AI summary by TwinMind
Why Google Maps Is Different Depending on Your Location
neo
9m 2s
Introduction to Mapping Subjectivity
- Question of what to believe can be arbitrary despite gut feelings
- Difficulty explaining reasoning for believability
- Maps appear objective but contain subjective decisions
Sea of Japan vs East Sea Dispute
- Google Maps shows "Sea of Japan" internationally, "East Sea" within South Korea
- Same body of water, different names based on browsing location
- 2-decade dispute between Japan and South Korea
- South Korean naming convention: West Sea, South Sea, East Sea around their country
- Japanese traditional name: Sea of Japan (more internationally accepted)
- South Korean argument: Name pushed during Japanese occupation when Korea couldn't dispute internationally
- Japanese argument: Name used long before occupation, historically internationally recognized
Cartographic Solutions to Naming Disputes
- Traditional photographer approaches for centuries:
- Choose one name
- Print both versions as equal alternatives
- Show main accepted name with alternative
- Leave disputed area blank
- Google's approach: Show different maps to different people (only possible for online services)
Persian Gulf vs Arabian Gulf Dispute
- International Google Maps: "Persian Gulf" with "Arabian Gulf" when zoomed in
- Arab countries pushed "Arabian Gulf" name since 1960s during Arab nationalism rise
- Google in Arab countries: Shows only "Arabian Gulf"
- Iran's position: Consistently called "Persian Gulf" throughout history
- Cultural and political significance between Iran and Saudi Arabia (both claiming regional leadership)
Legal Regulations on Maps
- Many countries have laws against publishing maps contradicting official government maps
- Google's choice: Adapt to laws or not offer Google Maps in those countries
- Maps politically significant - can confirm or question geographical claims
China-India Border Disputes
- Arunachal Pradesh dispute:
- India designates and governs area as Indian state
- Indian domain Google Maps: Shows as Indian state
- China calls area "South Tibet"
- Chinese Google users: See area as part of China
- Neither country shows border conflict to users
- Outside both nations: Dotted border lines indicate controversy
- Kashmir dispute:
- Claimed by India, China, and Pakistan
- Google in China and India: Shows respective government official maps
- Continuous border lines conceal dispute, make borderland seem internationally recognized
Google's Business Considerations
- Must obey country laws while not angering customers
- Leaving growth markets like China or India would be huge economic disadvantage
Google's China Situation
- Surprising Google offers maps in China given long disagreement with authorities
- 2010: Google relocated services from mainland China to Hong Kong to avoid Chinese firewall censorship requirements
- Google became insignificant in China but still offers map service
- Google Maps in China corresponds with official government viewpoint
South China Sea Disputes
- Google Maps in China shows "ten dash line" from 1947 Chinese map
- Used by China to justify claims on South China Sea islands
- Area disputed by many countries
- Conflicts caused by: Rich fishing grounds, sea resources, military importance of controlling area
Crimean Peninsula Dispute
- Disputed between Ukraine and Russia since 2014 conflict
- Controversial referendum led Russia to regard Crimea as territory
- International community considers this violation of international law
- International Google version: Dotted line
- Ukrainian version: No immediate line shown, only when zooming in closer
- Russian Google Maps: Shows Crimea as part of Russia
Google's Dilemma
- Difficult position where no approach avoids offending somebody
- Power Google doesn't want but must deal with responsibilities
- Drawing straight borders in disputed areas creates facts with strong real-world impact
Wikipedia's Approach
- Collaborative Wikipedia project struggles with neutral border conflict portrayal
- Long-lasting discussions between editors on correct dispute handling
- Crimean conflict example:
- Russian language Wikipedia: Shows as Russian territory
- Ukrainian language Wikipedia: Claims as part of Ukraine
- Both countries have information about dispute available
- Border rendering changes over time
- Wikipedia not blocked in either country
Wikipedia's Censorship Resistance
- Shows disputes even at risk of being blocked
- Switched web protocol to encrypted version
- Previously: Countries could censor individual articles (sexually explicit content in Turkey, marijuana article in Russia)
- Now: Countries can only block Wikipedia entirely, not single articles
- Wikipedia currently blocked in China
Conclusion and Critical Viewing
- Google has enormous power and responsibility as main online maps player
- Google's map becomes what many people believe
- Maps should always be viewed critically, not just Google
- Important to recognize seemingly objective truths may be subjective
- Every map (including Google Maps) has an approach
- Doesn't mean maps are bad, just should be viewed critically
- Map maker decisions affect our world view daily
