected, off-limits
  • Commercial zones compete with businesses for prime real estate
  • Result: Five-over-ones cluster in tiny high-density zones around campus
  • Pattern not unique to Fort Collins

Housing Market Consolidation

  • Of 293,000 large building housing units developed in 2019
  • 94,000 (one-third) constructed by country's 25 largest developers
  • Vicious cycle: limited multifamily-zoned land → higher prices → fewer developers can afford
  • Even fewer can develop profitably given higher purchase prices
  • Large developers enjoy economies of scale (shared walls, elevators, mechanicals, management)

Economic Advantages of Five-Over-Ones

  • Cheaper per unit than alternatives
  • Wood far less expensive than alternate materials
  • Easier to work with, reducing labor costs
  • Minimizes unionized tradespeople
  • Out-compete smaller buildings in market
  • Developers grow wealthier, expand across state lines
  • Process becomes cheaper through recycled plans, specialized staff movement
  • Greystar Real Estate's buildings look similar across time zones

Corporate Landlord Issues

  • Five-over-ones almost always rental buildings
  • Rarely affordable housing - Denver examples meet/exceed city average rent
  • Corner underserved mid-market segment
  • Can "get away with a lot" due to market position
  • San Francisco example: Greystar $2,800/month one-bedrooms
    • Increased rents/fees while cutting staffing/services
    • Trash piled in hallways, residents borrowed showers during boiler outages

Current Construction Trends

  • 2020 Census: US building more multifamily housing than any point this century
  • Building material, style, size characteristics indicate five-over-ones make up vast majority
  • Built for those not most acutely feeling housing shortage effects
  • Argument: construction frees up units for displaced, but at "less than ideal cost"

Interstate Hotel Standardization

  • Interstate exits dominated by Hampton, Holiday Inn, LaQuinta chains
  • Rarely independent hotels - always same nationwide brands
  • Sleep Inn Chiloquin Oregon identical "down to the inch" to Webster City Missouri
  • 1,500 miles/2,500 km separation, exact same hotel

Franchise Business Model

  • Sleep Inn owned by Choice Hotels International (7,000 properties globally)
  • Company doesn't own hotels, only brands - they're franchiser
  • Independent franchisee chooses from menu of brands
  • Franchisee selects floor plan, pool inclusion, color scheme (4 options)
  • Signs contract with approved contractors
  • Franchise model cuts design costs, permitting issues, contractor vetting, management knowledge
  • Allows "anyone to become hotelier" - exactly what Choice Hotels wants
  • Financial constraint/risk transferred away from parent company

Consumer Preferences Drive Standardization

  • Road trippers, pilots (10-hour mandated rest), consultants value consistency over uniqueness
  • Uniqueness often has little value, might be negative for weary travelers
  • Market research confirms independent hotels can't compete in mid-market
  • Independent hotels focus on high-end where hotel is destination, not waypoint
  • Cost savings from homogeneity + consumer apathy toward detriments

Franchise Prevalence Statistics

  • 57% of US limited service restaurants operate as franchises
  • Proportion rises with state poverty rates:
    • New York: 31%, Massachusetts: 38%
    • West Virginia: 71%, Mississippi: 78%

Global Business District Homogenization

  • Four major business districts: Sydney, Santiago, London, Frankfurt
  • Without firsthand knowledge, tough to differentiate
  • 10 major multinational finance companies location analysis:
    • London Canary Wharf: 9 of 10 companies
    • Frankfurt Bank district: 8 of 10 companies
    • Santiago "Sanhattan": 9 of 10 companies
    • Sydney CBD: all 10 companies
  • Same companies want same things globally (Sydney, Santiago, London, Frankfurt)
  • People move between districts within companies
  • Exact same companies signing leases globally

Root Cause: Globalization and Technology

  • World encourages sameness regardless of location
  • Human wants/needs unchanged from century ago - McDonald's would have succeeded in 1800s
  • What changed: technology enabling global operations
  • Pre-jet airplanes/internet: impossible to run global restaurant chains
  • Local conditions previously dictated possibilities (e.g., can't grow tomatoes in Norway)
  • Lacked long-distance cold chain supply lines
  • Now: getting tomatoes anywhere, instructing staff globally "hardly a challenge"

Forces Driving Homogenization

  • Globalization removed barriers (cargo ships, airplanes, internet cables)
  • Forces encouraging difference disappeared
  • Remaining forces: economies of scale, consumer preference for consistency, branding effectiveness, capital consolidation
  • In world "devoid of walls" - pervasive power of sameness

Benefits of Standardization

  • Yielded advances of modern age
  • Average person's standard of living never higher
  • Example: American Southwest growth enabled by standardized building materials
  • Timber prices barely differ between Oregon Lowe's (forest-adjacent) and Arizona Lowe's (desert)
  • Environment "devoid of difference" enables five-over-ones in Arizona or Oregon equally

The Problem with Sameness

  • Consistency = convenience with cost
  • Convenience and cost experienced by different parties
  • Hotel example: owners get benefit (profitable business setup), locals bear cost (unique Oregon wilderness becomes "epitome of any Town USA")
  • Creeping sameness not one big problem but "series of small problems experienced again and again by everyone"
  • Small problems relating to bigger ones still problems

Call for Consideration

  • Solutions respond to environments, humans part of urban environments
  • If priorities change, environment changes, solutions change
  • Few currently concerned (unsurprising in country building cookie-cutter suburbs for decades)
  • Don't have to be content with reality just because it's happening
  • Consider what common development style does to cities
  • Consider whether we want same dining options in every town
  • Consider the sameness

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome