AI summary by TwinMind

why I took down my climate science video

Sabine Hossenfelder

12m 29s

Initial Video Publication and Takedown

  • Published strongly worded video about climate science study on LA wildfires
  • Video disappeared day later, also deleted X/Twitter post
  • Took down video after 12 hours when someone claimed misreading of statistical results
  • Set video private to avoid spreading misinformation on policy-relevant topic affecting millions

World Weather Attribution Study Critique

  • Study examined LA wildfires from January with press release claiming:
    • "Human induced warming from burning fossil fuels made Peak January fire weather index 30% more probable"
    • "High confidence that human induced climate change primarily driven by burning fossil fuels increased likelihood of devastating LA wildfires"
  • Author's analysis showed results were statistically insignificant
  • Results compatible with climate change having no effect on LA wildfires
  • Study online for month, no other climate scientists noticed statistical insignificance

Climate Science Community Criticism

  • Many climate scientists know World Weather Attribution Center studies are "sketchy" but stay silent
  • Silent because speaking up would be "politically inconvenient"
  • Pattern similar to foundations of physics destroying research area reputation
  • Scientists look away from "crap going around in media" thinking "all attention better than no attention"
  • Reason for author's distrust of scientists despite appearances

Extreme Event Attribution Methodology Problems

  • Run climate models twice: once without global warming, once with current level
  • Count similar events to target (LA wildfires), compare probabilities
  • Major issues:
    • Many climate models don't correctly predict extreme events initially
    • Throw out most models (poor procedure)
    • Results depend on exact definition of extreme event
    • Too many details = never shows up in simulation (comparing zero to zero)
  • Calculate probability ratio: >1 = more likely, <1 = less likely

Statistical Analysis Confusion

  • Results table showed mean value 35% higher probability (1.35 ratio)
  • 95% confidence interval included 1.0 (no effect)
  • Author interpreted as not statistically significant
  • Paper doesn't explain what they mean by statistical significance
  • Standard: 95% confidence interval for significance (some areas require 99% or 99.999%)

Color Coding and Table Legend Problems

  • Table caption claims all changes are increases
  • Says decreases marked orange, increases marked blue
  • Author questions if colors were mixed up
  • Caption distinguishes light orange (non-significant) vs dark orange (significant)
  • Multiple orange shades used inconsistently across tables
  • Completely messed up table legends and color codes

Verification Process

  • Double-checked with climate scientist who agreed (not statistically significant)
  • Fed entire report to ChatGPT and Grok - both agreed not statistically significant
  • Colleague emailed lead author after 3 days
  • Received out-of-office reply, then response from co-author confirming:
    • "Changes in intensity and likelihood are unsurprisingly not statistically significant"
    • Light orange designation confirmed

Study Quality Assessment

  • Rapid attribution study (not peer-reviewed)
  • Not stated in press release
  • Author considers study "so bad" with "sincere doubts even authors read it"
  • Worse quality than initially thought after closer examination

Broader Context and Clarifications

  • Climate change may have made wildfires more likely in some world regions
  • LA wildfires specifically - this analysis tells nothing about climate influence
  • Multiple research groups work on extreme event attribution
  • Various methods available, some better/worse than others
  • Not all extreme event attribution research is unreliable
  • Some research "isn't crap" but author's opinion of climate scientists damaged

YouTube Algorithm Impact

  • Taking video down temporarily "nukes YouTube recommendations"
  • Algorithm treats private video as underperforming
  • Stops recommending video after republishing
  • Requests viewers click and let video run to help algorithm recovery

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome