Summary by TwinMind · 22m 23s
Summary by TwinMind · 22m 23s

Why Iraq is Dying

Why Iraq is Dying

RealLifeLore

RealLifeLore

Iraq's Economic Disparity

  • Iraq GDP per capita: ~$4,000 (comparable to Guatemala/Namibia)
  • Regional comparison: Saudi Arabia $20,000+, Bahrain $23,000+, Kuwait $32,000+, UAE $43,000+, Qatar $50,000+
  • Past 40 years: only 13 years peace, 28 years war/conflict
  • Military invaded Iran and Kuwait, threatened Turkey and Syria
  • Occupied by US superpower

Historical Geographic Foundation

  • Human civilization began in present-day Iraq between Tigris and Euphrates rivers
  • Surrounded by Arabian and Syrian deserts (largest Asian deserts)
  • Fertile oasis between rivers historically richest farmland globally
  • Southeast marshes: largest wetland in western Eurasia (Connecticut-sized)
  • Genesis point for agriculture age
  • Epicenter of global human population for centuries

Geographic Vulnerabilities

  • Water most precious resource - without it, worthless desert
  • Canal systems necessary for irrigation
  • Fragile balance between population and environment
  • Open plain vulnerable to invasions from northern/eastern mountains
  • Destruction of water infrastructure leads to population collapse
  • Climate change threatens delicate balance

British Colonial Border Creation (1913-1932)

  • Pre-WWI: Iraq including Kuwait part of Ottoman Empire
  • 1913: Kuwait part of Basra province in Ottoman Iraq
  • British agreement with local family created de facto protectorate
  • WWI: British declared Kuwait independent protectorate, occupied rest of Iraq
  • Post-war: British separated Iraq and Kuwait
  • Iraq left with mere 58km coastline, mostly marshes/swamps
  • Almost no deep water ports - mostly landlocked
  • King Feisal I protested absurd borders but ignored
  • 1923: Border recognized, ratified again 1932 upon Iraqi independence
  • Decades of Iraqi claims Kuwait rightfully theirs
  • 1990: Saddam's casus belli for Kuwait invasion

Maritime Vulnerabilities

  • Single deep sea port: Umm Qasr (downstream from Basra)
  • Only location for modern oil tankers
  • Capturing Umm Qasr shuts down 100% maritime trade
  • Strait of Hormuz: only Persian Gulf exit to world ocean
  • Blocking either point destroys entire maritime economy

Oil Resources and Curse

  • World's 5th largest oil reserves
  • World's 5th largest oil producer
  • Oil unevenly distributed among demographics
  • Shia Arab (southeast) and Sunni Kurdish (north) areas have vast reserves
  • Sunni Arab lands have very little oil
  • Uneven wealth distribution exacerbates ethnic/religious differences
  • Two-thirds of economy exclusively oil industry
  • External powers (Saudi Arabia, Russia, Kuwait) can crash economy via overproduction
  • Kuwait overproduction factor in 1990 invasion

Export Infrastructure Weaknesses

  • One pipeline from northern fields to Turkish Mediterranean port
  • Pipeline in Kurdish territories with massive autonomy from Baghdad
  • Western half sparsely inhabited desert
  • Limited trucking: only 2 highways to Saudi Arabia, 1 to Jordan
  • Maritime shipping easily blockaded
  • Decades of warfare left oil infrastructure in disrepair

Water Crisis - Greatest Weakness

  • 90% Euphrates flow originates in Turkey
  • 10% added in Syria
  • 0% contributed by Iraq
  • Multiple Tigris tributaries begin in Iran
  • 80%+ of Iraq's freshwater controlled by Turkey, Syria, Iran
  • All three neighbors building dams to hoard water

Turkish Dam Projects

  • 1960s-70s: Southern Anatolia Project
  • 14 dams across Euphrates basin
  • 8 additional dams across Tigris
  • Atatürk Dam: 5th largest dam worldwide (completed 1990)
  • Turks withheld entire Euphrates flow for 1 month to fill reservoir
  • Atatürk Dam alone reduced downstream flow by 1/3
  • All Turkish/Syrian dams mean only 1/4 historical flow reaches Iraq
  • Turkish dams defended by anti-air missile batteries

Water Consequences

  • Insufficient water for 40+ million population
  • Insufficient irrigation for farms
  • Low flow = increased pollution (sewage/garbage not flushed to gulf)
  • Climate change: hotter temperatures, faster evaporation
  • Historically dangerous problem for Iraq

Mosul Dam Crisis

  • Iraq's largest dam on Tigris upstream from Mosul (1.7M residents)
  • Built on gypsum (soft mineral dissolving in water contact)
  • Requires constant maintenance army to prevent collapse
  • 2006 US Army Corps report: collapse would kill 500,000 Iraqis
  • Labeled "most dangerous dam in world"
  • Badush Dam (fail-safe) construction began 1988, never finished due to Gulf War
  • 2014: ISIS seized dam, halted maintenance
  • 2016: US warnings of imminent collapse, evacuation urged
  • Iraqi forces recaptured, maintenance resumed

Geographic Catastrophic Failure Points

  • Maritime trade blocked by single area mining or city capture
  • Land highways easily shut down/bombed
  • External oil powers can crash economy via overproduction
  • Oil distributed unevenly fueling internal instability
  • Single missile at Mosul Dam = biblical scale floods
  • Three neighbors can shut off water supply instantly
  • Climate change worsening all factors

Saddam's Conflicts (1979-2003)

  • 1979: Saddam seized power
  • Iran-Iraq War: 8-year WWI-resembling conflict
  • 1990: Kuwait invasion bringing world coalition
  • Internal campaigns against rebels
  • 2003: US/UK invasion, Saddam overthrown
  • 25 years rule, 4 disastrous conflicts