AI summary by TwinMind

Why Is China Appointing Judges to Combat Climate Change? | James K. Thornton | TED Countdown

TED

11m 40s

Initial Engagement with Chinese Officials (2014)

  • Speaker invited to Brussels to meet Chinese officials seeking to encourage environmental groups in China
  • Subsequent invitation to Beijing by Supreme People's Court
  • Judges working on regulations for new law allowing Chinese environmental NGOs to sue polluting companies
    • Including state-owned companies
  • Officials interested in speaker's extensive environmental litigation experience in Europe and America

Supreme Court Collaboration and Law Development

  • Meeting in Beijing conference room with 3 Supreme Court justices, Ministry of Environment officials, and People's Congress members
  • Speaker called the law "revolutionary" - senior judge preferred "sea change"
  • 3-month collaboration designing recommendations for citizen law enforcement
  • Key provision on costs:
    • Winning environmental groups get all costs paid by polluters
    • Losing groups don't pay polluters' costs
    • Rationale: groups assert public interest win or lose

Law Implementation and System Changes

  • Follow-up meeting in Supreme Court building off Tiananmen Square
  • White marble table "40 feet long" meeting with 3 Supreme Court judges and EU-China Environment Programme head
  • Chinese accepted almost all recommendations, including key cost provision
  • Result: Chinese system became friendlier to citizen environmental groups than many countries

Judge Training Program

  • China appointed 1,000 environment court judges (specialists rare globally - only handful in Scandinavia)
  • Strategy: specialist judges to hear vast volume of cases, raise environmental rule of law quality quickly
  • Speaker agreed to train judges despite no prior experience
  • Started with Supreme Court climate litigation seminar
  • Chinese goal: "decide some of the best climate change cases here in China"
  • Partnered with EU-China Environment Programme to create ClientEarth Beijing office
  • Trained over 1,500 judges to date

Prosecutor Training Initiative

  • Year after judge training began, prosecutors requested training
  • New law gave prosecutors right to sue Chinese government for environmental matters
    • First time prosecutors could sue government
  • ClientEarth trained Chinese federal prosecutors to sue Chinese government
  • Trained over 1,200 prosecutors in environmental cases

Enforcement Results and Impact

  • Hand-delivered thank-you letter from prosecutors to Beijing office
  • 2020 results: over 80,000 environmental cases brought
  • Majority of cases against government departments
  • Prosecutors established bureaus nationwide to maintain case volume and raise compliance standards

Coal and Financial Institution Work

  • China burns more coal than any other country
  • Multi-year work with largest Chinese banks and financial institutions
  • Argument: coal is bad investment
  • Two-day Beijing seminar showed institutions internalized this argument
  • Government audit found many new coal-fired power stations illegally authorized by provincial officials
    • Officials wanted to boost balance sheets
    • Illegal authorization creates perfect enforcement targets

International Coal Commitments

  • Problem: Chinese companies planning coal-fired power stations in Belt and Road countries
  • Work with Ministry of Environment to stop pipeline projects
  • September 2021: President Xi Jinping announced at UN General Assembly
    • China will not fund or build more coal-fired power stations outside China
  • Belief China's emissions will peak soon and decline before 2030

Systemic Change Assessment

  • More work needed in China (and all countries) - faster pace required
  • Systemic changes observed:
    • Environment court judges
    • Tens of thousands of cases (many against government departments)
    • Enhanced Ministry of Environment powers
    • Banks/financial institutions recognizing coal as bad investment
    • Presidential commitment on international coal
  • Speaker's assessment: never seen such intense focus on systemic environmental change in any country

TwinMind

Get summaries like this for your own meetings

TwinMind takes notes in the background during meetings, lectures, and calls, then writes the summary for you.

Free plan to get started

No bot joins your calls

Phone, desktop & Chrome apps

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome

Your next meeting, summarized like this

TwinMind listens in the background and turns meetings, lectures, and calls into searchable notes you can chat with. Start free.

Available on phone, desktop & Chrome