AI summary by TwinMind
Why Is China Appointing Judges to Combat Climate Change? | James K. Thornton | TED Countdown
TED
11m 40s
Initial Engagement with Chinese Officials (2014)
- Speaker invited to Brussels to meet Chinese officials seeking to encourage environmental groups in China
- Subsequent invitation to Beijing by Supreme People's Court
- Judges working on regulations for new law allowing Chinese environmental NGOs to sue polluting companies
- Including state-owned companies
- Officials interested in speaker's extensive environmental litigation experience in Europe and America
Supreme Court Collaboration and Law Development
- Meeting in Beijing conference room with 3 Supreme Court justices, Ministry of Environment officials, and People's Congress members
- Speaker called the law "revolutionary" - senior judge preferred "sea change"
- 3-month collaboration designing recommendations for citizen law enforcement
- Key provision on costs:
- Winning environmental groups get all costs paid by polluters
- Losing groups don't pay polluters' costs
- Rationale: groups assert public interest win or lose
Law Implementation and System Changes
- Follow-up meeting in Supreme Court building off Tiananmen Square
- White marble table "40 feet long" meeting with 3 Supreme Court judges and EU-China Environment Programme head
- Chinese accepted almost all recommendations, including key cost provision
- Result: Chinese system became friendlier to citizen environmental groups than many countries
Judge Training Program
- China appointed 1,000 environment court judges (specialists rare globally - only handful in Scandinavia)
- Strategy: specialist judges to hear vast volume of cases, raise environmental rule of law quality quickly
- Speaker agreed to train judges despite no prior experience
- Started with Supreme Court climate litigation seminar
- Chinese goal: "decide some of the best climate change cases here in China"
- Partnered with EU-China Environment Programme to create ClientEarth Beijing office
- Trained over 1,500 judges to date
Prosecutor Training Initiative
- Year after judge training began, prosecutors requested training
- New law gave prosecutors right to sue Chinese government for environmental matters
- First time prosecutors could sue government
- ClientEarth trained Chinese federal prosecutors to sue Chinese government
- Trained over 1,200 prosecutors in environmental cases
Enforcement Results and Impact
- Hand-delivered thank-you letter from prosecutors to Beijing office
- 2020 results: over 80,000 environmental cases brought
- Majority of cases against government departments
- Prosecutors established bureaus nationwide to maintain case volume and raise compliance standards
Coal and Financial Institution Work
- China burns more coal than any other country
- Multi-year work with largest Chinese banks and financial institutions
- Argument: coal is bad investment
- Two-day Beijing seminar showed institutions internalized this argument
- Government audit found many new coal-fired power stations illegally authorized by provincial officials
- Officials wanted to boost balance sheets
- Illegal authorization creates perfect enforcement targets
International Coal Commitments
- Problem: Chinese companies planning coal-fired power stations in Belt and Road countries
- Work with Ministry of Environment to stop pipeline projects
- September 2021: President Xi Jinping announced at UN General Assembly
- China will not fund or build more coal-fired power stations outside China
- Belief China's emissions will peak soon and decline before 2030
Systemic Change Assessment
- More work needed in China (and all countries) - faster pace required
- Systemic changes observed:
- Environment court judges
- Tens of thousands of cases (many against government departments)
- Enhanced Ministry of Environment powers
- Banks/financial institutions recognizing coal as bad investment
- Presidential commitment on international coal
- Speaker's assessment: never seen such intense focus on systemic environmental change in any country
